BOSTON, July 14, 2004
Gays Battle 1913 Massachusetts Law
Suing To Overturn Law Restricting Weddings For Out-Of-Staters
-
Play CBS Video Video Politics Of Same-Sex Ban Jim Axelrod reports the polls show gay marriage is the top social issue this election year, with the majority of Americans against it, but also against a constitutional ban.
-
-
Banned in Boston: Amy Zimmerman (left) and Tanya Wexler of New York, who've been together for over 12 years, are among those suing to overturn the law preventing their marriage in Massachusetts. (AP)
-
A case of states' rights: that is the argument being made by Massachusetts Assistant Attorney General Peter Sacks, seen here speaking in court on behalf of the 1913 law. (AP)
-
-
Interactive Gay In The U.S.A. State-by-state laws on gay issues, the marriage debate and photo essays.
-
Photo Essay Married In Massachusetts Couples exchange vows in the nation's first state-sanctioned same-sex weddings.
-
Interactive Same-Sex Marriage Debate State-by-state coverage, opinions, history, photos and a look at the amendment process.
Their attorney, Michele Granda of Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders (GLAD), told Superior Court Judge Carol Ball that the law is discriminatory and should be struck down. Granda also asked for an injunction blocking the state from enforcing the law, which she says violates the U.S. Constitution.
"We're asking the court to tear down the fence of discrimination," said Granda, who wound up arguing the case at the same time as the U.S. Senate mulled a
Massachusetts Attorney General Thomas Reilly has said that the since the eight couples are not from Massachusetts - two are from Connecticut, two are from Rhode Island, and one each are from New Hampshire, Vermont, Maine and New York - they do not have the legal standing to challenge the 1913 law.
Arguing the case in court Tuesday, Assistant Massachusetts State Attorney General Peter Sacks defended the 1913 Bay State law as protecting other states' rights to define marriage as they see fit, a principle repeatedly cited by the Massachusetts high court in its landmark November ruling legalizing same-sex marriage.
That ruling, said Sacks, defines marriage as "two willing spouses and an approving state." Since no other state allows same-sex marriage, he said, that standard is not met anywhere but Massachusetts.
Judge Ball gave the state until Aug. 2 to file its response. She did not say when she would rule, but noted: "From what I've read so far, it appears the state is applying the law in a procedurally non-discriminatory manner."
Republican Gov. Mitt Romney, a same-sex marriage opponent, has invoked the 1913 law to bar same-sex couples from other states from getting married here.
When same-sex marriages began May 17, some municipal clerks openly defied Romney and issued licenses to anyone who applied. But Massachusetts' attorney general, acting on Romney's instructions, ordered them to stop.
Legal experts have said the law was passed to prevent interracial couples from getting married. But the attorney general has said there is no evidence lawmakers were motivated by race.
At any rate, the law was ignored for decades before the high court cleared the way for the nation's first state-sanctioned same-sex weddings to begin this past spring, Granda said.
Sacks did not dispute that assertion. "Certainly enforcement has been increased because there's much more reason than there was before to expect violations," he said.
Granda also argued the state is treating different groups of people unequally by enforcing the law. "The commonwealth can't use its formidable authority to bar gays and lesbians from marrying simply because they are gays and lesbians," she said.
Sacks said, however, that Massachusetts' enforcement of the law respects other states' rights. "People can come here from out of state to get married, if they're coming from a jurisdiction where it's recognized," he said.
Five of the couples who filed the lawsuit were married in Massachusetts by clerks who ignored the 1913 law, while the three others were turned away when they tried to get marriage licenses.
İMMIV, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
CBSNews.com On Digg
More From U.S.
Gen. Ray Odierno, head of multinational forces in Iraq, on progress there and plans for Afghanistan.
