Sept. 28, 2006
We Are Not The Cause
NRO: When Will Americans Stop Blaming Themselves?
-
Play CBS Video Video Pope Meets With Muslim Leaders The Pope met with Muslim leaders at his summer residence in an effort to soothe tensions over his recent speech on Islam. But as Charlie D'Agata reports, he did not directly discuss those remarks.
-
(AP)
-
Interactive The Fundamentals Of Islam Learn about the Muslim religion and find out where the largest Muslim populations live in the U.S. and around the world.
-
Interactive Religion In Iraq An interactive guide to Iraq's religious, ethnic and ideological mix.
-
Special Report War On Terror Complete coverage of the military's battle against terrorism.
According to a National Intelligence Estimate composed last February but released just this week by the Bush administration, "The Iraq conflict has become the 'cause celebre' for jihadists, breeding a deep resentment of U.S. involvement in the Muslim world and cultivating supporters for the global jihadist movement." Because of the war, "new jihadist networks and cells, with anti-American agendas, are increasingly likely to emerge." On the other hand, the report finds that if the "jihadists leaving Iraq perceive themselves, and [are] perceived, to have failed . . . fewer fighters will be inspired to carry on the fight."
None of this is conclusive, or even news, but the NIE's suggestion that the war in Iraq has become a recruitment tool for Islamic terrorists was immediately seized upon by Democrats to argue, yet again, that President Bush's decision to oust the regime of Saddam Hussein was a tactical blunder and that the effort to establish a liberal democracy in its stead has turned into an unmitigated fiasco.
The judgment of history on Bush's Iraq strategy is still decades away. Remember, Ronald Reagan's decision to aid the mujahedeen of Afghanistan in their fight against the Russians during the 1980s looked pretty smart after the collapse of the Soviet Union — . except the mujahedeen mutated into the Taliban, re-focused their hatred on America, trained a generation of terrorists and sheltered Osama bin Laden in the months leading up to September 11, 2001.
That decision doesn't seem quite so smart nowadays.
Nevertheless, to argue that the war in Iraq was ill-conceived because it might serve as a recruitment tool for al Qaeda is absurd. If America hadn't invaded Iraq, the United Nations would presumably still be enforcing sanctions against Saddam's regime — sanctions which were killing thousands of Iraqi children each month and which were specifically cited by Osama in 2002 as a justification for the 9/11 attacks. In other words, the situation in Iraq before the war was viewed by al Qaeda as a rationale for violence against America.
Then again, America's support for Israel was also cited by Osama to justify his terrorist jihad. Should we therefore end that support? What about our tolerance of, in Osama's words, "immoral acts of fornication, homosexuality, intoxicants, gambling's [sic], and trading with interest"? If our "immorality" is being utilized by al Qaeda to recruit terrorists, should we therefore crack down on Snoop Dogg, "Will and Grace," Budweiser, Las Vegas, and Citibank? And what of our stubborn refusal to convert to Islam — in Osama's eyes, perhaps the greatest provocation of all? Should we therefore renounce our Judeo-Christian heritage, abandon the separation of church and state and adopt sharia law to escape the wrath of al Qaeda?
If America is ever to triumph in its war against Islamic terrorism, we must get past the idea that we are its root cause. Specifically, we must get past the idea that a suicide bomber is just a peace-loving Muslim who, if we hadn't set him off, would be growing figs and building sand castles. Strapping explosives to your torso, marching yourself into a crowded marketplace and blowing yourself up in order to slaughter as many civilians, including women and children, as you can is a profoundly demented act, an act which undoes a dozen or so millennia in the moral evolution of the human species.
Such an act is not triggered by America's sociopolitical landscape or by its foreign policy. Rather, it is nurtured by an intellectually degenerate culture, sponsored by sleazy kleptocratic regimes and authorized by a once-honorable religious tradition perverted to serve the pipedreams of an apocalyptic death cult.
It's Muslim civilization, not America, that must change in order for Islamic terrorism to cease.
Mark Goldblatt is author of "Africa Speaks," a satire of black urban culture.
By Mark Goldblatt
Reprinted with permission from National Review Online.
 | America's Premier Site for Conservative News, Analysis, and Opinion. |
Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie."
- 1
- 2
- next
See all 36 CommentsFirst of all, thanks for an answer that actually conveys something new. Secondly, believers most times feel that they are owners of the truth and everyone else is wrong. It's called being myopic.
I highly appreciate your comments.Atleast somebody is getting involved in intellectual conversation.First thing I did after doin grocery for my mom is to check these comments.I don't mind who has what religious belief as long as they don't involve religion into politics.You are absolutely right about ideologues in our country and radical muslims.They both want to impose their religious views on other people.They always fight on the name of religions and whenever two persons fight on the name of religion there is some third person out there who takes advantage of the situation and gain financial benifits.One simple example is of India where Muslims and Hindus fight against each other,because in Hindu religion cow is their God and muslim eat cow.When muslims slaughter a cow,fight erupts which results in the death of hundreds of people from both sides.Does it make any sense at all that hundred of people should die on a *** cow.
Our problems don't stem from others in the world not subscribing to our constitution, they stem from ideologues in this country who wish to see it become a theocracy devoid of human rights with blind obedience to their God. (Sounds like there is little difference between these ideologues and radical Muslims, don't you think?)
Racism and hedgemony don't have anything to do with being GOD CHOSEN or not.........they are steeped in ignorance.
