Comments on: Study: Good Child Care Pays Dividends

Finds Link Between Pre-Kindergarten Care And Vocabulary Scores In 5th Grade

Add a Comment See all 35 Comments
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:11 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:11 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:11 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:11 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
by mrsbergy March 27, 2007 7:10 PM EDT
Your broadcast of this did not reflect the positive aspect of vocabulary attainment. Also, the researchers interview contradicts the definition of quality. He stated that quality of the day care center "didn't matter" in regard to the results. A point I have with the operational definition which the researchers defined as "child care" I feel is unreasonable, even a "stay at home mom" of higher social economic status, has reguarly scheduled help or other kids to take care of, work in classrooms etc. I would think that the behavioral differences would be apparent in children who spend 8 or more hours a day at a center from a young age. In the end it is all relative and the strongest indicator for an thriving and typically developing child is the parent interations. Unfortunately, many women are going to use this "information" that was on your broadcast to continue to "guilt" out working moms and provide validation for them staying at home. Next time you report on a literature based study, maybe define the parameters of the study beyond the number of participants. In the end, we all know lots of kids whose mothers stayed home and did everything for them and they end up sad and dysfuntional and we also have know lots of "latch key kids" who were said to be doomed to failure and unhappiness and who are thriving today. Hopefully, we can strike a relative balance and respect everyones decision for a career and family. From, A working mom in education
Reply to this comment
See all 35 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Author Thomas Friedman on Obama's Afghanistan plan and the war on terror. Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • Verdict In Italy Verdict In Italy

    American Amanda Knox and Italian ex-boyfriend Found Guilty in Murder of British Student

  • Day in Pictures Day in Pictures

    A Glimpse at the Day's News as Seen Through a Camera Lens

  • Decade in Photos Decade in Photos

    A Look Back at the Events that Rocked the Headlines in the 2000's

  • Jaimee Grubbs Secret Pics Jaimee Grubbs Secret Pics

    Los Angeles Party Girl Quick to Claim Tiger Affair, But Not So Fast To Reveal Criminal Past

  • Celebrity Circuit Celebrity Circuit

    Aishwarya Rai Photo Shoot:,"Lovely Bones" Premiere, Reese Witherspoon and Penelope Cruz

  • "Nine" Debuts in London

    Star-Studded Film Has a British Red Carpet Premiere

Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: