Sept. 21, 2006
freeSpeech: 'Carlos'
Undocumented Young Man Describes Difficulties In Obtaining
-
Photo
(CBS)
-
News Tools
Immigration Reform Plan
President Bush lays out his vision for comprehensive immigration reform.
-
Video Archive
Hot Topic: Immigration
Video Coverage: CBS News examines the heated debate over immigration in the United States.
My parents and I came here from Guatemala on a 6 month tourist visa. I was 11 years old. Before we left, our family business went bankrupt. We had lost our home there, and my parents could not afford to pay for school. So with the money we got from selling all our furniture, my parents bought airplane tickets and we came to the U.S. because it was our last hope.
Within a year of my arrival, I was already in regular English classes and on the Honor Roll. My dad got a job in construction, my mom cleaned houses. Three nights a week, my parents, my 9 year old sister and I used to pick up the garbage at a factory. On weekends, we collected bottles to recycle. Almost from the beginning my parents paid taxes, and two years after we arrived here, they applied for legal residency. Believe it or not, our application is still pending. That means my parents and sister and I can still be deported even though we did everything we were supposed to do to try to become legal.
I ended up graduating 5th in my high school class and have since graduated college and I hope to become a lawyer. But because I am undocumented, I could never get a license to practice law and that puts me in a state of limbo. I've grown up here and I feel American - I just lack the piece of paper that validates it.
"Carlos" is a young man who arrived in the United States without speaking english over 10 years ago, and recently graduated college. He aspires to become a lawyer.
His future and the future of thousands of other students who have grown up in the U.S. depends on the Development Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act (DREAM Act) now pending in Congress. For more information visit the website, www.dontjustdreamact.com.
©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News: FreeSpeech
-
Video
First Look: War Over Iraq Plan
-
Video
freeSpeech: Annette Ross
-
Video
freeSpeech: Mike Rutherford
- Latest in CBS Evening News: FreeSpeech
- freeSpeech: John Lewis
- freeSpeech: Annette Ross
- freesSpeech: Mike Rutherford
Maybe that should be the story. 10 yrs in the country and 8 yrs waiting on a pending application. That is shameful.
My mother is Guatemalan and she came to the U.S. more than 30 yrs. ago. She went thru the process and I think if people want to be U.S. citizens they should too but 8 yrs. waiting for a Congratulations or Denial letter is a long time.
http://www.cis.org/articles/2001/mexico/toc.html
http://www.fairus.org
http://www.scpr.org/considerthis/illegalimmigration/2yes.html
http://www.pewtrusts.org/pdf/PHC_Immigration_full_0306.pdf
92% of all murder warrants in L.A. are for Illegal Aliens
83% of all felony arrests in California are Illegal Aliens
49% of all persons incarcerated in the state of Texas are Illegal Aliens
51% of all persons incarcerated in the state of Colorado are Illegal Aliens
89% of all murder warrants in Pheonix are for Illegal Aliens
91% of all murder warrants in New Mexico are for Illegal Aliens
53% of ALL Federal Welfare Services to the poor in this country are paid to Illegal Aliens.**
47% of all Medicare payments are paid to cover Illegal Aliens.**
In 2005 the Federal government was forced to literally bail out over 1,239 hospitals due to unpaid services rendered to Illegal Aliens. Total cost to you and I?
It is $73 BILLION!
===========================
The United States cannot, and should not, accept an endless stream of illegal aliens from poor countries of the world. Look at the poll for the last twenty years and we made it clear: deport the illegal aliens, and significantly reduce the number of immigrants. Please.. do that congress.
From the moment illegal immigrants enter the United States they break the laws that made us successful. Their actions leave Americans dumbfounded. We%u2019re shocked. We can%u2019t understand why someone coming here for our blessings would defy the laws that created those selfsame blessings.
If these folks have been waiting for their application to be processed for for 6-8 years, I cannot help but ask, "Why haven't they followed up on it?!" In all that time, I am certain they could have found a sympathetic ear, or someone with influence, to help them. Rather, it sounds as if they simply filed the necessary papers and sat back. Now, Junior wants to be an attorney.
