September 7, 2010 5:30 PM
- Text
Mentos Ad Says Your Fat Friend Is a Figure of Fun
(MoneyWatch)
Mentos is surely about to apologize for an ad in which a skinny girl says to a fat girl, "I love hanging out with you. All the boys keep looking at me." The tagline is, "Selfishness without the guilt," and it's one of three ads in which the joke seems to be that if you want to be mean without feeling guilty, eat a Mentos. Or something. (Click to enlarge the image.)
Regardless, the ad is so needlessly insulting to the overweight, and so unlike what we know about the Mentos brand, that it looks like a mistake. Aside from a brief diversion in which it was discovered that a Mentos dropped into Diet Coke has explosive results, the Mentos brand has traditionally positioned itself around a "young, fun" faux naif theme. (Click here to remember just how naif those "freshmaker!" ads used to be.)
It's also horribly off-brand for Mentos' parent, Perfitti van Melle, which also makes Airheads and Smints. This is a company whose motto is -- and I'm not making this up -- "Caring for Excellence." Their web site intro is so shiny and happy it could pass unchanged as a "Saturday Night Live" pastiche of corporate image nonsense.
In fact, there are reasons to believe this is a mistake. First, the ad emerges from Neogama/BBH in Brazil, and yet is written in English not Portugese. Second, Brazilian ad agencies have a habit of running outre ads once in the media in order to cheat their way into advertising award shows. And third, the agency has not listed its client on its Ads of the World database credits. However, there are three different executions in this series and 18 BBH excutives have their names next to them, so it looks official.
Mentos' brand management needs to jump on this immediately. (The company did not immediately respond to a request for comment.) One of the odd new trends in advertising is people unaffiliated with a company making rogue ads just to get the attention of the creative community. An independent director recently made a speculative Quiznos ad without the company's permission, in which fat women were compared to meat.
Related:
Mentos is surely about to apologize for an ad in which a skinny girl says to a fat girl, "I love hanging out with you. All the boys keep looking at me." The tagline is, "Selfishness without the guilt," and it's one of three ads in which the joke seems to be that if you want to be mean without feeling guilty, eat a Mentos. Or something. (Click to enlarge the image.)Regardless, the ad is so needlessly insulting to the overweight, and so unlike what we know about the Mentos brand, that it looks like a mistake. Aside from a brief diversion in which it was discovered that a Mentos dropped into Diet Coke has explosive results, the Mentos brand has traditionally positioned itself around a "young, fun" faux naif theme. (Click here to remember just how naif those "freshmaker!" ads used to be.)
It's also horribly off-brand for Mentos' parent, Perfitti van Melle, which also makes Airheads and Smints. This is a company whose motto is -- and I'm not making this up -- "Caring for Excellence." Their web site intro is so shiny and happy it could pass unchanged as a "Saturday Night Live" pastiche of corporate image nonsense.
In fact, there are reasons to believe this is a mistake. First, the ad emerges from Neogama/BBH in Brazil, and yet is written in English not Portugese. Second, Brazilian ad agencies have a habit of running outre ads once in the media in order to cheat their way into advertising award shows. And third, the agency has not listed its client on its Ads of the World database credits. However, there are three different executions in this series and 18 BBH excutives have their names next to them, so it looks official.
Mentos' brand management needs to jump on this immediately. (The company did not immediately respond to a request for comment.) One of the odd new trends in advertising is people unaffiliated with a company making rogue ads just to get the attention of the creative community. An independent director recently made a speculative Quiznos ad without the company's permission, in which fat women were compared to meat.
Related:
- Are Fat Women "Meat"? Here's an Ad That Quiznos Ought to Reject
- WWF Did Approve Offensive Sept. 11 Ad; DDB Brasil's Award Show Cheating Exposed
Latest Now in MoneyWatch
- EU: Greece must cut deeper to get bailout
- Big banks, gov't officials strike $25B deal
- LinkedIn swings back to profit
- LinkedIn doubles revenue, beats growth estimates
- Kodak to stop making digital cameras, frames
- Market cap, schmarket cap, Apple still gets no respect
- Philip Morris Int'l income up nearly 8 percent
- Survey: Small biz plans big hires in 2012
- Freddie Mac: Mortgages inch higher but stay low
- Will the European debt crisis sink Obama's re-election?
- Banks in $25B deal to settle foreclosure abuses
- Joe Coffee: Scaling up without selling your soul
- Greek agreement accomplishes nothing
- 401K plans: New rules make costs clearer
- Are women leaders selling themselves short?
- Ask the Experts: New 401(k) rules
- Mortgage lenders strike a deal
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- India, EU hope to reach free-trade pact this year
- Blasts rock Syria's 2nd largest city, Aleppo
- Obama call for manufacturing revival a tough goal
- 2nd deposition sought for convicted Ponzi schemer
on Facebook
- Tenn. father charged with murdering couple who"unfriended" daughter on Facebook
- "Person to Person" with George Clooney
on CBS News






