Last Updated Nov 12, 2009 11:24 AM EST
Kapitall makes investing feel like something entirely different -a form of play-that speaks directly to the Gaming Generation and the way they prefer to engage, learn, and interact.And de Dreuzy should know how to make it fun, since he co-founded three game production, development and consulting companies and produced titles for PC, Xbox, PlayStation and Wii systems.
"We believe that investing is an adventure - it's fun, it's challenging, and the more you get into it, the more you get out of it. Our passion is to make the experience of investing as rewarding as the results," said Gaspard de Dreuzy, Kapitall's founder and CEO.
I navigated around the beta version, and have to say it has some very cool user interfaces, much like an interactive game. Demonstrating its commitment to making investing fun, it uses terms like "playground." I can't speak to whether it makes the "e investing experience as rewarding as the results," but they've definitely got the fun thing down.
Gaming is a lot of fun, no two ways about it. And in theory it makes all kinds of sense to try and tap into the universal experience of the next generation of techie investors coming up. But theoretically is the only way it makes sense. I've written about the "make it fun" approach before when my son had to learn the stock market game in fourth grade. It was fun for him too, but my take was that it teaches short-term speculation rather than investing.
While I haven't seen the live version, I understand their revenue model is from "trading revenues and premium offerings." I can cite the evidence that higher trading leads to lower returns, that buying individual stocks is taking uncompensated risk, and churning them based on analysts' opinions doesn't work. But who's going to listen to that boring data when there's fun to be had?
Another unique aspect of this site is that it carries a social networking structure, so that consumers can "share ideas with a personalized network of like-minded investors." This sounds to me like just an updated way to follow the herd, which we also know doesn't work so well.
The site offered an interesting "investor DNA" quiz, which I took. I was classified as a "fan," which defined me as an investor who just likes to watch the market. It says, "Maybe one day you'll be one of those making millions, but for now you're building your savings and learning the ropes. Who knows? You might be the next Warren Buffett." The next Warren Buffett, me? Really? Maybe I should consult my horoscope for a second opinion.
Well, as long as they are mentioning Warren Buffett, remember his quote, "Investors should remember that excitement and expenses are their enemies." I don't know how expensive this platform will be, but I'd bet very heavily Kapitall will be exciting.
They're not exactly preaching to the choir with me, whose investing slogan happens to be "dare to be dull." Speculation is exciting and having money on the table makes it a huge rush. Unfortunately, that emotional rush quickly gives way to your money rushing out of your pocket and into the pocket of someone else. I agree with Paul Samuleson that "investing should be more like watching paint dry or watching grass grow. If you want excitement, take $800 and go to Las Vegas."
MORE ON MONEYWATCH
It's Not How Much You Pay in Costs, It's the Total Return That Matters
An Interview with Ric Edelman - Is High Cost Indexing an Oxymoron?
The Importance of Knowing What We Don't Know
The 5 Scariest Threats to Your Financial Future
Lessons from Five New Imaginary ETFs
Why We Think it's So Easy to Find a Top Performing Mutual Fund
Fact Check - Even THE WALL STREET JOURNAL Perpetuates Investing Myth
Annuities and the Hundred Thousand Dollar Challenge