NEW YORK, Sept. 11, 2006
Bush: 'The War Is Not Over'
On 5th Anniversary Of Attacks, President Says U.S. In 'Early Hours' Of War
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Fallen Heroes
CBS News RAW: Kevin Dowdell was one of the 343 firefighters killed in the September 11th terrorist attacks. President Bush discusses why America is blessed to have heroes like Dowdell.
-
Video
9/11 Remembered
Jim Axelrod reports on the 9/11 remembrance ceremonies in New York, Shanksville, Pa., and the Pentagon.
-
Video
Bush Defends Iraq
CBS News RAW: President Bush explained why he went to war in Iraq even though Saddam Hussein was not responsible for the 9/11 attacks.
-
-
Photo
President Bush said, in an address from the Oval Office on the fifth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks: "Whatever mistakes have been made in Iraq, the worst mistake would be to think that if we pulled out, the terrorists would leave us alone." (CBS)
-
Photo
President Bush participates in a moment of silence at the Fort Pitt Firehouse in New York,, Sept. 11, 2006. (AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
-
Photo
First responders who were on the scene of the terrorist attack on the Pentagon salute above a large U.S. flag draped on the building's side during a memorial ceremony, Sept. 11, 2006 (Getty Images/Mandel Ngan)
-
Photo
Retired fireman Capt. Jim McDermott, of Ladder 52 in the Bronx, N.Y., looks at photos of victims on the outside of a bus parked near ground zero in Lower Manhattan, Sept. 11 2006. (Getty Images/Don Emmert)
-
Photo
Dan Hatlestad, center, his son, Erik, 13, left, and wife Lesia, of Littleton, Colo., pause to remember their neighbor, Capt. Jason M. Dahl, the captain of United Flight 93 on Sept. 11, 2001, at the memorial to Flight 93 victims in Shanksville, Pa. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)
-
-
Photos
Images: Five Years Later
Remembering the victims of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks and the heroes who perished trying to save them.
-
Interactive
Sept. 11 And Since
Reflecting on the events of Sept. 11, 2001, the day that changed America.
-
Interactive
Virtual Tour
Models, maps, audio reports and a 360-degree view show the changes at Ground Zero five years later.
"America did not ask for this war, and every American wishes it were over," Mr. Bush said. "The war is not over — and it will not be over until either we or the extremists emerge victorious."
Mr. Bush, in a prime time address from the Oval Office, staunchly defended the war in Iraq even though he acknowledged that Saddam Hussein was not responsible for the 9/11 attacks that killed nearly 3,000 people.
He said Saddam's regime, while lacking weapons of mass destruction, was a clear threat that posed "a risk the world could not afford to take." At least 2,600 U.S. servicemen and women have died in Iraq.
"Whatever mistakes have been made in Iraq, the worst mistake would be to think that if we pulled out, the terrorists would leave us alone," the president said. "They will not leave us alone. They will follow us."
The address was coming at the end of a day in which Mr. Bush honored the memory of the nearly 3,000 people killed in the attacks that rocked his presidency and thrust the United States into a costly and unfinished war against terror. In the speech, Mr. Bush explicitly linked the war in Iraq to the broader war on terror, CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric reports.Read the full text of President Bush's address
The president remembers 9/11
Bush defends his decision on Iraq
'Peace and moderation in the Middle East'
Remembering a fallen firefighter
"Our nation has endured trials, and we face a difficult road ahead," he said.
"We are now in the early hours of this struggle between tyranny and freedom," Mr. Bush said. "Amid the violence, some question whether the people of the Middle East want their freedom – and whether the forces of moderation can prevail."
It was a day of mourning, remembrance and resolve. Before his address, Mr. Bush visited New York, Shanksville, Pa., and the Pentagon to place wreaths and console relatives of the victims.
At 9:38 a.m. at the Pentagon and at 10:03 a.m. in Shanksville, Pa., everything stopped. The president visited those places and shared moments of silence. He also consoled families, laying wreaths and sharing a moment of silence, CBS News chief White House correspondent Jim Axelrod reports.
The president made no public remarks at the disaster sites Monday, calling it a "wordless day," Axelrod reports. "We were told it would be a non-political speech, with no distinctions between Democrats and Republicans."
Instead, Axelrod reports, viewers of the speech saw "stark differences made in terms of handling the war on terror. I think what we're seeing here is the bridge to Sept. 12," which starts the "final sprint to the mid-term elections."
