February 11, 2009 9:46 PM
- Text
G-Rated Violence At The Movies
(CBS)
Despite the assumption that G-rated stands for "good clean fun," a new study finds that G-rated animated movies are often more violent than parents know.
A study in Wednesday's Journal of the American Medical Association is the first ever to document violent content in all 74 animated G-rated movies released on videotape.
It looked at everything from 1930s classics to 1990s blockbusters. In that time, the amount of violence in children's movies has nearly doubled to an average of nine-and-a-half minutes per film.
Researcher Kimberly Thompson of the Harvard School of Public Health couldn't find one film without a violent scene.
Even Mickey Mouse, who wields an ax to solve his problems in Fantasia, and Winnie the Pooh, who totes a shot gun, are potentially bad role models for children, the study says.
Thompson says, "What these films show are a number of different messages that children might interpret as violence as a strategy that works."
Members of the movie industry respectfully disagree, saying the rating system works well, and children know the difference between fantasy and reality.
Motion Picture Academy President Jack Valenti says, "You are talking about films that children have been watching for years and years and years, and no one has suggested to this hour that they cause anti-social behavior."
The study defines violence as one character's intent to harm another. It can be overt and premeditated, or subtle and slapstick.
Thompson says: "We're not trying to discourage people from watching these movies or say that these movies are bad. We're trying to encourage parents to be aware of what their children are watching and to engage in a dialogue with them about the violence."
The beauty of videotape, Thompson says, is that it can be paused, giving parents the opportunity to take stock of how so much violence in the name of entertainment is really striking America's children.
A study in Wednesday's Journal of the American Medical Association is the first ever to document violent content in all 74 animated G-rated movies released on videotape.
It looked at everything from 1930s classics to 1990s blockbusters. In that time, the amount of violence in children's movies has nearly doubled to an average of nine-and-a-half minutes per film.
Researcher Kimberly Thompson of the Harvard School of Public Health couldn't find one film without a violent scene.
Even Mickey Mouse, who wields an ax to solve his problems in Fantasia, and Winnie the Pooh, who totes a shot gun, are potentially bad role models for children, the study says.
Thompson says, "What these films show are a number of different messages that children might interpret as violence as a strategy that works."
Members of the movie industry respectfully disagree, saying the rating system works well, and children know the difference between fantasy and reality.
Motion Picture Academy President Jack Valenti says, "You are talking about films that children have been watching for years and years and years, and no one has suggested to this hour that they cause anti-social behavior."
The study defines violence as one character's intent to harm another. It can be overt and premeditated, or subtle and slapstick.
Thompson says: "We're not trying to discourage people from watching these movies or say that these movies are bad. We're trying to encourage parents to be aware of what their children are watching and to engage in a dialogue with them about the violence."
The beauty of videotape, Thompson says, is that it can be paused, giving parents the opportunity to take stock of how so much violence in the name of entertainment is really striking America's children.
Latest Now in National
- Josh Powell to boys: "I've got a big surprise"
- What does Steve Jobs's FBI file say?
- GOP Congressman under insider trading investigation
- Fighting and deaths continue in Syria
- Plane makes perfect belly landing
- A compromise on contraception?
- Headlines: Cruise ships banned from releasing sewage
- Steve Jobs file reveals frank assessments
- Romney on the attack
- Sandusky judge to consider out-of-county jury
- Calling all conservatives
- $26B mortgage deal: Who gets the money?
- White House to pitch contraception compromise
- Eye Opener: Humanitarian crisis in Syria
- Jason Aldean's surprising day job before music
- Anchor recovering from dog bite during broadcast
- Man accused of threatening Obama charged again
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- Oscar lands in Los Angeles after Chicago flight
- Democrats renew push for campaign finance overhaul
- SKoreans visit jointly run factory park in NKorea
- Judge allows 2 claims in archdiocese bankruptcy
on Facebook
- Tenn. father charged with murdering couple who"unfriended" daughter on Facebook
- Adele opens up about vocal cord surgery
on CBS News






