EUGENE, Ore., April 9, 2004

Safety Glass: Anything But?

Used In Hospitals, Schools As Fire Deterrent, But Serious Concerns

  • Play CBS Video Video Hazards Of 'Safety' Glass

    Sandra Hughes reports a common kind of wired glass used in buildings to help slow the spread of potential fires can be very unsafe in other circumstances.

  • Wired safety glass can be hazardous for those who collide with it.

    Wired safety glass can be hazardous for those who collide with it.  (CBS)

  • Special Report Consumer Alert!

    Don't get taken! Check out our special coverage section. Know of a scam that needs investigating? Tell us about it! scams@cbsnews.com

(CBS)  Instead of blocking a shot, high school senior Brett Turman shattered his lifelong dreams.

The accident cost him the full use of his right hand and any chance for a college basketball scholarship. Twelve-year-old Zech Darmanin crashed through a window while rollerblading.

"I thought, 'Oh my gosh, I'm going to die,'" says Darmanin.

He lost half his blood, and as CBS News Correspondent Sandra Hughes reports, he's still in bandages.

"It was just horrible," says his mother Lisa Darmanin.

She says it looked like he got cut with a chainsaw.

"It didn't look like he got cut with glass," she says.

The young men were injured by wired glass used in schools, hospitals and athletic facilities as a fire deterrent. Often referred to as safety glass, its critics call it anything but.

"When it is impacted, you not only break through the glass but you also go through the wire," says Greg Abel, of Advocates for Safe Glass.

Abel launched a one-man crusade against wired glass after his son was severely injured.

"Once you go through you have to try to come back out, and all these shards of glass are being held into this penetrated opening," says Abel.

A study by an Emory University professor found most of the 2,500 annual glass door injuries in schools involve wired glass, because it's only half the strength of regular plate glass, critics say.

Back in 1977 the consumer product safety commission gave the manufacturers of wired glass a temporary exemption from strength requirements because at the time, it was the only kind of glass that slowed the spread of fire.

"Wired glass slows the spread of fire by staying in place, staying in the frame and not allowing flames and hot gasses to pass through the opening," says Willam Koffel, a spokesman for the wired glass industry.

Oregon state senator Vicki Walker says the consumer product safety commission dropped the ball.

"They're not doing anything about wired glass," says Walker. "The injuries are there."

Walker convinced her state to ban wired glass in all new construction and replace it in some old schools.

The wired glass industry vows to fight any kind of similar blanket ban. The consumer product safety commission and the industry say the number of injuries cannot be confirmed.

"Wired glass would be a safe product when used properly," says Koffel.

But not according to Abel, who worries about the thousands of old buildings with wired glass.

"It's extremely frightening because it's an accident waiting to happen," he says.

Accidents that have left behind painful memories and devastating scars.


© MMIV, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx

CBSNews.com On Digg

Exclusive Webshow

Gen. Ray Odierno, head of multinational forces in Iraq, on progress there and plans for Afghanistan. Watch Now

  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Lieberman May Torpedo Health Care Reform

    (333 recent comments)

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: