N.J. Senator Accused Of Kickbacks

Taped Phone Calls Could Damage Menendez's Campaign

(AP)  A childhood friend and close political adviser of Democratic Sen. Robert Menendez allegedly used the senator's name to pressure a psychiatrist to hire a doctor for local government work, according to a transcript of the telephone call, part of which is mentioned in federal court documents.

The doctor Menendez allegedly wanted hired believed some of the money from the government contract would be kicked back to Menendez, who was a congressman at the time, according to court documents.

Menendez campaign spokesman Matthew Miller called the kickback allegations "completely false."

As allegations of ethical wrongdoing against the man he selected to be U.S. senator persist, Gov. Jon S. Corzine on Friday endorsed Robert Menendez's campaign while Republicans continued trying to convince voters Democrats will change candidates.

"Bob Menendez was Governor Corzine's choice to replace him in the Senate in January," Corzine spokesman Anthony Coley said. "He is Governor Corzine's choice today and he will remain the governor's choice through the election."

The transcript of the 1999 conversation, obtained Thursday by The Associated Press, depicts an expletive- and chuckle-laden chat between Donald Scarinci, Menendez's friend and adviser, and Oscar Sandoval, a psychiatrist who taped the exchange as part of his work as an FBI informant in a criminal investigation of several northern New Jersey politicians.

In the conversation, Scarinci asks Sandoval to rehire a doctor, Dr. Vicente Ruiz, whom he fired the year before. At the time of the conversation, Sandoval had contracts with the Hudson County Jail and a county hospital.

The revelation of the conversation — reported by several newspapers Thursday, including The Philadelphia Inquirer, which obtained a copy of the tape — and details of the court filings were the latest in the ethics barrage hitting Menendez as his campaign enters its final months. Menendez, a longtime Democratic congressman appointed to the Senate when Jon Corzine took office as governor, is locked in a tight race with Republican state Sen. Tom Kean Jr.

In the transcript, Scarinci is quoted as saying, "If you can deal with Dr. Ruiz and make him happy, Menendez will consider that a favor. If you can't, then that's OK ... you can't."

Scarinci later says hiring Ruiz would give Sandoval "protection" but does not say what that meant. In court documents filed in March, Sandoval said "protection" meant that he would keep his government contracts.

The documents also state Sandoval was told by Ruiz he would have to divide his contract earnings between himself, Ruiz, Scarinci and Menendez. Sandoval had fired Ruiz in 1998, according to the documents, which give no reason for the dismissal.

Ruiz was not able to be reached for comment Thursday. He was rehired by Sandoval following the 1999 conversation and the court documents, filed as part of an ongoing civil lawsuit involving government corruption, indicate that Menendez was in on the talks.

"After this Dr. Ruiz, Scarinci and Dr. Sandoval met at Scarinci's office with the purpose of working together at which time now U.S. senator then U.S. Congressman Menendez came into the meeting and stated that he was glad we could work out our difference (sic) and could work together," one document states.

Ruiz in 1998 served as a physician with the North Hudson Community Action Corp. The U.S. attorney's office has issued a subpoena seeking records from the nonprofit agency related to a lease agreement it had with Menendez, who rented a house he owned in Union City to the group, and also helped the organization obtain federal funds.

[cbs_oliver]

Your article says, "The doctor Menendez allegedly wanted hired believed some of the money from the government contract would be kicked back to Menendez, who was a congressman at the time, according to court documents."

I am at a loss to identify who is making the allegation described.

You should clarify that.

Without such clarification there is a real possibility that the allegation comes from Menendez's opponent Tom Kean Jr. and that CBS is providing cover for Mr. Kean or his campaign by not identifying the source of the allegation explicitely.

Readers are also being led to believe that their is a legal charge ("allegation") when there isn't.

This reads like a political slime job rather than a news story. You should be ashamed.

[libsarenuts]

That's right. The allegations about Menendez must be right wing attack on an innocent man.
CBS actually reporting on this is the real story.

[cbs_oliver]

So far as I know there are no charges against Menendez just against someone who worked for him and that person was asked to leave the campaign.

It is important for journalists who use the word "allegation" to clearly identify the exact nature of the allegation and who has made it. It is not right to give cover to those who make claims about other people.

[jumkey]

Yeah I agree janem4, this is shocking given that the Republicans have always been the party or corruption.

Good thing is the Dems will take care of the problem while the Republicans would simply ignore it.

[drgoodwin12]

If he is guilty of kickbacks the article does not claim that, the individual who is making the accusations does then he should be sent to prison.I am a Democrat and I do not like political corruption in either parties.But to all those who have already declared him guilty have they thought the public has forgotten Cunningham,Ney,Reed,Delay and Abrahoff.Do no forget about Foley which is a much more heinous crime.And lets not forget Nixon,Agnew and pretty soon you will be able to add Bush,Cheney,Rumsfield and Rice to the list. Last time I checked Laura Bush is not rebuking Woodward just her office.Has any of the people Woodward mention rebuked him? No.The NIE report that recently came out and the one in 2002 only help confirm Woodwards book.Also a friend of mine has two sons serving in Iraq and they both corroborate what Woodward is saying about the amount of attacks on U.S. troops.

Unfortunately "the buck stops here". He's ultimately responsible for whatever goes on in his administration. The truth will eventually come out, whether he was directly involved or not.

www.politipoll.net

[sanfelz]

The source of the kickback claims is a jailed political rival of Menedez, former county executive Bob Janiszewski. Janiszewski and Sandoval are both criminal who have personal reasons to smear Menendez through Republican mud-slinger Chris Lyon. Lyon works for the Kean campaign. Kean must use such tactics because he is an empty suit who must rely on his father's good name and wealth to catapult him to the Senate. Kean Jr.'s positions are not supported in NJ, so he must divert attention through skullduggery.