SEARCH: CBSNews.com The Web
CBSNews.com
   ET

Section Front
E-mail This StoryE-mail This Story  Printable VersionPrintable Version

No Trial Date For Gitmo Detainees

WASHINGTON, Sept. 11, 2003


Cells in Camp Delta at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Cuba, where terror suspects have been held by the U.S. since the beginning of the war in Afghanistan nearly two years ago. (Photo: AP)



The Guantanamo Bay detention center holds about 660 men from 42 countries detained for alleged links to Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda terror network and/or the ousted Afghan Taliban regime that sheltered it.

Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld says the Pentagon is prepared to put the suspects on trial if that decision is made by President Bush. (Photo: AP)


WHY TRIBUNALS?
The crimes for which tribunals may now be used, according to the Pentagon, are:

  • Willful killing of persons
  • Attacking civilians
  • Attacking civilian objects
  • Attacking protected property
  • Pillaging
  • Denying quarter
  • Taking hostages
  • Using poisonous weapons
  • Using persons as shields
  • Using property as shields
  • Mutilation or maiming
  • Use of treachery or perfidy
  • Improper use of flag of truce
  • Improper use of emblems
  • Degrading a dead body
  • Rape
  • Hijacking
  • Terrorism
  • Murder
  • Destruction of property
  • Aiding the enemy
  • Spying
  • Perjury or false testimony
  • Obstruction of justice
    CBS



  • (AP) Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld says most suspected terrorists at a U.S. prison camp in Cuba will probably be detained for the course of the global war on terrorism rather than face trial. That sparked criticism from lawyers who said U.S. legal tradition insists on a transparent and open judicial process.

    Rumsfeld said Wednesday he expects some trials but prefers that most continue to be held at the Guantanamo Bay facility.

    "Our interest is in not trying them and letting them out," he said. "Our interest is in - during this global war on terror - keeping them off the streets, and so that's what's taking place."

    Erwin Chemerinsky, law professor at University of Southern California, said there is no authority in American or international law to hold these people indefinitely with no judicial process.

    "It's outrageous," Chemerinsky said. "There are no signs that the war on terrorism is nearing an end, so the government is saying it can hold people indefinitely and likely for the rest of their lives without complying with the requirements of international law."

    Human rights groups and countries of detained nationals have criticized the United States for refusing to designate the detainees as prisoners of war under international conventions.

    The Guantanamo Bay detention center holds about 660 men from 42 countries detained for alleged links to Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda terror network or the ousted Afghan Taliban regime that sheltered it. They include three teenagers whom the military may recommend for release soon.

    Mariano-Florentino Cuellar, an assistant professor at Stanford Law School, is also critical of the government's plan. He said people are sometimes detained as enemy combatants during wars but the same reasoning doesn't apply in a nontraditional conflict like the war on terrorism.

    "It is a war that does not have an end and the battlefield is spread across the world," Cuellar said.

    "Whether an administrative or judicial process, there needs to be an accounting of why someone is being held," he said. "That's why we have a judicial process."

    Rumsfeld said the Pentagon is prepared to proceed to trial if President Bush makes that decision.

    "We have the apparatus arranged, ready, and we have a very fine group of advisers as to how to do it in the event it has to be done," he said. "But for the moment, we don't have any candidates."

    Still, the vagueness made some in the legal profession uneasy.

    "How long could that be?" asked Stephen Dycus, Vermont Law School professor. "If the answer is potentially forever, then we've really created a new institution by which we can take people, lock them away - and that's not locking them up in the same way for a common criminal, but isolating them from the world, held incommunicado, where they don't have access to counsel or the court system."

    Part of the problem with the system Rumsfeld discussed, is that there's no way to find out what's going on or to test the validity of their detention, said Dycus.

    "There has been no demonstration that we couldn't put these guys on trial; if indeed they are criminals, lock them up and keep them out of trouble," he said.


    © MMIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
    INSIDE War On Terror
    U.S. Intel: Qaeda Plotting 'Big Bang'
    CBS News Reports Major Terror Attack Planned For Iraq

    Key GOP Lawmaker Blasts Ports Deal
    Senate Resoundingly Renews Patriot Act
    Judge Questions Gitmo Force-Feeding
    • More
    TOP STORIES
    Tight Security Greets Bush In Pakistan
    Air Force One Lands At Pakistani Airbase After Dark With Lights Off

    Settlement Ends BlackBerry Patent Suit
    'Cell Phone Bandit' Gets 12 Years
    Day Of Calm In Baghdad
    • More

    Back to Top Back To Top


    Help  |  Advertise | Contact Us  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  CBS News Bios  |  CBS.com  |  CBS SportsLine.com  |  Internships
    ©MMV, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.


    War On TerrorWar On Terror
    Iraq After SaddamIraq After Saddam

    Global Terror
    Enter
    Major terrorist organizations, the FBI's most wanted and facts and photos from recent attacks.

    War On Terror
    Enter
    Complete coverage, from Afghanistan to the Showdown with Saddam.

    Court Watch
    Enter
    CBSNews.com Legal Analyst Andrew Cohen reports on the big issues and analyzes important cases of the day.

    Story StoryGo

    100 Gitmo Detainees May Go Free
    Story StoryGo

    Military Tribunals Under Fire
    Story StoryGo

    Aussie, Brits Won't Face Execution
    Story StoryGo

    U.S. Grants Brits Tribunal Timeout
    Story StoryGo

    Gitmo Journal
    Story StoryGo

    Military Tribunals For 6 Suspects
    Story StoryGo

    Why Care About Guantanamo?
    Story StoryGo

    Gitmo Gears Up For Tribunals
    Story StoryGo

    Int'l Rights Group Slams U.S.




    Sign up: E-Mail Alerts

    RSS Feeds

    Podcasts