Of course, I do not know this to be the case. However, what IS clear to me is that they ARE here illegally. Furthermore, Ms. Couric and CBS are clearly obstructing justice and harboring an illegal alien.
Our laws have served us well for over 200 years. And, they have done so because we do not 'pick and choose' which laws we will administer.
This young man is very much aware that he is here in violation of the law. However, because he has learned English (as he should have), worked and gone to school (as should we all), he apparantly feels the law should noy apply to him. Or, at least, that's the way it appears as he hides behind a shadow on national television.
I have friends from Bulgaria who just became citizens. They GOT IN LINE and were here LEGAL for well over ten years before they attained citizenship. They are both professionals, doctor and engineer, but it didn't give them front of the line priveleges.
You don't deserve to be here if you cheated the system.
Illegal aliens are NOT issued social security numbers.
Most illegal aliens work for cash & pay no income taxes.
Most illegals who claim to be "paying taxes" use STOLEN social security numbers, a FELONY, for which the penalty is 25 years in federal prison and a $250,000.00 fine, followed by deportation for illegal aliens.
The US Social Security Administration defines social security numbers which are "made up", imaginary, borrowed, bought, or obtained by use of false information or false ID, as STOLEN.
Not to mention the credit nightmare facing the legal holders of those social security numbers which have been stolen and used by 15 or 20 illegal aliens.
USA citizens and legal immigrants are expected to respect, and obey our laws, why is it that the millions of illegal aliens currently in this nation believe they don't have to? What makes them think they are better than the rest of us?
The problem is, having made a premeditated decision to violate our nations federal immigration laws, illegal aliens have no respect for ANY of our laws.
Carlos and his family deserve the same respect we US citizens have when we break the law.
They should be arrested and deported poste haste.
SHAME on CBS news for airing yet another "poor pablo" story!
It's about time to tell the whole truth isn't it?
These people have created a problem: stealing from the tax payer and giving nothing back in return. The US citizens that need assisstance are on the bottom of any list for aid, however, the "ILLEGALS" can receive money, medical, housing, and anything else they need without contribution into the system. I was trying to get assistance for my disability through Social Security and I did not receive it because my disability can get better (I laugh - GBS does not always get better and I am proof).
The Social Services would not allow me to receive assistance, however, the lobby was full of "ILLEGALS" getting food stamps and other assistance. I have worked for many years prior to this disability contributing to the system and I could not even receive temporary assistance. I am of Euro/Latino heritage and my family disagrees with assisting these "ILLEGALS". There seems to be a racial profile for receiving anything from the "SYSTEM".
If we allow these "ILLEGALS" to continue to be "ILLEGAL" then we need to allow other criminals to continue their trade as well. It seems to me that these "ILLEGALS" are criminals hence the term "ILLEGAL".
What nerve to state that his parents' application for legal residency is still pending. People who have applied for residency the LEGAL way are sitting in their home countries waiting, not trepassing on American soil and fleecing American taxpapers by forcing them to pay for their children's education.
These people came for the cash. "Almost from the beginning my parents paid taxes." Is he serious? Are they looking for a pat on the back? Americans pay taxes FROM THE BEGINNING. And if his parents paid PAYROLL TAXES and not just taxes at Wal-Mart and the gas station, they were working under stolen identities, with fraudulently obtained social security numbers. More crimes, aspiring lawyer, and I believe those are felonies.
So Carlos was on the honor roll. So was I, but I didn't think that gave me the right to break the law and then cry about the consequences.
Bye, bye, Carlos. Go back home to Guatemala where you belong and practice law there.
And if CBS is going to have more of these heart-tugging stories from criminals, I will watch another network news show.
What nerve to state that his parents' application for legal residency is still pending. People who have applied for residency the LEGAL way are sitting in their home countries waiting, not trepassing on American soil and fleecing American taxpapers by forcing them to pay for their children's education.
These people came for the cash. "Almost from the beginning my parents paid taxes." Is he serious? Are they looking for a pat on the back? Americans pay taxes FROM THE BEGINNING. And if his parents paid PAYROLL TAXES and not just taxes at Wal-Mart and the gas station, they were working under stolen identities, with fraudulently obtained social security numbers. More crimes, aspiring lawyer, and I believe those are felonies.