Five years ago, the attacks transformed Mr. Bush's presidency and awakened the world to Osama bin Laden — who is still at large — and his band of al Qaeda terrorists. While the public has soured on the war in Iraq, which Mr. Bush calls the central front in the war on terror, the president still gets high marks for his handling of Sept. 11.
Terrorism has been a potent political issue for Republicans, and they hope to capitalize on it in the November elections. GOP lawmakers are anxious about holding control of both houses of Congress.
Congress has approved $432 billion for Iraq and the war on terrorism. At least 2,666 U.S. servicemen and women have died in Iraq. The toll in Afghanistan is 272.
"If we do not defeat these enemies now, we will leave our children to face a Middle East overrun by terrorist states and radical dictators armed with nuclear weapons," Mr. Bush said. "We are in a war that will set the course for this new century and determine the destiny of millions across the world."
White House officials said President Bush's speech was not intended to outline new strategy. Rather, it was portrayed as an appeal for unity and a commitment to win the struggle against terror at a time when the war in Iraq is widely opposed. There was no mention of Iraq in the excerpts of the speech, but officials said Mr. Bush would talk about it in his address.
"This struggle has been called a clash of civilizations," the president said. "In truth it is a struggle for civilization." He said the United States was standing with democratic leaders and reformers, offering a path away from radicalism.
©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Read the full text of President Bush's address
The president remembers 9/11



- 1
- 2
- next
See all 95 CommentsLike so many of us, my life forever changed on September 11th, 2001. After days of anguishing and searching for an answer, it suddenly came to me. That is, to erect a free monument to the thousands of lives lost.
So the next day, I went around to area companies for their support and help. And to my jubilant surprise, they too were anxious to get involved.
An area steel company offered to construct, erect, and even maintain forever the towers. Their workers even volunteered to come in on their days off to hand build the structures. "After all," they said, "we are steel workers and it was steel workers who built these buildings, and it was steel workers who came out voluntarily to clear the rubble and look for survivors. It's the least we can do."
A local stone company readily donated all the limestone materials and other companies offered their assistance. I really thought our message to the fallen would finally succeed. I was so wrong. I had no idea that this simple and quiet symbol and act of remembrance would solicit so many objections from civic, community, religious, government, and institutional groups as "inappropriate", "offensive to Moslems", and even, "out-of-character" by one community.
"Offensive," I asked, "to whom?" "Out-of-character? Inappropriate?" I wondered, "How's it possible?"
Tomorrow 12 septembre 2006, exactly TWO MONTHS ago, the Israeli Defense Forces has had started a TERROR attack on the land of Lebanon. ONE THOUSAND innocent victims unwillingly paid with their lives. There has been 15,000 (fifteen thousand) residential units destroyed, LEBANESE infrastructure: roads, bridges, hospitals, highrises, dairy manufactures, etc...
Total loss: more than fifteen billion dollars (15,000,000,000$) as per estimates of United Nations and Lebanese governement experts damage assessors.
Lebanese citizens are sharing the sorrow of the USA lost citizens, and adding up their fresh sorrow to the tragic human experience. The problem they are facing now is defining the ONE GROUND ZERO of their own. One tends to think there are as many as 15,000 of them on Tiny Lebanon land.
GOOD WILLS AND PEACE ON ALL OF US UNTILL ETERNITY COMES, UNTILL ETERNITY COME; WE ARE AND SHOULD STAY ONE EARTH NATION.
We went after them in Iraq and Afganistan.
In Iraq alone, 45000 civilians died in a three years period. Will they have a day to remember, or an eternity to hate us?
And in Iraq alone another 3000 of our sons and daughters died. Will they also have a day to remember?
Was it worth the price? Are we better now than we were then?
This is the same speach he gives constantly, for the past months and years. Where has he been?
A peom
A Thoughtful Prayer
Through Words We Can Not Feel
Through Our Soul We Can Touch
To A PlaceSo Real
To The People We Love So Much
Though We Can Not See
For Whom We So Much Think Of
For Whom Is Alive, Is Now Free
Is Now In The Heaven Above
Though You Are Not Here
Here In My Arms
Within A Thoughtful Prayer
You'll Always Be Here In My Heart
Love Is Here For Always
For The Love That We Had Shared
I Hold So Dear
For Within A Thoughtful Prayer
I Hold So Sincere
Memeories Of You That Lasts
No Matter Where You Are
You'll Stay Forever
Here In My Heart
Written By Tracy Rogers
The headline is this:
Five Years On: 2,992 Lives Remembered
Make your own conclusion.
Lets take a look at this aproval ratings: 89% at start of war 36% or so now. I am tired of all this anti Bush talk. You think the man is that supid to drive are nation into the muck? You think he is trying his best to protect us and not just us but the rest of the world? Hmm? The world needs leaders, and fewer people who think this war is not right. Oh no we should with draw and stay at home. Well may seem good idea at the moment, but what about the terrorist, what they doing? They planning to hurt more people... No attacks on our lands for 5 years, think Bush is trying to protect us? Yes.
Yes I feel bad about our armed services dying everyday, my cousin just went into the Navy. Every now and then he tells his mom that they stopped a drug boat in the ocean. Is that not protecting our nation? Hmm. Evil will win if you do not take action, staying at home will not work. War is sacrifice rather we like it or not. Only way to fix some peoples view ideas is to get ride of them, wish there was a peaceful way, but there is not, people have to die.
Put you self in Bush's shoes, what would you do? Think about that. Think Bush wants to live the rest of his life thinking he was a very bad President?
Americans need to suck it up and be strong. Show honor for our nation, lead the world to peace.
So see the big picture not bits and pieces.
This is a good plan and the 911 was a good starting point. Unfortunately those who are paying for it are the real American citizens. The sorrow is sincere for the real victims%u2019 relatives who lost sisters, brothers, sons, daughters, father, mothers, aunts, uncles, nephews, nieces, friends, partners and neighbors. It%u2019s not the case for the hypocrite president or his vice-president. Ask GW Bush and *** Cheney to send their immediate kin and relatives to the front in IRAQ or Afghanistan, and see how they%u2019ll behave. He himself never wanted to make it to the War when he was due.
So RonnieHM, hope you'll find this kind of standing right, but still eager to hear from you that other insignificant question.
Of course SADDAM was a common threat to Kuwait (which he invaded), to Israel (which he bombed with Scud missiles), and a direct threat to SA Kingdom (was next Saddam target after Kuwait). Altogether with the will of establishing the newly reshaped Middle East dreamt by the Neo-Cons for better insertion and conversion to Christianity, and the establishing of Greater Israel Kingdom from the Sea to the Euphrates and ... As long as Ben-Laden was hiding in Tora Bora and not threatening, it%u2019s fine. The way is wide open for the plan.
The American people EMOTIONS become a simple good for sale, and trade. The GW Bush tricky acting is the type of Ronald Reagan with more sophistication. He is endowed with a cold depressed face when solemn situation is needed. He is dubbing a great writers team of public opinion modulators. The later write speeches that can instill the fright in the hearts of American who are like sheep and goats, and who tend to agree on everything their president and leaders say.
Please Read Contd 2
Why Saudi families have been shipped immediately on the next if not the same day outside the USA on the day of 911, when ALL other flights have been suspended. Why their plane has not been shot down by fighter jets as per orders given by high authorities.
One of the theories is that Saudis and CIA have fomented the coup altogether, because of the fundamental Islamic threat that was growing stronger and harder with the O. Ben-Laden-likes... So is it plausible with the knowledge of Jewish organizations (so little of them have died that day), the Saudis have prepared (flights-trained) and paid the suicidals, under cover of Islamic charities, to commit this atrocity, under the blessing of CIA and GW Bush immediate entourage.
It's cool to say well no fricking way we did it nor did we know of it. Of course they did not do, but no one could prove they didn%u2019t know of it. And it looks much on purpose, they didn't prevent it from happening either, despite previous knowledge.
Please read Ctnd 1...
- was an alcoholic for the first half of his adult life;
- never ran a successful business in his life;
- was a mediocre student at Yale (the only reason he got in was because of his family's prominence and money);
- is so inept at being president that Cheney, Rumsfeld, and the Bush neo-cons are calling the shots;
- has been lying to us since before he became president;
- and on, and on and on...
The neo-cons are so fearful of losing their one-party control of this country that they will do absolutely anything to stay in power. Right now they are stooping pretty low.
Yet, people like Karl Rove are understandably anxious Americans might wonder about the long silences between speeches about the "light at the end of the tunnel", or a "darkness before the dawn", etc. That's old rhetoric, and most Americans now think Iraq is a mistake.
The GOP has to devise a new routine, a series of snappy one-liners for radio and TV spots-- "Hey, Joe, How do ya tell a military disaster from a Vietnam-style quagmire?" "Gee, I dunno, Bob." "Ya dummy! You can't-- It's an official secret!"
