January 29, 2009 12:05 PM
- Text
Virgin Sues Adrants Over Fake Hudson River Jet Crash Ad
(MoneyWatch) Ad blog Adrants has been sued by Virgin over its mistaken post that Virgin had taken advantage of the US Airways Hudson River airline crash with an ad calling the crash "Just one more reason to fly Virgin."
Virgin sued Adrants even though the blog corrected its item with a note saying, "UPDATE: Clearly, this ad is fake."
A cache of Adrants' original post (screenshot pictured) can be seen here. It pictured a Virgin ad with the copy, "The Hudson Crash: Just One More Reason to Fly Virgin."
Adrants' post said:
BNET's take: Virgin does not believe this lawsuit will ever come to court or succeed. The majority of its claims are spurious. For instance, to succeed on some of them, Virgin will have to prove that it suffered specific economic damages because of the Adrants post, i.e. by passengers choosing to fly on other airlines.
The claims are offset in part by Adrants immediate corrective that the item was a mistake, so the potential damages are already microscopic.
The real reason Virgin is doing this is to protect its brand from the internet. The airline knows that rumors and fake ads can go viral at astonishing speed, and once that happens rumor can replace truth. By taking a sledgehammer to this walnut it sends a clear signal to the blogoshere that repeating false information about Virgin has consequences.
Plus, Adrants is the perfect victim for Virgin because the T&A-focused site can hardly argue that it takes its journalistic responsibilities seriously.
Prediction: This suit will be quietly dismissed with the consent of both parties in a few weeks.
Virgin sued Adrants even though the blog corrected its item with a note saying, "UPDATE: Clearly, this ad is fake."A cache of Adrants' original post (screenshot pictured) can be seen here. It pictured a Virgin ad with the copy, "The Hudson Crash: Just One More Reason to Fly Virgin."
Adrants' post said:
"We've seen Virgin turn ugly situations to its advantage before, making it very much in keeping with the Virgin brand persona. The only thing saving the tribute from being in terrifically bad taste is the fact that no one lost his or her life in the crash. So woot! - slather your big reds all over those news shots, V."Later, Adrants posted:
"UPDATE: Clearly, this ad is fake. A spoof. Virgin America has confirmed this. We were always supect from he get go and didn't mean to mislead or misrepresent. So we'll clearly state now: the ad is a spoof. It's not real. Virgin America had nothing to do with its creation."The suit claims trademark infringement, deceptive advertising, and defamation, among other claims. Read a copy of it here.
BNET's take: Virgin does not believe this lawsuit will ever come to court or succeed. The majority of its claims are spurious. For instance, to succeed on some of them, Virgin will have to prove that it suffered specific economic damages because of the Adrants post, i.e. by passengers choosing to fly on other airlines.
The claims are offset in part by Adrants immediate corrective that the item was a mistake, so the potential damages are already microscopic.
The real reason Virgin is doing this is to protect its brand from the internet. The airline knows that rumors and fake ads can go viral at astonishing speed, and once that happens rumor can replace truth. By taking a sledgehammer to this walnut it sends a clear signal to the blogoshere that repeating false information about Virgin has consequences.
Plus, Adrants is the perfect victim for Virgin because the T&A-focused site can hardly argue that it takes its journalistic responsibilities seriously.
Prediction: This suit will be quietly dismissed with the consent of both parties in a few weeks.
Latest Now in MoneyWatch
- LinkedIn doubles revenue, beats growth estimates
- Kodak to stop making digital cameras, frames
- Market cap, schmarket cap, Apple still gets no respect
- Philip Morris Int'l income up nearly 8 percent
- Survey: Small biz plans big hires in 2012
- Freddie Mac: Mortgages inch higher but stay low
- Will the European debt crisis sink Obama's re-election?
- Banks in $25B deal to settle foreclosure abuses
- Joe Coffee: Scaling up without selling your soul
- Greek agreement accomplishes nothing
- 401K plans: New rules make costs clearer
- Are women leaders selling themselves short?
- Ask the Experts: New 401(k) rules
- Mortgage lenders strike a deal
- $25B foreclosure-abuse settlement reached
- Wholesale inventories rose 1 percent in December
- States, Feds to announce new mortgage settlement
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- Jack Hanna: Proposed exotic animal law too soft
- NY attorney general ends lawsuit against Intel
- Pharmacyclics rises after posting 2Q profit
- How the video games industry is faring
on Facebook
- Adele opens up about vocal cord surgery
- Tenn. father charged with murdering couple who"unfriended" daughter on Facebook
- Mo. teen gets life in prison for murder of 9-year-old girl
- "American Idol": Jim Carrey's daughter out, and then disaster
on CBS News