So Carlos was on the honor roll. So was I, but I didn't think that gave me the right to break the law and then cry about the consequences.
Bye, bye, Carlos. Go back home to Guatemala where you belong and practice law there.
And if CBS is going to have more of these heart-tugging stories from criminals, I will watch another network news show.
Seriously, how do you pay taxes without a social security number? Oh, that's right, with a stolen or fake one... another broken law. I am sure the bulk of the revenue we see from these ILLEGAL immigrants is local sales tax when they go pick up their Budweiser. Regarding his supposed application for citizenship he should be treated no better than any other person attempting the same... actually they should be treated worse. Carlos, join the military and do something for us for a change and maybe avenues will begin to open up for you!
I graduated high school in 1991 and even then we were forced to share books and sit on the floor as the district bussed in hispanics from the south side. When I was nineteen I could not get financial aid due to the fact I was white and the amount of money my father, not I, made. The fact that these people come here and receive free education and are virtually parasitic makes me sick... not to mention the impact they have on neighborhoods. Neighborhoods are being run down one by one... shopping carts and trash all over the place, graffiti and gang bangers at times also, schools struggling to get by and our emergency rooms closing one by one. Any more of this trash CBS and I'll stick strictly to cable. And to all illegals: GET OUT OF MY COUNTRY!!!
---------
A couple of mighty fine ideas!
Bush wants us to cut the amount of gas we use. The best way to stop using so much gas is to deport 11 million illegal immigrants! That would be 11 million less people using our gas. The price of gas would come down.
Bring our troops home from Iraq to guard the border. When they catch an illegal immigrant crossing the border, hand him a canteen, a rifle and some ammo and ship him to Iraq.
Tell him if he wants to come to America then he must serve a tour in the military. Give him a soldier's pay while he's there and tax him on it.
After his tour, he will be allowed to become a citizen since he defended this country. He will also be registered to be taxed and be a legal patriot. This option will probably deter illegal immigration and provide a solution for the troops in Iraq and the aliens trying to make a better life for themselves.
If they refuse to serve, ship them to Iraq anyway, without the canteen, rifle or ammo. Problem solved.
If you think this is a good solution to both the problems, forward it to your friends. I just did.
Greg Kandra
Editor, "Couric & Co."
Also, to clarify a couple of points made here, he and his family are applying for permanent residence, not citizenship. He said that application is still pending. They are allowed by law to apply while in the USA, it is NOT required to do so before they arrive. In fact, accouding to the US government immigration services web site:
" Applicants for adjustment to permanent resident status are eligible to apply for a work permit while their cases are pending."
So they are legaly allowed to work, while waiting for the application to be processed!
So let's not sterotype illegal imegrants! If we did ship them all back, are you going to pick all our vegtables?
Snopes.com and the LA times state the "95% of all outstanding warrents for homocide target illegal aliens" is an urban myth, totaly made up and spread around the internet as 'fact'.
As to the issue that some illegal aliens overstayed their visas, these is still a way for those people to remain, while they apply for a change of status. See this quote from the US Immigration web site:
"If you entered the United States unlawfully, if you entered with permission but did not stay in lawful status, or if you worked without permission, you normally would have to leave the United States in order to apply for an immigrant visa. Special rules under section 245(i) may allow you to apply to adjust status without leaving the United States."
Looks like it's you.
This is the ugly truth about illegal immigration:
Source: 2006 (1st Qtr) INS/FBI Statistical Report on Undocumented Immigration.
62% of all illegals in the USA are working for cash, not paying taxes.
95% of warrants for murder in Los Angeles are for illegal aliens;
83% of warrants for murder in Phoenix are for illegal aliens;
86% of warrants for murder in Albuquerque are for illegal aliens;
75% of people on the most wanted list in Los Angeles, Phoenix, and Albuquerque are illegal aliens;
24.9% of all inmates in CA detention centers,
40.1% of all inmates in AZ detention centers, and
48.2% of all inmates in NM detention centers
are Mexicans here illegally.