Or this one-- "Hey, Joe! When are American troops coming back home? They've been there almost as long as WW2." "Gee, I dunno, Bob." "Ya dummy! Not while I'm president!" "But you're not president, Bob!" "Exactly!"
Let's see if we can wake the hell up before the next 'anniversary' rolls around again.
If our leaders had an sense about them, they would be encouraging Americans to remember their loved ones on their BIRTHDAY instead of on 911.
911 is a day of celebrating American sorrow and maniac muslim 'success', of sorts, over Americans.
We should seek to make this day as insignificant as possible. Celebrate the dearly departed on their day of birth.
In this way, the loved ones will be remembered without simultaneously giving maniac muslims the pleasure to gloat at American grief!
Haven't we been through this before? Which war? After his public denial that he linked the cause of 911 with Iraq, Bush once again equates 911 with Iraq. Like a kid caught with his hand in the cookie jar of deceit, Bush is caught flat-footed once again in his favorite lie to the American people.
The only war Americans believe Bush is fighting is Iraq-- Afghanistan recedes into irrelevance, considering the emphasis Bush has given the campaign. Matters are not going splendidly there, either, perhaps explaining the lack of official news.
No, America did not ask for 911, but it did charge Bush to exterminate bin Laden in his lair in Afghanistan. Instead, Bush asked for Iraq.
Let me just say that hearing that dull witted, inarticulate, morally bankrupt piece of garbage that has waged war on my deepest held beliefs from day one of his administration begging for unity makes me want to puke.
That about sums it up.
Our official reply:
http://www.theweeklydonut.org/index.php/2006/09/11/take-a-nice-big-bite-america/
He then betrayed every American and most espcially the ones who suffered losses on 9-11 by claiming he was chasing Osama Bin Laden in Iraq. He had lost all interest in Osama by then.-11 was only an excuse he used.
This man is without conscious, morals, integrety, honesty any of the qualities we need in a leader. How he can sleep at night is beyond me. Maybe that is why he looks like death warmed over. All those dead souls he has killed by his lies must come to haunt him at night.
The best thing he can do right now is get out of Iraq and join with the UN as a peace maker. The UN works better if the USA is with them instead of off on some cowboy mission of Bush's doing.
But, Bush has already said that he won't leave Iraq while he is president. No, he is going to leave the big mess he has made for his successor. He a coward and well as stupid he is.
You have that chose. You can leave. I'm so sick of the blame game that everyone is playing. It wouldn't matter if someone else was president instead of Bush. They would blame him, our government and however else they can think of.
I regret that so many people lost their lives and alot of our military have died.
Stand tall America!!!
Which war, Iraq or "the war on terrorism"?
If you%u2019re talking about Iraq then I hope your wrong Mr. President. I hope it all ends soon there, and family of mine can come home before they get killed. I put the blame solely in your hands for the cursory war in Iraq, which you and your cursory administration led us into.
As far as the "war on terror" goes, well it didn%u2019t start with your office and it's not going to end with your office. I don't even think you understand what a "war on terror" is. It's not really a "war". It's a LAGRE scale criminal investigation won mostly by surveillance, intelligence and the ability to respond quickly to in coming threats. Terrorism has always been there, and Americans have often been the targets, but there isn't just ONE enemy. There area many terrorist groups and they all have there own goals. One of the goals of our terrorist enemies is to gain clout through attacking us. YOU GAVE IT TO THEM! WHY? You are the cause for thousands of new terrorists recruits. You are making the problem bigger by including Iraq in your so vague "war on terror". Mr. President you and your talking point robots of a constituency have lost my confidence. My vote is not going to be aligned with the GOP. Your party shows no willingness to show individuality, intelligence, and a freewill.
Mr. President, you and the GOP have failed us. WE WILL REMEMBER.
I love my country and I do stand behind what our government is doing. Yes, this country was founded on being able to voice your opinion. But it's always the people who are against EVERYTHING that you always hear from. They are never satisfied. No matter who is in office. Your also given a right at the age of 18, that's the right to vote. If you don't like the way the country is run, GO VOTE! It's your civic RIGHT!
PROUD TO BE AN AMERICAN!!!
We should be honored...honored to fight for freedom.
The lack of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq contradicts years of intelligence indicating Saddam had such weapons, which also was the conclusion of officials in the Clinton administration.
"The consensus was the same, from the Clinton administration to the Bush administration," she (Hillary Clinton) said. "It was the same intelligence belief that our allies and friends around the world shared.
- 1
- 2
- next
See all 95 Comments