SEARCH: CBSNews.com The Web
CBSNews.com
   ET

Section Front
E-mail This StoryE-mail This Story  Printable VersionPrintable Version

New WTC Death Toll Is 2,752

NEW YORK, Oct. 30, 2003



 (Photo: AP)



Among the names deleted are 4-year-old Barrett Vanvelzer and his 11-month-old brother, Edward, and their father, Paul Herman Vanvelzer - a case that had attracted attention because no other children were reported killed except on planes.


(AP) Forty names listed on the World Trade Center death toll for more than two years were removed Wednesday because the city cannot confirm their deaths or - in some cases - their existence.

The list was cut from 2,792 to 2,752, a decision made by several city agencies, including the medical examiner's office, the police department and the mayor's office.

The names removed include illegal immigrants whose jobs were not well documented and people whose relatives say they were near the trade center on Sept. 11, 2001, but know little more.

Among the 40 names deleted from the list were those of 4-year-old Barrett Vanvelzer, his 11-month-old brother, Edward, and their father, Paul Herman Vanvelzer. Authorities had said that they were reported missing by a California woman who said she was their grandmother. Their case had attracted attention because the boys would have been the only children to die in the attacks other than several youngsters on the hijacked airliners.

Officials had no immediate comment Wednesday on why the three names were taken off the list.

Thousands of names landed on the list in the chaos immediately after the attack, when worried callers swamped the city's "missing" hot lines to report a friend or relative they hadn't heard from.

Missing-person reports poured in from around the world, many from people who gave only sketchy information, partial phone numbers, misspelled names and few details.

The city formed a group called the Reported Missing Committee, charged with weeding out fraud and crossing errors off the death list, which peaked at 6,700 two weeks after the attack.

As of early September 2003, police had made about 40 arrests related to people falsely claiming they lost loved ones, and law enforcement agencies in other cities have nabbed others.

In most cases, victims whose remains have not been identified have been legally declared dead by the court and their families issued death certificates based on documents or other proof they were at the trade center or on the hijacked airplanes.

In the names removed Wednesday, no such proof was ever found and remains were never identified. About 60 percent of the victims have had remains identified.

The tally had stood at 2,792 since December 2002.

Days before the first anniversary remembrance last year, the city released its list of 2,801 names, which were read aloud by relatives and dignitaries. By that December, city officials removed nine of the names. One was a duplication, one was fabricated by a woman allegedly trying to defraud victims' charities and seven had been wrongly reported missing.

Here are the names that authorities removed from the World Trade Center fatalities list:


Jesus Acevedo-Rescand
Arturo Alva-Moreno
Patrick Asante
Nathaly Barrios La Cruz
Genieve Bonsignore
Ethel Brown
Steve Carey
Margarito Casillas
Jose Manuel Contreras-Fernandez
Nana Danso
Rafael Arturo Diaz
Osseni Garba
Joel Guevara Gonzalez
Eduardo Hernandez
Abid Hussain
Fernando Jimenez-Molinar
Guylene Joseph
William Lutz
Rene Padilla-Chvarria
Victor Martinez Pastrana
Jisley McNish
Diakite Minata
Mehmood Naseem
Luis Norales/Morales
Frank Oni
Gerard Phillips
Carlos Quishpe-Cuaman
Juan Romero Orozco
Neoraha Sadaranghgani
Mohammad Ali Sadeque
Jorge Octavio Santos Anaya
Sheila Scott
Kulwant Singh
Keisha Smith
Shell Tester
Sumati Thakur
Renu Vaidea
Barrett Vanvelzer
Edward Vanvelzer
Paul Herman Vanvelzer


By Sara Kugler © MMIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
INSIDE War On Terror
U.S. Intel: Qaeda Plotting 'Big Bang'
CBS News Reports Major Terror Attack Planned For Iraq

Key GOP Lawmaker Blasts Ports Deal
Senate Resoundingly Renews Patriot Act
Judge Questions Gitmo Force-Feeding
• More
TOP STORIES
Tight Security Greets Bush In Pakistan
Air Force One Lands At Pakistani Airbase After Dark With Lights Off

Settlement Ends BlackBerry Patent Suit
'Cell Phone Bandit' Gets 12 Years
Day Of Calm In Baghdad
• More

Back to Top Back To Top


Help  |  Advertise | Contact Us  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  CBS News Bios  |  CBS.com  |  CBS SportsLine.com  |  Internships
©MMV, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.


War On TerrorWar On Terror
Iraq After SaddamIraq After Saddam

Sept. 11 And Since
Enter
Chart the sequence of events on Sept. 11 and look back on the challenging days that followed.

The Heart Of The Tragedy
Enter
CBS News' John Roberts reports on terror's toll, with a complete list of the lives lost Sept. 11.

Bin Laden & Al Qaeda
Enter
Where al Qaeda operates, who's been caught, how they're financed and a timeline of attacks on Americans.

Story StoryGo

Pearl Murder, 9/11 - Same Guy?
Story StoryGo

Daniel Pearl's Killers Still On Loose
Story StoryGo

Mastermind: 9/11 Plot Began In '96
Story StoryGo

Alleged Pearl Killer Captured
Story StoryGo

Pearl Body Returns Home
Story StoryGo

Body Is Pearl's
Story StoryGo

Daniel Pearl Killers Appeal
Story StoryGo

Death Sentence In Daniel Pearl Case
Story StoryGo

Baby Born To Daniel Pearl's Widow




Sign up: E-Mail Alerts

RSS Feeds

Podcasts