April 20, 2011 4:41 PM
- Text
Hooliganism? Hardly.
(MoneyWatch) Vladimir Putin is critical of monetary policymakers in the US:
The real issue is that, as noted in the article linked above, "Russia has the world's third-largest international reserves after China and Japan." Policymakers in Russia are worried about inflation in the US eroding the value of these reserve holdings. But why does Russia have so many reserves to begin with? It comes from a trade surplus, one that -- like the surplus in China -- can be alleviated by allowing its currency to appreciate on foreign exchange markets (that would also help with inflation in both countries). The US cannot reduce its trade deficit unless other countries are willing to reduce their surpluses. That is, unless it is willing to undergo deflation -- another way to allow foreign currencies to appreciate against the dollar. But policymakers in the US are not going to allow that to happen since it could lead to a deflationary spiral.
I can't blame Putin for trying to force all the adjustment on the US, or as much as possible anyway. Or China. But both countries -- by taking the steps necessary to reduce their trade surpluses -- are in the best position to address the concerns they've expressed.
Putin: U.S. Monetary Policy Is 'Hooliganism', WSJ: Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin slammed expansionary U.S. monetary policy, calling it "hooliganism", in remarks that followed more veiled criticism from China after Standard & Poor's Corp. cut the outlook on its U.S. debt rating this week. ...
"Look at their trade balance, their debt, and budget. They turn on the printing press and flood the entire dollar zone -- in other words, the whole world -- with government bonds. There is no way we will act this way anytime soon. We don't have the luxury of such hooliganism," he said. ...I suppose this can be explained by something like "the best defense is a good offense," but the fundamental problem is not the behavior of monetary policymakers in the US. First, although I disagree that monetary policy is responsible for the run-up in commodity prices, e.g. see this argument from the SF Fed, if it is true Russia benefits from this. Russia is a resource exporting country and when commodity prices rise, it does better. Again, I don't think there's any basis to do so, but if they object to selling their commodities at higher prices, I don't think anyone would mind if they reduced the price.
The real issue is that, as noted in the article linked above, "Russia has the world's third-largest international reserves after China and Japan." Policymakers in Russia are worried about inflation in the US eroding the value of these reserve holdings. But why does Russia have so many reserves to begin with? It comes from a trade surplus, one that -- like the surplus in China -- can be alleviated by allowing its currency to appreciate on foreign exchange markets (that would also help with inflation in both countries). The US cannot reduce its trade deficit unless other countries are willing to reduce their surpluses. That is, unless it is willing to undergo deflation -- another way to allow foreign currencies to appreciate against the dollar. But policymakers in the US are not going to allow that to happen since it could lead to a deflationary spiral.
I can't blame Putin for trying to force all the adjustment on the US, or as much as possible anyway. Or China. But both countries -- by taking the steps necessary to reduce their trade surpluses -- are in the best position to address the concerns they've expressed.
-
Mark Thoma Mark Thoma is a macroeconomist and time-series econometrician at the University of Oregon. His research focuses on how monetary policy affects the economy, and he has also worked on political business cycle models and models of transportation dynamics. Mark blogs daily at Economist's View. Follow him on Twitter at @MarkThoma.
Follow on Twitter »
Latest Now in MoneyWatch
- Ask the Experts: Gas Prices
- HP sales miss highlights growth challenges
- HP earnings sink, miss analyst targets
- Microsoft files EU complaint against Motorola, Google
- Why Apple's labor practices may never improve
- Geithner presses case for revamping corporate taxes
- The 10 best places to retire
- How much is your leisure time worth?
- What Uncle Sam can REALLY do for small business owners
- Existing home sales up, inventory down -- for now
- Corporate tax cut: Good idea, but won't stimulate economy
- Generate leads like a management guru
- The Investor Edition: Featuring Allison Goldberg and David S. Rose
- A simple strategy to keep your inbox clean
- Why even great employees get average evaluations
- Fitch downgrades Greece
- Retirement planning inspiration from the Oscars
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- Summary Box: HP CEO pleads patience
- A look at tech companies with IPOs this year
- A look at how some IPO stocks have fared
- Thai flooding impact on tech companies, suppliers
on Facebook
- Adele flips off producers at Brit Awards
- American, French journalists killed in Syria
- Is world's shortest man this 22-inch-tall Nepalese 72-year-old?
- Six decades of Oscar fashion
on CBS News






