• Show Search Options  • Search Tips


Section Front

War On TerrorWar On Terror
Iraq After SaddamIraq After Saddam

Photos

Week In PhotosWeek In Photos
Check out the week's most compelling pictures.
Week In Photos

Interactive

The LeakThe Leak
People and events surrounding the leak of a CIA officer's name.
The Leak

Interactive

Samuel A. Alito Jr.Samuel A. Alito Jr.
Profile of the latest Supreme Court nominee and the steps required for his confirmation.
Samuel A. Alito Jr.




E-Mail This StoryPrintable Version

Supreme Court to Hear Tribunals Challenge

WASHINGTON, Nov. 7, 2005
(AP)


(AP) The Supreme Court agreed Monday to consider a challenge to the Bush administration's military tribunals for foreign terror suspects, a major test of the government's wartime powers.

Justices will decide whether Osama bin Laden's former driver can be tried for war crimes before military officers in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Chief Justice John Roberts, as an appeals court judge, joined a summer ruling against Salim Ahmed Hamdan. He did not participate in Monday's action, which put him in the difficult situation of sitting in judgment of one of his own rulings.

The court's intervention piles more woes on the Bush administration, which has already suffered one set of losses at the Supreme Court and has been battered by international criticism of its detention policies.

"I think it's a black eye for the Bush administration. This opens a Pandora's box," said Michael Greenberger, a Justice Department attorney in the Clinton administration and law professor at the University of Maryland.

In 2004 justices took up the first round of cases stemming from the government's war on terrorism. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who is retiring, wrote in one case that "a state of war is not a blank check for the president when it comes to the rights of the nation's citizens."

Arguments in the Hamdan case will be scheduled next spring, in time for O'Connor's successor to take part. Bush has named Samuel Alito, an appeals court judge, to replace her. In his lower court decisions Alito has been deferential to government.

The announcement of the court's move came shortly after President Bush, asked about reports of secret U.S. prisons in Eastern Europe for terrorism suspects, declared anew that his administration does not torture suspects.

"There's an enemy that lurks and plots and plans and wants to hurt America again," Bush said during a joint news conference in Panama City with President Martin Torrijos. "So you bet we will aggressively pursue them but we will do so under the law."

Hamdan's case brought a new issue to the court _ the rights of foreigners who have been charged and face a military trial in a type of proceeding resurrected from World War II. Trials of Hamdan and three other low-level suspects were interrupted last year when a judge in Washington said the proper process had not been followed.

The men are among about 500 foreigners, many swept up in the U.S.-led war in Afghanistan, who have been held at the U.S. military prison in Cuba. The government had planned to proceed with a military trial for another foreigner, Australian David M. Hicks, with a pretrial hearing later this month, but that will likely be stalled now.

Guantanamo Bay has become a flash point for criticism of America overseas and by civil libertarians. Initially, the Bush administration refused to let the men see attorneys or challenge their imprisonment. The high court in 2004 said U.S. courts were open to filings from the men, who had been designated enemy combatants.

Retired military leaders, foreign legislators, historians and other groups had pressed the Supreme Court to review the case of Hamdan, who like many Guantanamo inmates began a hunger strike over the summer.

A three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, including Roberts, ruled against Hamdan, finding that the 1949 Geneva Convention governing prisoners of war does not apply to al-Qaida and its members.

The ruling was handed down shortly before Roberts was named to the Supreme Court. Ethics experts have disagreed over whether Roberts should have recused himself from that case, because he was being interviewed for the Supreme Court while the matter was pending.

The administration argued that it was unnecessary for the court to hear Hamdan's case because the Pentagon had relaxed the rules for tribunals, enabling classified information to be shared with defendants "to the extent consistent with national security, law enforcement interests and applicable law." The government also changed the structure of the panels that will hear the cases and decide the men's punishment, with death sentences possible.

Hamdan's lawyer, Georgetown University professor Neal Katyal, said in a filing that "it is a contrived system subject to change at the whim of the president."

"With constantly shifting terms and conditions, the commissions resemble an automobile dealership instead of a legal tribunal dispensing American justice and protecting human dignity," he wrote.

Hamdan's attorneys may ask Roberts to participate in the case to avoid a 4-4 tie.

Hamdan, who was captured in Afghanistan in November 2001, denies conspiring to engage in acts of terrorism and denies he was a member of al-Qaida. He has been charged with conspiracy to commit war crimes, murder and terrorism.

The case is Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, 05-184.

___

On the Net:

Military tribunals: http://www.defenselink.mil/news/commissions.html

Supreme Court: http://www.supremecourtus.gov/


MMV The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Back To Top  Back To Top



E-Mail AlertsRSS FeedsPodcasts
Advertisement

Go To CBS News Video

TOP VIDEOS

Watch VideoMajor U.S. Ally Killed In Iraq | E-Mail

Watch VideoGreenspan On Housing Market | E-Mail

Watch VideoHumberto's Aftermath  | E-Mail

Watch VideoBarack's Running Mate | E-Mail

More Video

  • Show Search Options  • Search Tips
Wireless Alerts:  CBS News To Go  E-Mail Sign-Up:  Breaking News  |  Today On CBS News  |  60 Minutes  |  48 Hours  |  The Early Show  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  News Summaries

Recommended Sites:  CBS Corporation  |  The ShowBuzz  |  Wallstrip  |  CBS.com  |  CBSSports.com  |  CWTV.com  |  ETOnline.com  |  The INSIDER  |  CBS Store  |  CBS Careers  |  CBS Cares
Breaking News© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.