I do agree with you about this regurgitation about the concept of GOD CHOSEN and GOD NEGLECTED.You know why?It's becuase this RACIST and UNJUST CONCEPT of human beings not being created as equal is hurting the humanity in general and our country and it's people specifically.I criticize this BACKWARD,RACIST and UNJUST IDEOLOGY because I don't find anything else hurting our country the most like this ideology.We have been isolated in the world because of those who don't believe in our constitution which separates church from state and make the policies of our country based on RACIST belief.We get oil in cheaper prices from Arabs and then support their enemies and think that Arabs should be nice with us.I have to repeat the same thing over and over again because nobody comes with reasons to oppose or favor my thinking with proper and scientific reasons.I've seen thousands of my fellow Americans dying on 9/11 because of thier tax money being spent on this RACIST,UNJUST ideology.I don't want to see more Americans die for being GOD NEGLECTED.
I don't believe that stopneofatbs has to ask anyone not to read your comments. They all appear to me to be regurgitations of your all caps shouting about GOD NEGLECTED, GOD CHOSEN, and the like. I've read your last comment but not because of stopneofatbs.
Everything comes at a price.
Were the U.S. to be invaded and occupied by another country, this former Marine would become one of the best terrorists out there against the occupiers, I can assure you.
It was funny to see that you called me ANTI-AMERICAN.I love United States,so I am Anti-American and those who want to protect the illegitimate and unjustified existance of Israel on the cost of existance of USA because ISRAEL is a HOLY LAND whereas USA is not,are PRO-AMERICAN.I love and care about my fellow Americans so I am ANTI-AMERICAN whereas those who want Americans to die and waste their money for protecting the EUROPEAN INVADERS IN PALESTINE because Americans are GOD NEGLECTED and the EUROPEAN INVADERS IN PALESTINE are GOD CHOSEN are PRO-AMERICAN.I am ANTI-AMERICAN because I firmly believe in the constitution of my country which forbids the involvement of religion into politics by separating church from state whereas those who deny our constitution by making the policies of our country on the basis of bible which racially discriminate Americans by considering them as GOD NEGLECTED and considering NON-AMERICAN EUROPAN INVADERS IN PALESTINE as GOD CHOSEN,are PRO-AMERICAN.Islamonazis are not my friend.The person who built USAMA BIN LADEN from scratch by giving him money,weapons and military training was a RADICAL,RACIST and UNJUST CHRISTIAN from the REPUBLICAN PARTY named RONALD REAGAN.
After a busy day yesterday,I got chance to see your comment about me today.I am so grateful for your kindness that you practically accepted your defeat by not bringing up a single reason to prove that I was wrong.VERY CLEAR EVIDENT FACT that what ever I wrote was aboslutely right and that's why I had reasons to prove my points.You are asking people to ignore what I say because you know for fact that just like you,nobody among the enemies of USA like you has a single reason to prove that I am wrong and the RADICAL,RACIST and UNJUST ENEMIES of USA like you are right.I challenge you that if you think I am wrong bring reasons to prove that.I bet you'll never ever be able to do that.Otherwise,be a gentleman,accept your defeat(which you practically have)and stop your animosty against USA,it's people and it's constitution which forbids the involvement of religion into politics by separating church from state.
I doubt the rest of the world sees Americans as blaming themselves; in fact, it is America's perpetual claim of self-renewable innocence and self-cleansed purity that make it an appealing target for critics. Not only do we not blame ourselves, we make every effort to avoid taking responsibility. We are a nation which wears its patches on the back of its coat, out of its own sight, but sadly visible to the rest of the world.
It never ceases to amaze me, the power of self-absolution of which this Administration and some of its true believers seem capable. I suppose it's helped, made at all possible in fact, by an appalling ignorance of history.
Did we "deserve 9/11"? No...no nation deserves an assault of that sort. Have the Muslim nations been demeaned, exploited, and mistreated by the rest of us? Yes...and no nation deserves that either.
Between the "jingoism is a synonym for patriotism" witless citizens and the XianXrazyXrusaders, it's increasingly hard not to plummet head-first into the slough of desond.
How can we possibly claim to be in the right? Why do some feel we are justified in killing and bombing while condemning others for the same thing?
Our government, which does NOT represent me, has voted for torture.
Our government, which does NOT represent me, has voted for neverending detainment of people even without charges, merely suspicion. It doesn't take much to create suspicion against each other in the climate of fear this administration has fostered.
Our government, which does NOT represent me, has killed many innocent civilian men, women and children.
Our government, which does NOT represent me, started this war. If, as the administration has stated, there were no 9/11 ties to Iraq, and this war is not about oil, and there was little if no Al Qaeda influence in Iraq before we got there, what exactly is this war about?
How can we possibly claim to be in the right? Why do some feel we are justified in killing and bombing while condemning others for the same thing?
He needs to recognize the basic premise he is arguing against. Our government lied us into war for the benefit of large American corporations that own the mainstream media.
Maybe he is trying to propagandize a report by ALL of our government intelligence agencies that further indicate this bush administration is a complete failure fighting their contrive and fraudulent war of terror.
Obvious despicable right wingery!
While we can not appease, we can start to do less incitement in ways that do not compromise our prosperity or security.
We should dismantle bases in islamic holy lands as a gesture of understanding, and focus our energies on a peaceful palestinian state. If we can ever bring real security and peace to Afghanistan and Palestine (particuliarly by pulling back some of our support for ISrael unless they make necessary peace steps like retreating to the 1967 borders and recognizing the palestinian state), then MOST extremists would lay down their arms (except those in iraq really). The iraq problem will go on for years but the fact is that it has made more problems than it will ever solve, the only way to achieve real regime change is internally. We should have simply supported the kurdish alliance enough to have Kurdistan break off and then Saddam would have a much more concentrated problem in the Shia vs his Sunni regime - we could have backed the Shia after the kurdish revolution. That is how you help people achieve freedom, not forcing it down their throat with shells and bombs.
We are now reaping the consequences of this meddling.
- 1
- 2
- next
See all 36 Comments