29% (630,000) convicted illegal alien felons fill our state and federal prisons at a cost of $1.6 billion annually;
Less than 2% of illegal aliens in the United States are picking crops , but 41% are on welfare.
There is a lot more, I can post it if you need to see it.
It won't be the "anchor babies" because they are too busy going to college on our tax dollars and taking jobs from future generations of Americans. And if you want to talk racism, if Haiti was on the other side of the border, then we wouldn't even be having this discussion. The illegals have it made! Just sign me...use to live in
Atlanta, but now it's like Mexico.
I am an IT Professional and I have worked in areas that they are hiring people with H-1B visas over American citizens because they can hire them for about 1/2 the cost of an American.
I write to my congress (HR & Sen) at least once a week to encourage them to pass proper legislation to combat this growing problem with the invasion of this country, distruction of the dessert plants and the federal parks along the border, the bat caves that have been invaded by illegals and have chased away the endangered bats species. The list goes on and on.
Hospitals along the borders and in California are closing because about 80% are illegal immigrants who have no insurance and are having anchor babies. If something is not done, the problem will continue to grow.
Section 245(i) of the Immigration and Nationality Act will be available temporarily to people physically present in the United States on the date of enactment, December 21, 2000.
In order to be eligible for 245(i) adjustment under the LIFE Act, a person must be the beneficiary of an immigrant petition or application for labor certification filed on or before April 30, 2001.
Section 245(i) is not amnesty for all persons unlawfully in the United States.
If you are living illegally in the United States, the mere filing of a visa petition or application for a labor certification has no effect on your current immigration status or unlawful presence in the United States.
The LIFE Act provides a very short window of opportunity, which ended April 30, 2001, for individuals to preserve their eligibility to file for adjustment of status under Section 245(i).
All petitions and applications must be properly filed and approvable when filed.
~You might want to do your homework next time.
It's sad that Carlos family lost their business in Guatemala. But does that mean America should give amnesty to every single family in other country w/o money citizenship?
It's interesting too, CBS pick this Carlos as an example that EVERY illegals should be given amnesty because he went to law school and his family worked hard (since we can't verify Carlos true identity, who knows if his background story is true)? It'd be nice if every illegals crossing our border ended up A students and contribute.
The fact is, all kinds of illegals get thru, whether it's farmer pickers AND gang members like MS-13 (why won't CBS do a segment on the destruction MS-13 cause in North America?), and drug dealers poisoning our streets. CBS woud like you to believe this cartoony image of all illegals are these heart warming poor family with star students.
Carlos parents are the ones who brought him and his sister here, not America. Illegal entry is illegal, no matter what your background is. Worst, CBS is pendering to politically correct sob story to get ratings.
For CBS's next commentary, how about get a illegal gang members sit down in shadow, so he can talk can about how much drugs he sell or how many guns he used to gun down people, and why won't America let anymore of his MS13 homies to come over to kill more people? That would be a balance persepctive, CBS.
Carlos should go back to Guatemala, where he could probably thrive given his educational advantages and improve the Guatemalan society, and wait to be admitted to the US legally like everyone else had to.
Giving Cover to Illegal Aliens
IRS Tax ID Numbers Subvert Immigration Law
http://www.cis.org/articles/2002/back1202.html
-
by cbs_suckass
September 24, 2006 8:34 PM PDT
- CBS thinks the invasion is a game? WHEN WILL YOU BROADCAST HOW US AMERICANS FEEL ABOUT ILLEGAL ALIEN INVADERS? We have had it with your B***SH*T!
-
Reply to this comment
-
See all 45 Comments2000 Americans have been murdered by illegal aliens in california alone. CBS tries to scare the hell out of the country nightly with the latest warnings. Now they are betraying the very people who made CBS what they are today. YOU SUCK CBS & Katie better start showing OUR side of the ILLEGAL immigration debate....theAmerican side. America is NOT A MALL!
DEPORT Jose TODAY, and his criminal family! No mention that jose's father OES NOT HIRE AMERICANS only other ILLEGAL ALIEN INVADERS?
Wise up CBS & tell the truth!