CARROLL, N.Y., Sept. 9, 2006

Suspected Cop Killer Surrenders

Cops Nab Ralph 'Bucky' Phillips, Ending State's Largest Manhunt

  • Play CBS Video Video Suspected Cop-Killer Caught

    CBS News RAW: New York State Police superintendent Wayne Bennett announced the arrest of Ralph "Bucky" Phillips, who escaped from a Buffalo-area jail in April.

  • Video Manhunt Continues For Fugitive

    Police continue to comb the Pennsylvania-New York border area in search of suspected cop-killer Ralph "Bucky" Phillips. Authorities believe they may have him cornered. Byron Pitts reports.

  • Video Massive Manhunt Continues

    Only On The Web: Commanding Officer Lenny DePaul of the U.S. Marshals Service talks with CBS News' Katie Couric about the massive manhunt for an escaped prisoner.

    • Fugitive Ralph Photo

      Fugitive Ralph "Bucky" Phillips, right, is escorted by U.S. Marshals toward the U.S. District Courthouse garage entrance in Buffalo, N.Y., on Friday, Sept. 8, 2006.  (AP)

    • Ralph Photo

      Ralph "Bucky" Phillips, a fugitive suspected of shooting three New York state troopers, one fatally, is driven away by authorities after he surrendered to police, Friday, Sept. 8, 2006.  (CBS)

    • A wanted poster provided by the FBI for Ralph Photo

      A wanted poster provided by the FBI for Ralph "Bucky Phillips.  (AP / CBS)

    • State police converge in Carroll, N.Y. Friday after a reported sighting of Ralph Photo

      State police converge in Carroll, N.Y. Friday after a reported sighting of Ralph "Bucky" Phillips, an escaped convict believed to have killed a state trooper.  (WIVB)

    • Joseph Longobardo, shown here in an undated photo, was shot in the leg Thursday night while staking out the property of a former girlfriend of Ralph Photo

      Joseph Longobardo, shown here in an undated photo, was shot in the leg Thursday night while staking out the property of a former girlfriend of Ralph "Bucky" Phillips.  (AP/New York State Police, file)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Interactive FBI Crime Statistics

    Explore the latest information on U.S. crime, from acts of violence to property damage.

  • Interactive Guns In America

    State-by-state gun laws and death rates, maps of recent school and workplace shootings and facts on who's at risk.

(CBS/AP)  A fugitive suspected of fatally shooting a New York state trooper and wounding two others while on the run for more than five months surrendered to police who had cornered him in a field just over the Pennsylvania border Friday night.

Ralph "Bucky" Phillips walked out with his hands up, ending the state's largest manhunt for the 44-year-old career thief who broke out of a Buffalo-area jail in April, New York State Police Investigator Gary Colon said.

The arrest capped a frantic day of searching that included troopers firing at Phillips earlier in the day as he dodged authorities in a wooded area.

Phillips appeared in U.S. District Court in Buffalo Saturday where a judge agreed to turn him over to state police to face a charge of attempted murder of a state trooper in Chemung County.

Phillips, who had threatened "suicide by cop" and once promised to "splatter pig meat all over Chautauqua County," was on the FBI's 10 Most Wanted list.

During the four-minute hearing, the exhausted and unshaven suspect answered "yes" when asked if he was Ralph Phillips and if had received a copy of the federal complaint charging him with unlawful flight to avoid prosecution.

Wearing an orange prison jumpsuit, he stood with his hands folded in front of him as the judge spoke. After the appearance, U.S. Marshals placed a chain around his waist, handcuffed him and led him out of court.

For hours, police had methodically moved closer to Phillips. Just before nightfall, 25 SWAT officers and 12 dogs swept through a field where he was thought to be hiding. He gave himself up around 8 p.m., police said.

"A few of my guys had spotted him in an open field, the helicopter zeroed in on him," said Lenny DePaul, commanding officer of the U.S. Marshals Service fugitive task force.

He did not know what condition Phillips was in. In a photo taken as he was driven away from the field, Phillips looked gaunt, dirty and exhausted.

