'Survivor:' The Glazed Temptation

New Star On Their Side, Koror Faces Sticky Decisions; Boots Diva-Male

(CBS) 

After reading her tree mail, which she was instructed to pack her bags and go over to Koror's island, she started squealing.

"Oh my gosh. That's awesome!" she said. "I'm gonna have friends."

That's not all.

"I hope I don't cry when I see them," exasperated, she went on. "They're gonna be like, 'What's wrong with this lunatic psycho?!'"

But the new girl was welcomed with open arms. Katie Gallagher, Jenn and Steph had a serious bonding walk through the woods in which they talked personal hygiene, hookups and miscellaneous topics more fitted for "Sex and the City" than "Survivor: Palau."

She showed her Philly roots when taking a tour of the hut.

"Their place is just sic!" she told the cameras.

But before too much bonding could be done, two native Palauans showed up in a reed canoe to teach the survivors how to fish. But Coby caused some drama, the source of which was unclear. He either wanted to fish or didn't want to fish, and whatever Ian, Gregg and Tom said, it didn't seem to help.

They left Coby at the shore.

Not only did the men, who fished into the sunset, come back with 13 fish and a lobster, but they also brought back a bottle of rum. Everyone filled their bellies with the fish, and, apparently, had quite a few swigs of rum to wash it down with.

"With you came the party!" someone said to Stephenie across the table in the dark night.

Before the end of the meal, Tom was stumbling on his words, saying something that resembled, "I knew we needed new l-l-legs" before falling off his bench.

But the hardworking firefighter was the first one awake in the morning, trying to make some redeeming fish catches.

"Stephenie's going to add a whole new layer to this game," Coby said before pulling her off to the side to share gossip. But his version of the alliances didn't seem to match the ladies'. Steph hopped back over to her girls to share what Coby said, though it wasn't clear whom she believed.

For the immunity challenge, each survivor was given a pedestal in the water to stand on. Whoever stayed put the longest would win immunity.

But after an hour and no motion, a trio of donuts made the situation stickier. Instead of diving in immediately, though, Coby brought out his bargaining skills. If more than one tribesmember would jump, how many donuts would each get? Coby wanted at least two. "I could do two," host Jeff Probst said.

Janu and Coby jumped.

"What does it say when two people voluntarily give up immunity for a couple of donuts?" Jeff asked the tribe.

"Either they want to go home or they don't think they're in danger of going home," Katie said.

After 2 hours and 23 minutes of standing on pedestals, Jeff came out with a tray of chocolate chip cookies and milk. Before he could say what it was…

"I have with me a tray of 15 coo…" Jeff uttered.

Four of the standers jumped off.

Three remained.

But a pizza stood between them and immunity.

Only Tom, who wasn't strong against native rum, was strong enough to stand and not leave the perch to eat.

Immediately, tribal council followed the challenge. Steph has seen the flames and vote readings nearly a dozen times, but the other tribesmembers were unfamiliar. So, too, were some of the women with the planned outcome of the evening.

Janu thought she'd be voted out, as did Steph. But instead, Coby took a steady string of votes.

He seemed sad as he said, "They did give me a chance to be a part of the team." For more of Coby's thoughts on the life and times of Koror, tune in to Friday's The Early Show.