Comments on: Giuliani Touts ID Card Plan For Foreigners

GOP Presidential Hopeful Vows To Stop Flow Of Illegal Immigrants

[dallison7]

Giuliani combines Bush's foreign policy genius with Clinton's sexual impulse control.
Posted by shingles1


Naw, every time Rudy has an affair, he marries her.

[klingon69]

Posted by RandaIDS at 12:11 PM : Aug 15, 2007
Randal;
you're back, thought you'd been shot or something. So, what's for dinner?

[randaids]

I'm a resident alien. Dumb fu(k Rudy should realize, there is a fu(king card out there for all of us legal aliens - whether we are permanent residents or guest workers. The cards contain our photos and thumb print. If you don't have a card you need to freaking leave.I hate politicians...they're the slimiest lying pieces of *** on this earth. They love having illegals here.
Posted by kiwi_chick at 11:27 AM : Aug 15, 2007

Good for you for doing it the right way!

[usadvisor101]

I'm a resident alien. Dumb fu(k Rudy should realize, there is a fu(king card out there for all of us legal aliens - whether we are permanent residents or guest workers. The cards contain our photos and thumb print. If you don't have a card you need to freaking leave.I hate politicians...they're the slimiest lying P O S on this earth. They love having illegals here.
Posted by kiwi_chick at 11:27 AM : Aug 15, 2007



yes, good point shows how stupid he is. he wont come out and say dont have them come here. he probably has several at his residence doing his cleaning and yard work, that dont have green cards!!

[randaids]

Will it be an arm-band with yellow writing on it?
Posted by grazinggoat at 10:28 AM : Aug 15, 2007

Oh come on now, like a US National ID card would in any way equate to Nazi Germany. As stated by Prinzowhales, citizens with passports already do have a national ID. If required to carry them, passports would most definately seperate legal citizens from illegal aliens. What makes a national ID so different than a passport?

[usadvisor101]

if you liked bush than here is the perfect clown for you !!!

he has gone out and got like 30 or more of bushs smear nazis to work for him.

if your a former oil exec or draft dodgin silver spoon lazyazz, you gotta appreciate how he claimed 7000 in income while going through his divorce, then now has over 30,000,000.00

one of those rove like neoclown nazis must have finally figured out that most americans are against illegals.

good call, pull on the heart strings of america, now time to pull some rove like move and smear the guy next to you !!!

[ckcool192001]

Hey Rudy, Maybe we should just give everyone a name tag so we can all know each other's name. This is just one step toward a National ID card.

I will give him credit...at least he/or one of his advisors has spent time coming up with this plan.

The only problem with this is, if this database he speaks of tells him that this person's green card or temp work card has expired..how does he suggest finding these people to deport them? This would be a waste of tax payer money because enforcement would be next to impossible.

[shingles1]

Overheard:

Giuliani combines Bush's foreign policy genius with Clinton's sexual impulse control.

[jack3213]

Perhaps if any of you who are so=critical either about any candidate or their plan come up with a better solution or "logical" person to run for Office, we all would like to hear it. If you feel that any politician is worthless then you are free to move to another country. If all you want to do is complain about how bad you have it try moving somewhere else and tell us about that too. It gets so tiring to read comments that are extremely critical and biased as the"CBS" website itself.

[sevenveils]

This proposal shows how out of touch with reality Giuliani is. In essence his plan is to issue a card to every illegal and legal alien entering the country to identify them as such. If an alien doesn't have a "card", then it's neither illegal or legal.

As if people entering this country don;t have enough cards (green, pink, yellow and red if they are to be sidelined)