Comments on: McCain Eyes Longer Gas Tax Holiday

Says Proposal To Suspend Tax For The Summer May Need To Be Extended

Add a Comment See all 94 Comments
by cbsblogger July 18, 2008 2:45 PM EDT
Typical Bush like neo-Republican response.

Borrow and spend to make short term political points. Saddle the future with the difficult decisions.

I can''t believe that McCain has gone from someone who made some sense to an idiot just like Bush.
Reply to this comment
by missingamerica July 18, 2008 2:43 PM EDT
Noticed the press is IGNORING the T.Boone Pickins Plan for the BIGGEST WIND FARM and REALLOCATING our energy resources.

The man MADE HIS FORTUNE in oil AND GAS.

Posted by homespunlady at 11:31 AM : Jul 18, 2008

Actually, the key to what you just said is "made his fortune".

I personally think that Mr. Pickens has recognized a potential threat to his various cash cows and is trying to "head it off at the pass", as a Texan like him would say.

His proposed replacement energy infrastructure would guarantee the continuation of a commercial source SELLING you energy.

What is he trying to head off, you ask?

Every American having his or her own solar (or wind, as the case may be) energy installation and getting energy "for free".

You have to understand that even as T. Boone Pickens is running those seemingly "good-hearted" commercials, he has been attempting to buy up all the water rights that he can in parts of Texas so he can monopolize those.

Pickens is smart - that is how he got rich. Three ways to stay rich - and absolutely control the American people - are to gain a complete or near monopoly on food, water, or energy.

Bear that in mind when he finally publicizes his "plan".
Reply to this comment
by dowell100 July 18, 2008 2:38 PM EDT
Posted by Hasher47
I''''ll take Obama''''s idea and action come Jan 20th anyday!
-------------------------------------

Don''t count your chickens before they hatch. I say he only has a 50-50 chance of surviving his trip to Iraq. He has lots of enemnies there and they''re all carrying guns.




Reply to this comment
by missingamerica July 18, 2008 2:36 PM EDT
The Democrats are going to invoke road tolls no matter what. There will be no other way to pay for the transportation infrastructure.

Posted by dowell100 at 11:32 AM : Jul 18, 2008

Oh, I don''t know that the Democrats would ever want to use tolls - I think that is what those Republicans who lust after the idea of privatizing our roads see as their personal private tax on the Average American.

lolll...wait - they don''t call it a "tax" - they call it "profit".

Besides, I can think of some ill-advised, inequality curve-busting tax cuts that can be rolled back.
Reply to this comment
by dowell100 July 18, 2008 2:32 PM EDT
Posted by homespunlady
Go for it. The shortsighted gas tax "holiday" ...

Then spend MORE on CAR REPAIRS and MEDICAL BILLS as the ROADS and BRIDGES fall apart.
--------------------------------

More gaseous liberal short-sightedness!

If we had roads filled with hybrid cars, the gas tax income would go away anyway because they burn less or, in some cases, no gas at all.

The Democrats are going to invoke road tolls no matter what. There will be no other way to pay for the transportation infrastructure.



Reply to this comment
by homespunlady July 18, 2008 2:31 PM EDT
Noticed the press is IGNORING the T.Boone Pickins Plan for the BIGGEST WIND FARM and REALLOCATING our energy resources.

The man MADE HIS FORTUNE in oil AND GAS.

Hello, doesn''t that TELL you something.

The MEDIA PUPPETEERS and McSame would rather keep advocating DOING THE SAME THING OVER AND OVER - (drill and stick with OIL and outdated nuke technology) which is the definition of insanity rather than STOP beating OUR HEADS against the OIL EXTORTION WALL and work on VIABLE EXISTING ANSWERS!
Reply to this comment
by missingamerica July 18, 2008 2:29 PM EDT
To stay strong, America needs short term gas price reductions...

Posted by dowell100 at 11:26 AM : Jul 18, 2008

OK - so we''ll raise the income taxes on everybody making more than $250,000 gross annually to make up for the lost gasoline taxes.

Don''t want the nation''s roads and bridges to go the hell, you know.

(Republicans - and oil boyz in particular - remind me of that commercial on TV where two inspectors find a leak in the dam, and one of ''em sticks his bubblegum in the crack and then checks it off as "fixed".)
Reply to this comment
by dowell100 July 18, 2008 2:26 PM EDT
Posted by Hasher47
"It''''s a quick fix for people who believe cheap gas is their birthright," said Tom Kloza, chief oil analyst at the research firm Oil Price Information Service. "It''''s not a prudent thing to do."
--------------------------------------------


It is the prudent thing to do, if you are not an Obama-O-Maniac.

About 95% of us out here do believe cheap gas is our birthright and we want a government who can supply it to us.

To stay strong, America needs short term gas price reductions, and in the long term more drilling, more nuclear plants, more wind power, more coal production, and more hybrid cars and trucks.

I''m sure Omaba has 1,000 advisors reading up on these things, but we need some action.

Reply to this comment
by homespunlady July 18, 2008 2:19 PM EDT
dowell 100

Go for it. The shortsighted gas tax "holiday" if it''s anything like the BUSH "TEMPORARY TAX CUT" for the RICHEST 1 percent will then translate into MORE PROFITS for the OIL companies as they RAISE the price. Hey who''s stopping them EXCEPT consumers NOT buying that necessity.

Then spend MORE on CAR REPAIRS and MEDICAL BILLS as the ROADS and BRIDGES fall apart.

Then McCain can BACK PRIVATIZATION to the FOREIGN ROAD TROLLS and YOU can PAY THEIR TOLLS to drive on the roads OUR TAXES BUILT.

Yep, immediate GREED wins with DUMB people every time even if it KILLS them LATER.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 July 18, 2008 2:17 PM EDT
homespunlady at 11:09 AM : Jul 18, 2008
+ report abuse

Great post homespunlady
Reply to this comment
by hasher47 July 18, 2008 2:16 PM EDT
dowell100, If you read up on this, you would also realize that there is a slim of zero chance of it passing in Congress anyway. Why, it is a c rapping idea.

I''ll take Obama''s idea and action come Jan 20th anyday!
Reply to this comment
by missingamerica July 18, 2008 2:12 PM EDT
lolll...ya know what amuses me the most about Republicans?

They CONSTANTLY yammer on about "individual responsibility" and how awful "entitlement programs" like Medicare/Medicaid are and how "Social Security should be privatized".

OK, then...so untold hundreds of thousands of Americans have gone to work and worked HARD for 20, 30, and even more years to EARN pensions and retirement health care packages that were promised to them.

And what happened?

The corporations, CEOs, boards of directors, and stockholders who make up the backbone of the Republican Party simply said "Sorry, we are not fulfilling those promises.".

What kind of schizophrenia is that? Only people who are not wealthy have to keep promises, live up to contractual obligations, and obey the law?

lollll...it amazes me to even think of it - but that is the essence of Republican philosophy.
Reply to this comment
by dowell100 July 18, 2008 2:12 PM EDT
Posted by Hasher47
Try reading up on it.
You Repugs DO READ don''''t you.

---------


All the Obama-O-Manics "read up on stuff" but take no action.

I read in the NYT today that Obama has 300 foreign policy advisors! Only a do-nothing jerk would have that many "experts" to plow though before making a decision. Lots of reading there.

I''ll take the gas tax cut for a while, thanks. It''s better than the cheap talk the confused Obama offers.

Reply to this comment
by homespunlady July 18, 2008 2:09 PM EDT
The only "disgrace" concerning Social Security is that McCain is GETTING AND KEEPING one of the SS HIGHEST RATES while telling the REST of America that THEY DON''T DESERVE to RECEIVE it for WORKING at REAL JOBS rather than RAKING IN THAT LOBBYIST CASH for "favors".

I thought being Cindy''s Gigolo should have been enough cash - DONATE your SS income BACK to the REAL POOR JOHN if you have such a LOW opinion of it!

That MEASLY 27K is HUGE for so many of us REAL WORK "mental recession" poor that will NEVER see that much from SS.
Reply to this comment
by hasher47 July 18, 2008 2:06 PM EDT
Here Dowell100,
"It''s typical of how Washington works -- let''s find some short-term, quick fix, even though we''re not really doing anything," he said. Watch an analysis of how the candidates'' plans differ ;

Instead, Obama would use a windfall profits tax on oil companies to help low-income families pay their energy bills. He also insists he would put forth more effort than others to limit oil companies'' influence in Washington.

Analysts and Obama said the proposal to suspend the tax temporarily would do little to stimulate the economy or lower gas prices and could leave roads in disrepair.

"It''s a quick fix for people who believe cheap gas is their birthright," said Tom Kloza, chief oil analyst at the research firm Oil Price Information Service. "It''s not a prudent thing to do."

Reply to this comment
by nanc12 July 18, 2008 2:06 PM EDT
Proposing this in front of the autoworkers. No pandering there, lol!

And what is he proposing to replace those funds with? A windfall profits tax on the oil companies. Nope. No ideas for that. He doesn''t realize the gas tax money is what pays for road & bridge repair?

He knows it wouldn''t help anything, and he knows it will never get passed. So he doesn''t NEED to come up with any ideas on where the missing money will come from, but he can SAY he''s got plans to help us. Maybe he should just lay down and rest for a while.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 July 18, 2008 2:06 PM EDT
he GOP does NOT care about the youth of this nation any more than they care about the aged of this nation - they just want your money badly enough to lie and lie and lie.

Posted by ibsteve2u at 10:57 AM : Jul 18, 2008

Your post was right on and the propaganda this administration followed by McBush is just that propaganda. Please young people just look what would happened to your money you invested in social security in todays market. You would not have one dime to live on. The republicans seem to forget this social security money is not there''s it is our money and if they keep there cotton picking hands off it we would be just fine when the time comes for us to retire
Reply to this comment
by whitemale08 July 18, 2008 2:06 PM EDT
It''''s mainly the lower and lower, middle class that are really feeling the pince. But hey, their''''re only 65% of Americans


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by Hasher47 at 10:57 AM : Jul 18-

you''re right, the vulture hedge funds are picking over the scraps.
Reply to this comment
by hasher47 July 18, 2008 2:02 PM EDT
The "Gas Tax Holiday", a smoke and mirrors gimmick that doesn''''t really solve the gas price problem, creates another problem by taking money away from much needed maintenance of roads and bridges, but gives willing Americans a psychological boost.

If that''''s the kind of problem solving you want running this country the vote for this guy.
Reply to this comment
by hasher47 July 18, 2008 2:01 PM EDT
I don''''t know if the gas tax holiday idea will work or not, ..
Posted by dowell100 at 10:58 AM : Jul 18, 2008
------------------------
Try reading up on it.
You Repugs DO READ don''t you.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply to this comment
See all 94 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Kennedy: Bishop Barred Me From Communion

    (337 recent comments)

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: