The Dot-Degree Boom

The Nation: Online Education Gets The Green Light

(The Nation) 

In October 2001, President Bush nominated Stroup to be assistant secretary of education overseeing postsecondary education, and to run the distance trial program. Three weeks later, she resigned as a Phoenix lobbyist. (This month, Stroup left the Education Department and returned to Congress as a legislative staffer to work on education law.) Still, even with Phoenix safely placed in the trial program, the law remained on the books, which could have spelled disaster for the company if it again came under scrutiny.

Boehner started pushing to get rid of the "50 percent" rule in 2001 with the Internet Equity and Education Act. He tried again with the Expanding Opportunities in Higher Education Act and the Fed Up Higher Education Technical Amendments Act. The provision almost made it into a Hurricane Katrina relief bill, and was part of the College Access and Opportunity Act, which is still pending. But the passage of the Deficit Reduction Act last month makes that effort moot. Days after Boehner became majority leader, a two-paragraph provision eliminating the "50 percent" rule slipped into the Deficit Reduction Act. It is expected to cost taxpayers more than $700 million over the next decade.

A small group of legislators including Boehner, the former head of the House Education Committee, and his successor in that post, Representative McKeon, have been favored by Phoenix and others in the for-profit college industry.

According to the Center for Responsive Politics, the two Congressmen and their political action committees have received $313,000 from the for-profit college industry since 2000.

Peter Sperling and John Sperling, Phoenix's largest stockholders, have given more than $550,000 to politicians and PACs of all stripes since 1997. In the past two years, Apollo's PAC has given $30,000 to the National Republican Congressional Committee, John Sperling has given $15,000 and recently departed CEO Todd Nelson gave $25,000 to the Republican National Committee and $20,000 to the NRCC. Apollo also has its own PAC funded by its executives, employees and advisers.

A 2004 Chronicle of Higher Education investigation found that over 18 months, those in the student loan and for-profit school industries gave $1 million in campaign contributions to the forty-nine members of the House Committee on Education. About $540,000 went to Boehner and McKeon, representing 20 percent and 45 percent, respectively, of the total revenues for their leadership PACs.

Losing Out

That may help to explain why Phoenix seems to have two sets of parents: a coddling, permissive Congress and allies like Stroup on the policy side, and the stern, accountable financial aid regulators and Inspector General in the Education Department.

Increasingly, it looks like the regulators are losing out, with Congress quietly bowing to the for-profit educational lobby by nixing the "50 percent" rule and playing hooky on a serious discussion of how to leverage billions of federal student aid dollars each year to insure quality education now and into the future.

Tyrone Jacobs' saga with Axia ended on March 22, leaving him nearly a year and a bit less than $5,000 in the hole. He withdrew from one class in the second-to-last week because the teacher told him he couldn't catch up. He was "auto-dropped" from another, for failure to engage in an online class discussion on the designated day. Jacobs called it an honest mistake, but Axia officials, with his tuition firmly in hand, called it a violation of strict policy. No refunds are available.

Now Jacobs will try again, possibly at a nonprofit online program, one that might cost about one-third of Axia. He hopes to transfer his credits, straighten out his financial aid and get his education back on track, moving toward an associate's degree — to try to get ahead. Eventually, he hopes to earn a business degree at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock.

"The question is: Do you want to rush into funding these schools with public money before you're sure the protections are in place to make sure [students] are getting a quality education, because that's ultimately what we want," said California Deputy Attorney General Robyn Smith, whose office handles cases of fraud involving for-profit schools.

Much as Congress avoided explicitly posing Smith's question, it implicitly provided an answer: Phoenix, Axia and other online education businesses now have virtually no impediments to growth. The dot-degree boom begins.