February 11, 2009 6:07 PM

Hate Those Pesky Geese? Grab Your Gun

(AP)  They tried border collies in Virginia. They tried a stuffed coyote in New Jersey. In fact, officials nationwide have tried just about everything to get rid of large flocks of Canada geese that move in, eat the grass and leave lots of unwanted poop.

Until now, geese foes have had to obtain permits from the government to kill the geese or destroy their nests and eggs — and that hasn't been easy. But the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has issued a new rule making it easier for farmers, airports, landowners and public health officials to kill the geese without permits.

The new rule went into effect last week.

Animal rights activists say there's got to be a better way to deal with the birds. But people who consider the geese a nuisance are applauding the measure.

Rep. Jim Saxton, R-N.J., who has been working to control the geese population for years, said, "This day has been a long time in coming.

"Canada geese are larger and more aggressive than native waterfowl," Saxton said. "They have upset the natural ecology of our waterways."

The new rule includes several provisions, which now allow:

  • Airports, public health officials and landowners to destroy nests and eggs without federal permits.
  • Private and public airports to round up the birds for destruction without federal permits.
  • Local governments to round up the birds if they threaten public health by congregating at reservoirs, athletic fields, parks and public beaches.

    The new rule also lets states establish August hunting seasons for the birds. The existing hunting season is Sept. 1 to March 10.

    The Fish and Wildlife Service said the rule was prompted in response to "growing impacts from overabundant populations of resident Canada geese." The agency said in the Atlantic Flyway, the resident Canada goose population has increased an average of 2 percent per year over the past four years and was estimated at 1.15 million this past spring.

    "This final rule offers the essential flexibility needed for effective natural resource management," Service Director Dale Hall said in a statement.

    John Hadidian, urban wildlife program director for The Humane Society of the United States, said the Fish and Wildlife Service is trying to bring down the resident Canada goose population by 1 million birds.

    "That means killing that many birds every year, for the next 10 years," Hadidian said. "That's appalling."

    The Human Society says the reason so many would have to be killed to reduce the population is because on average, a goose will have five eggs at a time in a nest, which take about a month to incubate. And if a nest is destroyed, a female goose often will simply lay another group of eggs.

    Hadidian said communities have resorted to various measures to get rid of the birds, ranging from sterilizing eggs or destroying nests to rounding up the birds when they are molting and unable to fly and taking them to commercial poultry houses where they are killed.

    He said the new rule destroys any way for his organization and others to keep track of how the geese are being eliminated. The Humane Society favors measures that would create places where the birds can migrate to without being a nuisance to humans.

    "They are very smart birds and they learn right away where they are and are not tolerated," Hadidian said.

    The geese are attracted to mowed and fertilized grass, which is why they tend to gather at golf courses, airports and parks. Businesses or communities inundated by geese either call companies like National Goose Control in East Hanover, N.J., to help them gain permits so eggs and nests can be destroyed, or they resort to other measures.

    In Saltville, Va., two border collies named Annie and Risk, were unleashed to run off the geese. That worked. In Fair Lawn, N.J., officials put a stuffed coyote on a float in a municipal pool hoping to scare off the geese. The coyote was snatched, and the geese stayed.
  • © 2009 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
    Add a Comment See all 11 Comments
    by gails1960 August 19, 2006 8:40 PM EDT
    i live in wyoming where we have to contend with the growing wolf and grizzly population. the geese seem to be a nuisance but nothing else. on the other hand the wolves kill livestock that are part of someones livlihood. so excuse me for not feeling sorry for those that must put up with a little poo
    Reply to this comment
    by cornflower3 August 18, 2006 11:14 PM EDT
    wonder if the dogs can collect unemployment
    Reply to this comment
    by cdgsonc August 18, 2006 3:53 PM EDT
    Sorry, but because of the 1500 charcater limit, my soapbox speech actually starts four posts down.
    CD
    Reply to this comment
    by cdgsonc August 18, 2006 3:51 PM EDT
    ...
    Hopefully, this new law will provide community officials with a better means for scaring them off.

    The Canadian geese are no longer migratory birds. They have found paradise in our year round warm climate (compared to Canada). They no longer have to go "way" south for the winter because there is never a winter in North Carolina anymore! They just stay here year long. With freshly manicured lawns and abundant water supplies why wouldn't it be a paradise? More and more neighborhoods are being developed in the outskirts of cities, and more and more storm water ponds have to be built. This is the natural attraction for these geese that land in these small ponds and then walk up into neighboring lawns throughout the day and leave big piles of feces every five feet. Please understand that this is not the run of the mill songbird dropping that occasionally hits your windshield; this is a literal PILE of ****!
    Too much of any type fertilizer will kill grass and plants. Not to mention that it stains driveways and sidewalks so that the dark green and black stain can't be removed without a pressure washer. And I would like to enjoy my yard, and so would my children. There's nothing worse than playing catch in your yard just to end up slipping in goose feces.

    Canadian Geese are a menace and they need to be controlled, plain and simple.
    ...
    Reply to this comment
    by cdgsonc August 18, 2006 3:50 PM EDT
    I can%u2019t post but 1500 characters at a time, but here%u2019s my rant.

    These two must not live in an area that is flooded with these pests. The laws that will be put into effect will still have specific restrictions for instance in my neighborhood where they are an extreme problem, I still won't be able to walk out on my front lawn and shoot them. I've done a lot of research on better ways to rid my lawn of these animals. I've bought motion sensor water sprinklers; grape juice repellant specifically geared toward geese, blow horns at them, installed fake owls and foxes, and had the dogs to chase them only to find out that they are just as mean! These geese are smart enough to walk around the deterrents.
    ...
    Reply to this comment
    by mlangaard August 18, 2006 2:48 PM EDT
    Once again Fish & Wildlife is against fish & wildlife. Since when is pooping a crime? Just another license to kill!
    Reply to this comment
    by starlady2 August 18, 2006 2:41 PM EDT
    If Rep. Jim Saxton, R-N.J., reaction to Friday, May 26, 2006; Posted: 1:21 p.m. EDT (17:21 GMT)
    WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Police were searching the Rayburn building in the Capitol complex Friday after reports of gunfire in a garage in the building-- just imagine rifle touting shooting at everything in site under the pretext that they have the green light from US Fish & Wildlife ruling. Who is liable for those "accidental killings" of human beings? MANAGE THAT!!!
    Reply to this comment
    by doubler-ms August 18, 2006 2:21 PM EDT
    Your confusing the issues at hand. Again. The article is about problematic resident, nonmigratory Canada geese in urban areas. With all due respect, please reread the article.
    Reply to this comment
    by starlady2 August 18, 2006 2:14 PM EDT
    Sound wildlife management!!! How about Creating 'human-animals' for research, or EPA May Allow Pesticide & Chemical Experiments on Children & Adults! How about "BRIDGETON -- An executive of a Vineland chemical company pleaded guilty recently to accusations that he allowed his employees to dump contaminated waste into a retention pond, the Attorney General's Office announced Friday. Kumar Ogale, 45, of Thorofare, vice president of TransWeb LLC on West Forest Grove Road, pled guilty before Superior Court Judge John Waters on July 31." How about managing these monsters!


    Reply to this comment
    by doubler-ms August 18, 2006 1:54 PM EDT
    Sound wildlife management, plain and simple. waterfowl DO NOT provide down until they are being plucked for consumption. Their "fertilizer" is fecal waste. It does not belong on walkways and public use areas. Conservation is the wise use - key word use - of our natural resources to ensure its perpetuity. Hunters will utilize the meat, which is delicious. The population will be stabilized through hunting to parameters of benefit to both the geese themselves and to society. far more efficient use of human resources than following teh geese with poop scoopers?
    Reply to this comment
    See all 11 Comments
    .
    Scroll Left
    Scroll Right More »
    CBS News on Facebook