February 11, 2009 8:45 PM
- Text
Queen Latifah Sued Over Hit Movie
(AP)
A New York lawyer who claims she had the original idea for the box-office hit "Bringing Down the House" filed a $15 million copyright lawsuit Friday against star Queen Latifah and the movie's other producers.
Marie Flaherty claims the movie is a rip-off of "Amoral Dilemma," a screenplay she wrote several years ago about a lawyer who meets a prisoner online, only to have the prisoner wreak havoc in his life.
"Bringing Down the House," a comedy starring Latifah and Steve Martin, is about a prisoner who meets a lawyer in a chat room, then weasels her way into his life in hopes he can exonerate her.
The movie has been atop the box-office charts since it was released earlier this month, raking in $83.3 million through last weekend.
Flaherty claims Boston attorney George N. Tobia Jr. agreed to represent her in 1999 as she tried to sell "Amoral Dilemma."
Just a few months later, she says, Tobia called her to say he and a family friend, screenwriter Jason Filardi, had sold a script "Jailbabe.com," the screenplay that eventually became "Bringing Down the House."
Flaherty confronted Tobia about the similarities, and he told her repeatedly that Filardi's script was a comedy, while hers was a drama, she argues in the lawsuit.
Tobia did not immediately return a call for comment.
The copyright-infringement lawsuit, filed in Manhattan federal court, seeks a minimum of $15 million — but Flaherty points out the court could award her more considering the movie's hefty gross.
The lawsuit names as defendants Tobia, Filardi and the movie's producers — including Latifah, whose real name is Dana Owens. Latifah spokeswoman Amanda Silverman did not immediately have a comment.
Hyde Park Entertainment, which produced the film, and Walt Disney Co., which distributed it, also are listed as co-defendants.
Flaherty, an attorney who plans to represent herself, did not immediately return a call for comment.
Marie Flaherty claims the movie is a rip-off of "Amoral Dilemma," a screenplay she wrote several years ago about a lawyer who meets a prisoner online, only to have the prisoner wreak havoc in his life.
"Bringing Down the House," a comedy starring Latifah and Steve Martin, is about a prisoner who meets a lawyer in a chat room, then weasels her way into his life in hopes he can exonerate her.
The movie has been atop the box-office charts since it was released earlier this month, raking in $83.3 million through last weekend.
Flaherty claims Boston attorney George N. Tobia Jr. agreed to represent her in 1999 as she tried to sell "Amoral Dilemma."
Just a few months later, she says, Tobia called her to say he and a family friend, screenwriter Jason Filardi, had sold a script "Jailbabe.com," the screenplay that eventually became "Bringing Down the House."
Flaherty confronted Tobia about the similarities, and he told her repeatedly that Filardi's script was a comedy, while hers was a drama, she argues in the lawsuit.
Tobia did not immediately return a call for comment.
The copyright-infringement lawsuit, filed in Manhattan federal court, seeks a minimum of $15 million — but Flaherty points out the court could award her more considering the movie's hefty gross.
The lawsuit names as defendants Tobia, Filardi and the movie's producers — including Latifah, whose real name is Dana Owens. Latifah spokeswoman Amanda Silverman did not immediately have a comment.
Hyde Park Entertainment, which produced the film, and Walt Disney Co., which distributed it, also are listed as co-defendants.
Flaherty, an attorney who plans to represent herself, did not immediately return a call for comment.
Popular Now in Entertainment
- Beyonce, Jay-Z post photos of Blue Ivy Carter
- "Idol": Carrey's daughter out, and then disaster
- Zsa Zsa at 95: Husband releases birthday photos
- Leslie Carter dead at 25
- Gender-bending model a runway sensation
- Madonna stalker escapes from mental hospital
- Schwarzenegger, Stallone have hospital run-in
- Will Ferrell delivers hilarious NBA player intros
- Macaulay Culkin through the years
- Beyonce shows off her post-baby body
- Paul McCartney is a star in Hollywood
- Target to release "Breaking Dawn" DVD at midnight
- Only Denzel can rescue "Safe House"
- George Clooney on his longest practical joke
- Macaulay Culkin is in good health, says rep
- "The Vow": What the critics are saying
- Madonna stalker caught by Los Angeles police
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- The Beach Boys to start party early at Grammys
- Charge against country star Rodney Atkins retired
- Montenegro almost cut off by heavy snow
- Putin's rivals face pressure, biased coverage
on Facebook
- Adele sings a cappella for Anderson Cooper
- Occupy protestors kicked out of CPAC
- CPAC: Will Sarah Palin spring a surprise?
- Beyonce and Jay-Z post first photos of Blue Ivy Carter
on CBS News