"He could run but he couldn't hide," said New York State Police Superintendent Wayne Bennett. "The bottom line is the pressure was so great on him. The game was up and he knew it."

While on the run, police believe Phillips had stolen at least 15 cars and more than 40 guns; living off the land, ex-girlfriends and at least one boyhood buddy who's since been arrested, reported CBS News correspondent Byron Pitts.

A U.S. Marshals Service task force joined the investigation Wednesday and had about 30 investigators on the ground, commanding officer Lenny DePaul said.

CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric asked DePaul how Phillips could elude such an enormous manhunt.

"He's got little bit of a history — with his background being the woodsman that he is. He grew up in the area, he's got a lot of experience doing what he's doing," DePaul said of Phillips.

Friday's search started shortly before 2 a.m. in Pennsylvania when a police officer tried to pull over a stolen car. After a short chase, the car crashed and the driver, identified by police as Phillips, fled into the woods.

A half-hour later, Phillips stole a second car and drove back into New York, where troopers located him and launched a second chase, authorities said.

Phillips jumped out of the moving car and ducked into woods, zigzagging back and forth between New York and Pennsylvania, authorities said. Police dogs tracked his scent for several hours until he was spotted by two troopers, Bennett said.

As troopers approached, Phillips wheeled around with a pistol in his hand but did not fire, police said. One of the troopers fired an undisclosed number of shots as Phillips disappeared into the thick woods.

Phillips became the subject of a huge search after allegedly shooting a state trooper near Elmira June 10. The trooper survived.

Then, authorities said, he ambushed and shot two New York state troopers on Aug. 31 as they staked out the home of Phillips' former girlfriend. One trooper died on Sunday; the other was in critical condition.

©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Video and Galleries from U.S.

Add a Comment See all 42 Comments
by jamesie4 September 8, 2006 1:49 PM PDT
Maybe this is entertainment for the rest of the country and the news media, but for people who live in SW NY it is just sadness.
Reply to this comment
by jamesie4 September 8, 2006 1:50 PM PDT
why did it have to turn out this way, now that young trooper is dead and someone else is going to probably die too
Reply to this comment
by bub223 September 8, 2006 2:38 PM PDT
This whole thing is kind of a game between cops and Bucky. At least that is what it seems like to us. The cops "find him" and then he mysteriously escapes again. We feel if the police really wanted to get Bucky then he wouldnt have all these chances to keep running. They should have got him when he was in Wild Cat Park. It wouldnt have been that hard to surround the place and end this "chase" then....Oh well scare innocent people some more...The only thing i agree with that the police have said, is that "I dont feel one bit sorry for the ******* people who help Bucky out. This is insane!!!!
Reply to this comment
by bub223 September 8, 2006 2:39 PM PDT
This whole thing is kind of a game between cops and Bucky. At least that is what it seems like to us. The cops "find him" and then he mysteriously escapes again. We feel if the police really wanted to get Bucky then he wouldnt have all these chances to keep running. They should have got him when he was in Wild Cat Park. It wouldnt have been that hard to surround the place and end this "chase" then....Oh well scare innocent people some more...The only thing i agree with that the police have said, is that "I dont feel one bit sorry for the ******* people who help Bucky out. This is insane!!!!
Reply to this comment
by bub223 September 8, 2006 2:39 PM PDT
This whole thing is kind of a game between cops and Bucky. At least that is what it seems like to us. The cops "find him" and then he mysteriously escapes again. We feel if the police really wanted to get Bucky then he wouldnt have all these chances to keep running. They should have got him when he was in Wild Cat Park. It wouldnt have been that hard to surround the place and end this "chase" then....Oh well scare innocent people some more...The only thing i agree with that the police have said, is that "I dont feel one bit sorry for the ******* people who help Bucky out. This is insane!!!!
Reply to this comment
by bub223 September 8, 2006 2:39 PM PDT
This whole thing is kind of a game between cops and Bucky. At least that is what it seems like to us. The cops "find him" and then he mysteriously escapes again. We feel if the police really wanted to get Bucky then he wouldnt have all these chances to keep running. They should have got him when he was in Wild Cat Park. It wouldnt have been that hard to surround the place and end this "chase" then....Oh well scare innocent people some more...The only thing i agree with that the police have said, is that "I dont feel one bit sorry for the ******* people who help Bucky out. This is insane!!!!
Reply to this comment
by rs9x243 September 8, 2006 2:41 PM PDT
This entire story, no matter how it plays out, is so sad. I'm the widow of a retired New York State Trooper. All of the public, should be saddened, by the senseless death, and severe wounding of the Troopers involved. NON-VIOLENT?? my foot. Please catch this guy, before anymore tragedy occurs.
Reply to this comment
by chicabear1 September 8, 2006 4:01 PM PDT
These worthless, cop killer maggots don't even deserve to live in civilized society. The law is too *** lenient on these criminals! They suck down oxygen they don't deserve and terrorize society. Lock them up and throw away the key!
Reply to this comment
by pinkgiraffe69 September 8, 2006 4:50 PM PDT
Enough is too much! It's time to bring Phillips to justice, and right now he has made the term 'justice' very vague when applied to him. The thing that makes an individual like him do the things he's been doing, differentiate him from those who can succeed in society. This is a self indulgent rampage for infamy and notariety. He'll be one for the books alright, but the final line won't serve him well. 'The End' of his freedom is signaling only the beginning of suffering for way too many innocent individuals. Even his own family will be known forever as relatives of "Bucky" Phillips, the ruthless killer.
Reply to this comment
by tebmom2 September 8, 2006 6:49 PM PDT
Shoot him. Shoot him several times. That would be justice, or at least on the right path.
Reply to this comment
by lmc7102 September 8, 2006 8:05 PM PDT
It is apparent that this man has no intentions of being captured alive. I agree with the head NY tropper, the only way he is coming out is in a body bag. He has no remorse for the shooting of those three men, who were doing there job, all we can do is pray for those involved. May no harm come to anyone. God Bless
Reply to this comment
by shoestore61 September 8, 2006 8:32 PM PDT
What happened to the presumption of innocence? I find it funny that Bucky supposedly had amunition capable of piercing thru both the front and back of the troopers body armour and shot a trooper in Elmira whilst staying in Chautauqua County throughout this ordeal! Yes he is NON VIOLENT and no one has shown me a shread of evidence otherwise! Have they indicted the trooper who shot and killed an innocent civilian because he thought it was Bucky 6 weeks ago?

My thoughts...call off the search...stop hunting the man...let him surface and arrest him! Is this worth more lives much less 500k per day? I dont think these guys could find their kids in a closet!
Reply to this comment
by genesauto September 8, 2006 8:46 PM PDT
Test of password.
Reply to this comment
by kwlambi September 8, 2006 8:47 PM PDT
ok what the hell? is this a story? who decided this is a story ? one guy? playing with himself? who cares what he did? why do we know to know? Is this a white guy to offset the black guys ? what is this?
Reply to this comment
by genesauto September 8, 2006 8:55 PM PDT
I don't know if they have the ability or not to use the infrared imaging system from aircraft, but if I were searching for him with those things in my capability, I would use it after the ambient temperature had dropped below the 90 degree mark and start in the area he was last sighted. He would literally have to be in a cave to prevent detection. While hiding in a cave is not beyond his ability in that area, many folk know where those caves exist. How hard can it be to catch this man in this day and age with all this technology? Isn't that what it was built to do?
Reply to this comment
by canisteoman September 8, 2006 9:26 PM PDT
I am very happy that this *** is finally caught! Hopefully we can bring him to justice and sentence him to DEATH! He deserves it what an idoit thinking he can take on the State Police and win. I am very happy that no more of our protectors were hurt. I am a little disappointed that bucky didn't get to feel the pain he has inflicted. Hopefully they will continue to keep bringing in all the rest of the jackasses that have been helping him and throw the book at them.
Reply to this comment
by s8trrr September 8, 2006 11:27 PM PDT
HANG THE FOOL AND JOIN TOBY KEITH WITH "WHISKEY FOR MY MEN AND BEER FOR MY HORSES"
Reply to this comment
by tpeks40 September 9, 2006 12:08 AM PDT
Hey shoestore ***, He was caught and nobody else got hurt. Are you aware that this jerk stole cars, leaving it feasible that he could have been in Elmira. As you recall, there wasn't as much an urgency to catch him when he was just a scumbag that escaped from jail, that is until he shot the trooper that pulled him over on the stolen motorcycle he was riding. Are you aware that a gun store was robbed and the weapons just happened to be found at the idiots double wide that was helping him? He had many weapons at his disposal, but the troopers were vigilant and caught him with his pants down and without access to them. Speaking of his pants being down, I hope they bunk him with Bubba for the next 30 years. He won't get what he deserves, which is someone that he loves being taken from him by an idiot lowlife scumbag.....someone like yourself. that is.
Reply to this comment
by geiffrey September 9, 2006 12:48 AM PDT
Its to bad that this cop killer will never get the Death Penalty. That's because New York is run by liberals like Gov. George Pataki , soft on crime --even cop killers!!!

