March 1, 2009 12:41 AM
- Text
Capitol Power Plant Protests Heighten Danger for Coal
(MoneyWatch) What do Washington, D.C.'s Capitol Power Plant, an E.ON plant in Kingsnorth, England and a mine in Konin, Poland have in common? Two things: The first is coal, and the second is a problem with protesters.
Coal companies and investors have long known lower profit margins lay ahead due to carbon regulations and more difficulty in getting plants permitted. But one wonders if they foresaw an increasingly effective public campaign against their resource.
The Capitol Power Plant is getting attention right now because a protest that hasn't even happened yet appears to have spurred politicians to action. Run by the Architect of the Capitol to heat nearby government buildings in D.C., the plant is aging and inefficient. Yet meddling by congressmen from coal-mining states has allegedly kept the plant burning a fuel mix including coal, rather than switching over to pure natural gas, which would be cleaner.
A relatively small protest scheduled for this Monday -- at one point it was touting 2,500 sign-ups -- was organized to try to force the plant to make the switch. Yet the two ranking senate Democrats, senators Pelosi and Reid, have pre-empted the protestors by asking the Architect to get rid of the coal.
The cynic in me says the senators, like any good politicians, are seeking to turn the attention to themselves. But in the process, they've also brought far more attention to the event itself, which is still set to happen, and will now get more national coverage when it does.
For some, it will be the first time seeing significant protests against coal. Yet there was already a rising tide of the same. At Kingsnorth, activists have been heckling plant owners and workers for months. At Drax, another English plant, they went much further, hijacking an entire coal train. The Polish protests were led by Greenpeace, an organization that exists to make a nuisance of itself and as such is sometimes ineffective, but seems to be increasingly zeroing in on coal. Other actions have happened in the United States, China and Australia.
Notably, many would be occurring even without groups like Greenpeace. There is a grassroots movement, and every day it bears more resemblance to the decades-ago backlash against nuclear power, one of the two major factors that led to the end of the use of that fuel in many countries (the other being higher cost).
Nuclear, it should be noted, never had a hundred percent of the people against it. What it did have was an extremely dedicated core of opposition -- people who did not want nuclear power, come hell or high water. Those outspoken opponents overwhelmed nuclear's supporters. Soon, that may be the case with coal.
The video made to entice people to the Capitol protest, made by Dr. James Hansen, a NASA scientist who has long been at the forefront of the climate debate, is below.
Coal companies and investors have long known lower profit margins lay ahead due to carbon regulations and more difficulty in getting plants permitted. But one wonders if they foresaw an increasingly effective public campaign against their resource.
The Capitol Power Plant is getting attention right now because a protest that hasn't even happened yet appears to have spurred politicians to action. Run by the Architect of the Capitol to heat nearby government buildings in D.C., the plant is aging and inefficient. Yet meddling by congressmen from coal-mining states has allegedly kept the plant burning a fuel mix including coal, rather than switching over to pure natural gas, which would be cleaner.
A relatively small protest scheduled for this Monday -- at one point it was touting 2,500 sign-ups -- was organized to try to force the plant to make the switch. Yet the two ranking senate Democrats, senators Pelosi and Reid, have pre-empted the protestors by asking the Architect to get rid of the coal.
The cynic in me says the senators, like any good politicians, are seeking to turn the attention to themselves. But in the process, they've also brought far more attention to the event itself, which is still set to happen, and will now get more national coverage when it does.
For some, it will be the first time seeing significant protests against coal. Yet there was already a rising tide of the same. At Kingsnorth, activists have been heckling plant owners and workers for months. At Drax, another English plant, they went much further, hijacking an entire coal train. The Polish protests were led by Greenpeace, an organization that exists to make a nuisance of itself and as such is sometimes ineffective, but seems to be increasingly zeroing in on coal. Other actions have happened in the United States, China and Australia.
Notably, many would be occurring even without groups like Greenpeace. There is a grassroots movement, and every day it bears more resemblance to the decades-ago backlash against nuclear power, one of the two major factors that led to the end of the use of that fuel in many countries (the other being higher cost).
Nuclear, it should be noted, never had a hundred percent of the people against it. What it did have was an extremely dedicated core of opposition -- people who did not want nuclear power, come hell or high water. Those outspoken opponents overwhelmed nuclear's supporters. Soon, that may be the case with coal.
The video made to entice people to the Capitol protest, made by Dr. James Hansen, a NASA scientist who has long been at the forefront of the climate debate, is below.
Latest Now in MoneyWatch
- Insurers respond cautiously to contraceptive plan
- Judge: Legally, breastfeeding not related to pregnancy
- Budget deficit drops to $27 billion in January
- Why the Powerball Jackpot is part of my investment strategy
- Is the new VW Beetle diesel worth the money?
- Consumer sentiment highlights risks to recovery
- Valentine blues? 10 best cities to be single
- December trade deficit widens to $48.8 billion
- Alcatel-Lucent returns to profit in 2011
- 6 things never to say in a performance review
- $26B mortgage deal: Who gets the money?
- Friendly's CEO steps down
- Quarterly loss hits $3.3B at Postal Service
- Greeks rail against cuts as EU demands more
- 6 things you should never share on Facebook
- Make moves now to increase financial aid
- Valentine's Day: 9 places to save
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook Most Discussed Stories
on CBS News
- Grizzlies end 3-game skid, beat Timberwolves 85-80
- Grizzlies end 3-game skid, beat Timberwolves 85-80
- Chef Jesse Schenker, wife Lindsay's Val Day dish
- Nowitzki scores 25 in Mavs' 105-95 win vs. Nuggets
on Facebook Most Discussed Stories
on CBS News






