Simon Cowell suggested on "American Idol" April 10 that finalist Haley Scarnato was wearing sexy clothes as a "tactic" to stay in the competition. Her short shorts weren't enough to keep her on the show and she was sent home the following night.
Here, Scarnato is shown in a relatively demure outfit Feb. 21, after the competition was whittled down to 24 finalists.
(Photo: Michael Becker / FOX)
Share This Gallery