This just shows us that Pataki has been bad for New York State and even worse for America.
Reply to this comment
by September 9, 2006 7:10 AM PDT
I'm very happy they got this cop killing criminial.He was good at shooting Troopers in the back or when their guns were in their holsters but when the moment of truth arrived he failed to DO THE DO and gave up like a girlie man. Screw YOU BUCKY - Have a nice life ****head!
Reply to this comment
by harryg9 September 9, 2006 8:30 AM PDT
Bucky Phillips is now in custody. He vowed to go down in a blaze of glory. In his own words, it would be "suicide by cop". In the end, he showed himself for exactly what he is. A gutless coward. When he couldn't ambush anyone from behind and he was faced head on, he surrendered like we all knew he would. Snivelling two-bit punk...
My thoughts and prayers go out to the family of Trooper Joseph A. Longobardo. Rest in peace, my brother.
To Trooper Donald Baker Jr., best wishes on a speedy and complete recovery.
Reply to this comment
by jjw14692 September 9, 2006 9:55 AM PDT
Bucky is FINALLY in custody. It's to bad the State Police didn't shoot him. Rot in hell you scumbag. You turned my community into your own little playground and now it's our turn. You will NEVER see daylight again. Enjoy Prison.

It's just too bad you're a coward and didn't do "suicide by cop" like you wanted. It would have saved us from having to pay to lock your butt up until you die.

Now we can bury one of our Troopers and give his family some comfort knowing you have been taken off the street.
Reply to this comment
by moc01 September 9, 2006 10:16 AM PDT
I'm sorry for the police officers death but they too have failed policies. I sure don't trust the police.
Reply to this comment
by trailwalker2 September 9, 2006 10:41 AM PDT
I too am glad that this is over and mourn the loss of the trooper who was killed. I hope that those who harbored the criminal are hit hard by the justice system and shunned by others. It is unfortunate that the scumbag was not killed instead of taken alive. A similar incident occurred in Blacksburg, VA near VA Tech where my son goes to college. It is unfortunate that that cop killer did not get killed too instead of being captured. Where would we be without police officers, firemen, rescue workers, and our armed services personnel?
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 9, 2006 10:54 AM PDT
In regard to the press reports...they choose to interview the 5% of the population in Chautauqua County who did have a fear of Bucky and ignore the majority who know what Bucky was about. In regard to his capture, I am relieved that there was not further injuries or deaths. I hope that the justice system sorts out what is speculation and what is truth and he receives his day in court.

In regard to Bucky - If the State of New York had invested even $1,000 in a counselor for Bucky when he was abused as a 12 year old boy they may never have had the events of today occur and it would be money well spent when you review the millions of wasted dollars in this search. In regard to locating him by infared...you cannot get your budget expanded for next year and get paid overtime and bonuses for being stationed away from your home barracks if he is captured so it was not in the plan of the State Police to capture him until they could justify their budget and get even more for next year set aside and pad their own pockets.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 9, 2006 10:55 AM PDT
I challenge everyone to find one instance where Bucky received significant help and appropriate counseling and intervention when he was a child.

I can't find any...
Reply to this comment
by cgarrison32 September 9, 2006 11:29 AM PDT
The New York State Police should take some responsibility for the death of Joseph Longobardo and for the shooting of Don Baker. The NYSP had Child Protective Services remove Ralph Phillip's grandchildren from their home, one of whom was a nursing baby who was taken from her mother. This was a tactic intended to root out Phillips, and it worked, as the Longobardo and Baker families will attest. Did Ralph deserve to be caught- absolutely. If he shot those Troopers, he deserves the maximum penalty. It seems that by deliberately provoking Ralph Phillips, the NYSP put their own men in jeopardy, and should have to be partly responsible for what happened.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 9, 2006 12:09 PM PDT
Absolutely! I can tell you the mindset he had.

---You NEVER saved me from my abuse and here you are taking innocent children from a good parent and abusing an infant...NO WAY---

I would rate the actions taken against the infant granddaughter of Bucky as child abuse by the State of New York. This child did nothing to them and it was not the proper action to take...as others have stated if they just backed off no one would be dead including Bradley Horton and he would one day get comfortable and reveal himself in a location that he is recognized and be taken into custody. I am sure that someone would have turned him in for the money (with no loss of life) if he were not hunted by the police and hiding from the general public.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 9, 2006 12:28 PM PDT
For those who still aren't getting the concept of living in New York and Chautauqua County (these are not Bucky relatives by the way)--
CASE 1 - Family with 4 children under age 10 and a 2 week old infant. Mother has not slept regularly since new baby was born father is an over the road trucker. Teacher knows there is a new baby in the home but has the nerve to call child protective services when the child in her class wears the same clothes accidentally 2 days in a row.
CASE 2 - Family has a child injured and physicians notes IN THE OFFICE IN THE SCHOOL excusing a 20 day absence from school. The school calls child protective services stating that the child was absent for unknown reasons EVEN THOUGH THEY HAD A PHYSICIANS NOTE on file.

And the country wonders why Bucky is a little nutty. I'd go on but I'm only allowed 1500 characters each entry.
Reply to this comment
by Lucky Bob September 9, 2006 12:41 PM PDT
prophecy411, the percent of us in Chautauqua County who knew what "Bucky was about" was more than five percent. It wasn't that Bucky turned deadly because the Big 'Ol Bad State Police started picking on him. He broke out of prison, supposedly shot a police officer, and then possibly stole a number of vehicles and FIREARMS. He knew what he was getting into when he broke out of prison. You can't expect that when a man breaks out of prison for the police to say, "Eh, oh well. Maybe he'll come back or turn himself in. Eh." Don't give me that he would have eventually turned himself in. He had no intentions of it! Would you if you were free, and after having shot someone??? He ignored a request by someone he previously worked with who was willing to take the $50,000 reward and give it to Bucky's grandchildren!

Oh, and I know the State Police wanted to just rack up their overtime and bonuses. I mean, come on, who wouldn't want to work twenty-four hour shifts when you have a family at home to support...please...

Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 9, 2006 1:12 PM PDT
Lucky Bob - I am sure that there are officers walking away from here with at least $10,000 to $25,000 in their pockets more than they earned last year. I don't blame them...they are looking out for number one and it is not cheap to get raped by New York State for taxes. That is the yearly salary of most of the people who live in Chautauqua County so we consider that a lot of money.
I never said Bucky would turn himself in did I?
Budgets for all New York State entities are determined by what is spent the year before...if you don't spend it, you lose it...if you spend more you get more the following year. Facts of life in New York State...
I am an ordained minister and I spend my time cleaning up messes made by New York State free of charge by counseling those that cannot afford the help they need.
Reply to this comment
by Lucky Bob September 9, 2006 1:19 PM PDT
I have to agree that the state's child protective services can be a joke. It seems like they end up going after innocent people when the children that need help don't get it very often. But I guess that's a story for another day...
Reply to this comment
by hulbie1 September 9, 2006 2:55 PM PDT
interesting commets....if you dont trust the cops who you going to trust..nope they arent perfect but think they would be better to do so with than say bucky ya think?..bucky as a person is responcible for his actas with out any excuses that people seem to want to make for him..to me bottom line is we all have our "demons" to fight and most of us seem to be able to obey the law in doing so ..we struggle and battle daily to achive the things we want without taking from others even though at times it seems insurmountable roadblocks... his way was the "easy" way to take and let others work for what he wanted.. no excuses for that...he had less than week to do and he made decision to do it this way...just another idiot with the i want so i'll take and screw others and what they think..yea a great guy...not
Reply to this comment
by oopydoop September 9, 2006 4:06 PM PDT
How can you even begin to say that this idiot "Bucky" was concerned for his grandchildren and that he was provoked by the police. Where was he for the last 21 of 24 years? The answer, jail. I'm sure he did a whole hell of alot for his grandchildren and family while committing crimes to get his *** thrown back in the slammer. As a matter of fact he went back to jail after violating rules in a half way house by making threats towards family members. He is no family man. He is just a "piece of human debris" that has total disregard for others.
Phillips took the life of a fine young man, Trooper Joseph Longobardo, and the only thing Phillips deserves now is death. I wished to God that he had been killed so that I would not have to hear about this piece of garbage again. But unfortunately he has shown how much of a scumbag coward he really is. He is lucky that the police play by the rules! Phillips is nothing more than a drain on society.


Trooper Joseph A. Longobardo,you have completed your Tour of Duty and may you now Rest in Peace.





Reply to this comment
by ihatedss September 9, 2006 9:53 PM PDT
Ill make this brief, Ontario County DSS NY
took my *3 DAY OLD* nursing baby from her mother and then returned the child 3 days later. They did this to be punative to me because I attempted to stand up for my rights previously regarding a 4th amendment violation.

The state troopers didnt like that I told them they need a warrant to inspect my home and threatened to arrest me 'for obstruction of justice'. I should have let them. They are the real criminals. As in this case, they shouldnt have taken the grandkids. Our system isnt supposed to work this way.
DSS needs to be reigned in more than the BATF Currently DSS officers are completely
immune and that is not how our system is supposed to work. Separately, I even think 'family court' (a misnomer) isnt even constitutional.

The problem is that most lawyers have kids and are AFRAID of DSS taking their kids. We need to sue the state for abolishment of DSS.

Reply to this comment
by diamondp50 September 9, 2006 10:59 PM PDT
prophecy411 ::::

Would you get over it already. Not everybody receives help when they come from a horrid childhood, but that still doesn't give you the right to step over the line. When you get to adulthood, you know what is right and wrong and you figure it out. "Bucky" is a career criminal and he never did anything on his own to change that. So will you please GET OVER IT already. If this is all you have in his defense then you have no defense at all.
Reply to this comment
by diamondp50 September 9, 2006 11:15 PM PDT
prophecy411:::
One more thing, if it is so bad in your county, get off your ***** and change it. You have the power to make the change. Stop blaming everyone for your problems, stop waiting for handouts from the state, go out there and raise your voices to bring about change. Stop boo hooing and help yourselves. You are supposed to be an ordained minister and you make more excuses for the bad guy, and more excuses as to why things are the way they are in your county, but what I want to know is what are you, as a religious leader doing to bring your community together? What are you doing to help bring about change? Stop wasting all your energies talking your B*S* and get something positive going...Make the school and CPS answer to the community for their actions. Fight for a better system. Get out there and vote in new leaders...Put your gripes into action and quit with all the excuses.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 10, 2006 2:38 PM PDT
The so called boo hooing is giving a voice to the issues. I am stating what I am finding fault with and actively taking action against. If you are in the area please stop in and join me. I am not blaming but identifying factual information. If the government says there is help for people and tell you to come and get it and they go to get it and the government response is no, we won't help you who is at fault?
What if you are 12 years old and living in the woods with no real home because your parents told you to leave and never come back and the neighbors know it and they are all looking the other way. That is where Bucky was sent to live by his parents. Should CPS have found a foster home...yes...but they were busy chasing their tails investigating reports from people who make unfounded reports to push other peoples buttons.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 10, 2006 2:52 PM PDT
Other articles previously responded to by me regarding Bucky have postings from me stating that Bucky had no intervention prior to age 18 to help him. He is responsible for what he has done and I will stand and wave a flag with everyone condemning him for criminal acts he committed from age 18 on because you cannot pass through life without observing proper behavior and learning right from wrong.
I however will not do so without pointing out that he was completely broken before he hit age 18 and those early experiences were not healed and he formed his personality from those experiences. Is he messed up, you bet! All of you who had horrid childhoods can probably point to at least one person who changed you and you modeled yourself after for change. You however do not allow the possibility that Bucky had no one and that there are still children that had no one but other criminals to help them survive.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 10, 2006 3:18 PM PDT
Efforts have been underway for years to separate New York City from New York State as we are beyond tired of subsidizing New York City. Statistics have shown that it is a drain to the entire state to pay for things such as welfare recipients to take taxis to buy aspirin at $30.00 a pop. If businesses in New York City are hiring millions of immigrants who are using Medicaid for their health plan then the ones who are needing them should be the only ones paying their health care, but City residents are not containing these costs...it is spread across the state. They have it all... counseling... transportation... over-the-counter medications FREE on me and all other residents of New York State. People who try to move to another adjacent state and apply for welfare are offered the following: that state will pay someone to move to New York and set them up in an apartment so that they will no longer seek assistance from the state the applied for assistance in because New York pays the most benefits in all areas - and people take the offer. I sure feel the drain in my pocketbook. You get to wait years for urgent mental health care here. My husband works too hard and we don't even get back 1/3 of the taxes he pays in our tax return. The city needs to separate and pay for those living in that geographic location. Erie County was the first to go bankrupt under this system and we are soon behind them and elections require money that is obviously not in our pockets.
Reply to this comment
by diamondp50 September 10, 2006 7:10 PM PDT
prophecy411
I ran away from the abuse at age 11 the first time, the cops threw me back into the hell. I didn't have one teacher that ever came to me and say "how can I help". My grandparents were as messed up as my parents and the gp's/siblings on my mom's side could have cared less, except for one Uncle that molested me for a couple of years. I had a son at 15 and the nurse insisted I was better off giving my son up which I did to the very people who I called parents. I didn't have a clue about life, about right & wrong, or how to make a decision. I quit school at age 15, and before that ran away time and time again, sleeping in old cars and worse in the middle of winter. I never stole from anyone, and I was never busted. I was cold, hungry, scared & alone. I didn't see my 2(by this time)sons or my siblings for 5 years as I ran from the fear. I was married 4 times to wife abusers from 15 to 33 all the while trying to "make a life". It took almost 25 years to even start to get it right and I still made alot of mistakes because I had no direction from anyone. Today I am 48 years old, have my GED, MY BA in Criminology, a good relationship w/both my sons, a beautiful daughter and 6 grandkids. I work in a great job and I did it w/out help. There are millions of people like Bucky and I, some have it worse than we did, the difference is that most of us chose be something, no matter how hard we had to work and struggle to get there. Bucky chose his path and he did that on his own.
Reply to this comment
by prophecy411 September 11, 2006 8:21 AM PDT
diamondp50 - I am soooo truly sorry that your life was like that. You deserved so much better. Unfortunately this proves part of what I am trying to communicate. The system failed me as a child, and defnately you as a child and obviously Bucky as a child. I praise God that like you I overcame severe abuse and did something constructive. I congratulate you for your success. Your strength is admirable and my prayers are with you for continued success in your field. I understand your anger but please understand from a pastoral point of view one of the greatest crimes in this world is an absence of love in your heart for others. You can love people and refuse to condone and even despise their actions. So many people come to know God in prison because it is the first time they receive genuine love from anyone. Sometimes the hardest part of my job is to express God's love to someone who has committed a repulsive crime. I am called to remember whatever I might feel, God loves that person and will forgive them 100% if they ask.
Reply to this comment
See all 42 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs