Comments on: In Too Deep
A College Girl Gets Caught Up In A Gruesome Murder Case
Add a Comment See all 95 Comments
- I did not have the opportunity of meeting the beautiful Jennifer Cave but I do know one of her siblings.I am absolutley disgusted by this interview. Guilty!!! I dont even understand... why is there even a question??? The writing is right there on her face and listen to the words that come out of her mouth. How can one think she had nothing to do with it. Watch this show and I think there will be no confusion with your decision. Tattoo!!! Laura Hall put a murderers tattoo on her body..I dont think if you were being kidnapped you would be getting tatoos. And look at that smile in the picture from Mexico no remorse from either one of them they both deserve to burn in Hell. 5 years? try 500. I cant believe this is even a question. THose eyes!!And her lawyer said she didnt have enough strength to do that. BS shes a swimmer. Dont they know swimmers are very strong. I wouldnt put anything past that crazy ***!! umm.. laura the media didnt destroy you.. they displayed the truth of how truley crazy you are!!! Laura belongs in prison for life!! My prayers and thoughts go out to Jennifers entire family no one should have to go through this. Jennifers mother is correct she is a psychopath! Why couldnt the jury see that?
- Reply to this comment
- OMG! I think the girl is SATAN! I believe that she shot & dismembered Jennifer Cave. She orchestrated the whole thing. She caught the two together and killed Jennifer in a fit of rage & jealousy. Colton was probably given GSB and passed out or was just that loaded. I cannot believe that the prosecutors did not even entertain the idea. I am completly outraged with the whole story. God bless the Cave family. I pray that if hat monster ever gets out of jail that she doesn''t go after them.
- Reply to this comment
- I think that Laura Hall is as guility as that boy she should have gotten the same sentence as Colton she knew exactly what she was doing five years in prison is nothing it''s a slap in the wrist.
- Reply to this comment
- This woman is guilty! Watch her nervousness, her responses in her interview (interrogation) is just screaming guilt. The authorities better watch this one when she gets out. The jury in Laura''s case must not have seen all the evidence. I feel extreme sadness for the Cave family.
- Reply to this comment
- I don''t know why she was only facing 10 yrs. But I feel sorry for the residents of Austin. When she eventually does get out, I doubt people will be sleeping easily that night.
- Reply to this comment
- Hi Why was she facing only 10 years and received only 5 years. This girl is so guilty. She did so much more than aid and abet. She scares the hell out of me,
ths - Reply to this comment
- My favorite part of this story was when they claimed Laura said that DNA evidence doesn''t matter hahaha. I guess I''d say that too if my DNA was found on a freaking murder weapon. She is the craziest person I''ve ever seen interviewd. And look at her eyes. They are deep pools of black. Nothing there, no soul, no life, no nothing. You can see the devil in her eyes. What a psycho.
- Reply to this comment
- I am absolutely stunned that the jury took two days to convict Laura. This was completely a no-brainer. You would have to be a complete idiot to think that Laura had nothing to do with dismembering Jennifer''s body. Getting only five years? She should be elated! I would be absolutely dancing on the ceiling if I got five years for chopping a person''s body into pieces! This is worse than killing the person, I would think. You''re a very sick woman, Laura..... you should have gotten as much jail time as Colton, if not more.... yeah, and another thing... you got a tattoo with "Colton" after the murder???? Does this make any sense? For the guy who you say framed you? This is enough to get a guilty verdict without even knowing all of the facts of the case. Rot in jail Laura!!!! What you did was absolutely respulsive and a disgrace to the human race! You deserve no mercy!
- Reply to this comment
- Okay, didn''t laura''s father and mother seem a little odd also? And watch the video of her interagation, using your left hand is a sign of lying!
- Reply to this comment
- The media didn''t destroy you Laura, you did everytime you opened your mouth. I can''t believe she only got 5 yrs, she should have gotten 55 yrs. I hope that witch burns in hell. She''s trying to claim her innocence, meanwhile she''s partying it up in Mexico with the murderer, even getting his name tattooed on her ankle after the murder? The picture of her and Colton in Mexico said it all. She had the biggest smile on her face. She didn''t look "terrified" at all. G U I L T Y. She is guilty as sin. She''s the moest manipulating person I''ve ever heard. When she wished she was dead, I second that wish. I wish she was dead too. And her lawyer made me want to puke, trying to claim Laura was just as much of a victim as Jennifer. How can he say that, Laura wasn''t murdered, and then mutilated. I am so heartbroken for Jennifer''s family, and for Laura''s. I can''t imagine having to claim a monster like Laura for a daughter. If her parents are smart, they''ll run away and never look back.
- Reply to this comment
- Laura is in prison, though she has been tring to make bail since her conviction is being appealed. So far her parents haven''t been able to raise enough money~thank God. I don''t want her on the streets of Austin.
The show didn''t tell the whole story, but got most of it right. This woman is a sociopath, making things up as she goes along. She''s telling more lies; I live in Austin, and if you could have seen her reactions in the courtrooms during all the hearings leading up to her trial, you''d be as disgusted as I am. I don''t believe the show mentioned a comment she made to a friend on her return to Austin from Mexico: the friend asked her why should would go with Pytoniak to Mexico, and she says: thats just the way that I roll. Yeah, really innocent there, honey.
I followed her trial closely, and most of the details were omitted from this show. At the trial, it was never mentioned that she left his apartment after first arriving. After he showed her the body, they hung out and watch cartoons! Then it''s believed she sent him to the hardware store for the supplies to cut up poor Jennifer.
At her trial, she claimed she was innocent of the charge of helping a wanted man flee, because at the time they left for Mexico, Colton wasn''t a wanted man~because the body had not been discovered by then!!!
When she gets out of prison, I hope she moves to another state....we don''t need her here. - Reply to this comment
- I knew Jennifer Cave. We were in 4-H together and later she transferred to my high school. She was an amazing, out going, and talented woman. She was always friendly and fun to talk to. I have followed this case very closely. I still can not believe that someone could do this to a human being. I think that this woman, Laura Hall, is lying with every fiber in her body. Everything she said and all of the evidence that surrounds this case proves that this woman is a killer''s helper and psychopath. I had never seen the picture that was taken with Laura and Colton in Mexico. After everything that they did to Jennifer how could take a picture that looks like a couple, without a care in the world, on vacation? This woman deserved more than 5 years. She is pathetic. She is saying things that don%u2019t even make sense. If you are in fear for you life, then why go back? You are out of harms way and you go back? Why would you get a tattoo of Colton%u2019s name after the murder? Clearly this woman was heavily involved with the tragic actions that happened to Jennifer%u2019s body after her death. Jennifer Cave was a remarkable woman. I pray for Jennifer%u2019s family.
- Reply to this comment
- I have only written in a few times ever on any shows but after seeing In Too Deep I am outraged that this girl only received 5 years. I found her very disturbing. A good person whether fearful of someone or in love with someone would have called the police as soon as they left that apartment knowing their boyfriend killed someone. Where was her outrage over his being with someone else? She is sick. Then she goes to Mexico and enjoys herself playing in a playpen and getting a tatoo with his name on it. She should have gotten AT LEAST 20 years herself. It''s okay to not report a murder??? and then go off and party with the murderer??? Then she goes on your program and says "poor me - look what he''s taken from me and he told on me - I didn''t tell on him, etc" UNBELIEVEABLE. She is so abnormal it''s scary. I really feel for Jennifer''s parents. They are right. That girl is a psychopath. It''s a disgrace she only received 5 years.
- Reply to this comment
- 5 years? What an injustice! Laura should be put away for life. She is the most manipulative young woman I have ever seen or heard.
- Reply to this comment
- Laura should be in jail with her boyfriend......
- Reply to this comment

