By

Larry Swedroe /

MoneyWatch/ September 4, 2012, 9:45 AM

A look at four years of a zero-rate policy

(MoneyWatch) In November 2008, the interest rate on one-month Treasury bills fell to less than 0.10 percent. Thus, we're now approaching four full years of the Federal Reserve's "zero interest rate" policy. The fact that the policy has been in place for so long has been a surprise to most economists and investors alike, especially for investors who have been sitting on cash waiting for rates to rise. Despite low interest rates and a plethora of other bad news, the markets have fared well since then.

The same month, the S&P 500 Index hit of low of 741. (It would hit its lowest point of the recession at 667 on March 6, 2009.) Let's take a look at some of the things that happened since then. Having perspective and knowing your financial history helps you become a better investor.

S&P 500 returns

In 2009, the economy dipped into a recession, and we've had the slowest economic recovery in the post-war era. Despite the slow U.S. recovery, high unemployment, the European financial crisis and dramatic slowdowns in growth in the emerging market countries, the S&P 500 is now over 1,400 -- an increase from the March 2009 low, not even counting the return from dividends, of more than 100 percent. Unfortunately, many investors missed out on the rally as there was a flight of hundreds of billions of dollars out of equity mutual funds.

Bond yields

In November 2008, the 10-year Treasury yield fell to below 3 percent. Defying the predictions of most forecasters, the 10-year Treasury is now trading at around 1.65 percent, well below even the 2.30 level we saw as recently as April 2012. The closing low yield was 1.43 percent on July 25, 2012. And it's worth remembering that it was yielding as high as 3.75 percent on Feb. 8, 2011.

Recall that all this occurred despite the U.S. Treasury losing its precious AAA credit rating in August 2011. Here too, many investors missed not only the rally because they were sure rates couldn't go lower, but they have also been faced with the problem of how to reinvest the proceeds of their bond investments that have matured over the past four years.

It's been said that experience is the best teacher. However, that only works if you learn from your mistakes. If you've missed the stock and bond rallies of the past four years or failed to adhere to your investment plan because you panicked and sold, it's not too late to learn. Even smart people make mistakes. They just don't repeat the same ones. However, to learn from your mistakes you must first admit them -- something that's very hard for many, if not most, to do.

Image courtesy of Flickr user 401(K) 2012.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
4 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
dlnewco50 says:
It is difficult to find a safe haven -- with any return -- for one's nest egg. Retirees have run into reinvestment risk. Yes folks, your capital is pretty safe, but there are no guarantees on return.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
taxed01 says:
Obama and the Democrats are following policies that hurt senior citizens. Those of us responsible enough to prepare for retirement are getting screwed:
1 He wants to reduce the amount of money going into Social Security by cutting the payroll tax. There would be some smoke and mirrors going on to make it look like there would still be the same amount of money going to the SS account, but that's all it is - smoke and mirrors.
2 Getting nothing (no interest) on our short term savings, CDs and money market accounts.
3 Seeing half a Trillion being removed from Medicare to pay for the uninsured (from cuts in payments to essentially every Medicare provider — hospitals, hospices, nurses, etc. - this will have to be made up elsewhere).
4 He wants to tax us more when we sell some stock or mutual funds that we bought years ago for our retirement.
5 The interest sensitive parts of pension funds are taking huge hits because of the low long term interest rates being introduced.
Obama and the Democrats have declared war on responsible seniors so they can continue to give handouts to the welfare crowd.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
get_down says:
Hummm, this author sounds like a perfect spokesman for that genius Federal Reserve Chairman Mr. Ben Bernanke whose policies and actions resulting in setting the key interest rate close to zero since 2008 and later launched the QE1 and QE2 (up to this point) which were aiming to force potential investors to put their assets on stock and bond. Well, did it work? As far as I can tell - the stagnant economy remains. Why, that genius Federal Reserve Chairman Mr. Ben Bernanke said the best - "the economy still lacks enough spending" recently! What? Why in the world after all those people chose to invest their money on stock and bond and yet he still crying for consumers lack of spending? The truth is his skewed one-sided wishful thinking policies and actions are only about the "Trickle-Down Economics" which only benefited the riches and at the same time totally ignored the general populace (It's well known that Consumer spending account for 70% of the economy growth). Case and point - my saving account with a balance of 12K earned me 1 dollar for the month of May, 99 cents for the month of June, 1.02 for the month of July and $1.07 for the month of August - i.e. $4.08 interest for 4 whole months. And then Mr. Ben Bernanke wondered why a consumer like me wouldn't spend more?! Oh yeah, I used to follow the "diversify" principle by distributing my 401K's fund into - e.g., "fixed", "Large", "Small" and company stocks, after a few years of steady losses, I took my HS Valedictorian daughter's advice and consolidated all of them into just the "fixed" and the NAV is 5.63 currently. After working more than 29 years, I'm recently retired and living on my pension and my Social Security benefit along with my better-half whom I married for more than 36 years. This article is discussing anyone chooses to play the stock market or sugar-coat it by saying "Stock investing" - then their "401(k) could be at the mercy of market cycles". Yes, I still own more than 1K shares of the Company's stocks which I'm earning quarterly dividends from. I'm more than convinced that Mr. Ben Bernanke is not only truly clueless but also incompetent to the Nth degree. As long as he stays on as the FRC, our stagnant economy remains HOPELESS to say the least!
reply
get_down replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Come to think of it - the credit has to give to Mr. Obama for awarding the Second term of FRC to Ben Bernanke even though Mr. Obama's original campaign slogan was "Change and Hope" and yet he lied. Coming November, I as one of the many Independent voters will vote for "Change and Hope" - not Mr. Obama again - for sure - also NOT "Moving Forward" with Ben Bernanke stays on as the FRC which would be HOPELESS to say the least!