Watch CBS News

China Defends Safety Of Its Exports

Officials said today that thousands of tubes of contaminated Chinese-made toothpaste were shipped to correctional facilities and hospitals in the Southeast, in a sign that U.S. distribution of the tainted products was wider than initially thought.

Georgia state officials have confirmed to the Associated Press that toothpaste containing the chemical diethylene glycol (DEG), a poison used in some antifreeze products, was purchased by the state and distributed to two state prisons, five state psychiatric hospitals and four juvenile detention facilities. The toothpaste was removed after an alert from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

"It's being stored," Rick Beal in the purchasing division of the Georgia Department of Administrative Services told The Associated Press. "It's segregated from their operating supply. 'Do not use' signs are placed on them. And they're pending disposition."

The New York Times reported today that approximately 900,000 tubes of tainted Chinese toothpaste has shown up in prisons, juvenile detention centers and hospitals in North and South Carolina, Georgia and Florida, including some serving the general population.

State officials in Georgia and North Carolina said no illnesses have been reported, and the toothpaste in question is being replaced with brands not manufactured in China.

The report came the same day that a Chinese official defended the safety of his country's exports, taking the rare step of commenting directly on rising fears over Chinese products following toothpaste and tire recalls, as well as reports of food tainted with industrial chemicals and pigs headed for slaughter with bellies full of wastewater.

Wang Xinpei, a spokesman for the Commerce Ministry, said China "has paid great attention" to the issue, especially food safety because it concerns people's health.

"It can be said that the quality of China's exports all are guaranteed," Wang told reporters at a regularly scheduled briefing.

The statement was among Beijing's most public assertions of the safety of its exports since they came under scrutiny earlier this year with the deaths of dogs and cats in North America blamed on Chinese wheat gluten tainted with the chemical melamine.

Since then, U.S. authorities have turned away or recalled toxic fish, juice containing unsafe color additives, and popular toy trains decorated with leaded paint.

Earlier this month, a spokesman for North Carolina's Department of Correction said Pacific brand toothpaste was distributed to prisoners who could not afford to buy a name brand at prison stores. The tubes were taken away after trace amounts of DEG was found in them.

The FDA, which has stopped all imports of toothpaste from China, said DEG in toothpaste "has a low but meaningful risk of toxicity and injury" to children and individuals with kidney or liver disease, among others.

The FDA advised consumers to "avoid using tubes of toothpaste labeled as made in China," according to a statement posted on the agency's Web site.

Officials in Georgia told the Times that their investigation had located almost 6,000 cases of toothpaste containing up to 5 percent of DEG, which were removed from correctional facilities and mental health care centers. The toothpaste had been purchased as long ago as 2002, at 9 cents a tube.

Chinese-made toothpaste has also been banned by numerous countries in North and South America and Asia for containing DEG, a chemical often found in antifreeze which also serves as a low-cost — and sometimes deadly — substitute for glycerin, a sweetener in many drugs.

On Wednesday, three Japanese importers recalled millions of Chinese-made travel toothpaste sets, after they were found to contain as much as 6.2 percent diethylene glycol. No illnesses were reported.

Wang, the Commerce Ministry spokesman, said Chinese experts have already "explained the situation."

He gave no details, although the country's quality watchdog has in the past cited tests from 2000 that it said showed toothpaste containing less than 15.6 percent diethylene glycol was harmless to humans.

In the U.S., safety officials ordered a New Jersey tire importer to recall as many as 450,000 tires that it bought from a Chinese manufacturer and sold to U.S. distributors. Foreign Tire Sales Inc., of Union, New Jersey, said an unknown number of the light truck radials it imported since 2002 from Hangzhou Zhongce Rubber Co. could suffer tread separation, a problem that led to the largest tire recall in the U.S. in 2000.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration sent Foreign Tire Sales Inc. a letter stating that it is legally responsible for the recall and faces fines of up to $6,000 per violation if it fails to properly remedy the situation, with a maximum of nearly $16.4 million for any series of related violations.

The government, which has given the company until July 2 to respond to the letter sent Tuesday, said the company's argument "that it is not in a position to conduct a recall is not acceptable."

An attorney for FTS said Thursday that the company can afford only about 10 percent of the roughly $80 million in expenses associated with a full recall.

Hangzhou Zhongce said in a statement Wednesday that its tires met U.S. safety standards and FTS's specifications, accusing the U.S. company of making the claim to gain an advantage in a commercial dispute.

China appears to have gone on the offensive recently, prominently announcing rejects of foods imported from the U.S. such as orange pulp and dried apricots containing high levels of bacteria and preservatives, as well as health supplements and raisins that China said did not meet its safety standards.

"With regard to food which does not meet imported food safety standards, the Chinese side should take corresponding measures according to regulations," Wang said.

Yet, there were more reports underscoring the chaotic food safety situation in China, where manufacturers and distributors often use additives that have not been approved, falsify expiration dates, or find other ways to cut corners to eke out small profits.

On Thursday, state media said Beijing police raided a village where live pigs were force-fed wastewater to boost their weight before slaughter. Plastic pipes had been forced down the pigs' throats and villagers had pumped each 220-pound pig with 44 pounds of wastewater, the Beijing Morning Post reported.

Paperwork showed the pigs were headed for one of Beijing's main slaughterhouses and stamps on their ears indicated that they had already been through quarantine and inspection, the paper said. Suspects escaped during Wednesday's raid and no arrests were made, it said.

Earlier this week, inspectors announced they had closed 180 food factories nationwide in the first half of this year and seized tons of candy, pickles, crackers and seafood tainted with formaldehyde, illegal dyes, and industrial wax.

"These are not isolated cases," Han Yi, an official with Wei's quality administration, was quoted as saying in Wednesday's state-run China Daily newspaper.

Han's admission was significant because the agency has said in the past that safety violations were the work of a few rogue operators — a claim aimed at protecting China's billions of dollars of food exports.

Wei Chuanzhong, deputy director of the General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine, said local governments "should be fully aware of the importance and improve responsibility for imported and exported food safety."

His remarks, made during an inspection tour of the port city of Tianjin, were posted Thursday on the administration's Web site.

The Associated Press' Anita Chang in Beijing contributed to this report.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.