HealthPop
By

CBS News Staff /

CBS News/ May 24, 2012, 9:38 AM

Gov't safety group urges swimming lessons in black and Hispanic communities

generic swimming pool water CBS/iStockphoto

(CBS/AP) Black and Hispanic children should be taught how to swim to curb the racial disparities in drowning rates, according to government safety advocates.

Drowning risk high for kids in portable pools
CDC: Kids' accidental death rates down 30%, "but we can do more"

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) will release its annual childhood drowning report Thursday at the Fort Lauderdale Aquatic Complex, home to the International Swimming Hall of Fame. The report  urges parents to be aware of swimming pool safety before the summer heats up.

The report presents estimates of deaths and injuries associated with pools, spas and hot tubs, and coincides with a national campaign called "Pool Safely" that aims to reduce the number of similar events. The campaign, found at www.PoolSafely.gov, is focusing this year on increasing swimming education in black and Hispanic communities.

Black children between the ages of 5 and 14 are three times more likely to drown than white children of the same age range, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Research by the USA Swimming Foundation indicates that up to 70 percent of black and 62 percent of Hispanic children cannot swim, the CPSC said.

Citing that research, safety commission chairman Inez Tenenbaum said "there's no question" that not knowing how to swim contributes to the deaths of minority children who drown in pools and in natural bodies of water such as lakes, streams or the ocean.

"We are focusing on minority children because the data show they are most at risk for drowning," she said in a telephone interview. "It's a cultural issue, because many of the African-American and Hispanic children have parents and grandparents who never learned to swim."

The safety commission is working with the Y, the American Red Cross, public schools and other community organizations to boost access to free swimming lessons.

In its report, the agency has found that:

  • Between 2007 to 2009, an annual average of 390 pool- and spa-related deaths involving children younger than 15 were reported. About 73 percent of those deaths occurred at a residential location, and three-quarters of the reported deaths involved children younger than 5.
  • Of the 5,200 pool- or spa-related injuries involving children younger than 15 from 2009 through 2011, approximately 51 percent occurred at a residential location.
  • Portable pools accounted for an annual average of 40 deaths involving children younger than 15.
  • Children between the ages of 1 and 3 represented 66 percent of the estimated injuries for 2009 through 2011 and 67 percent of the reported fatalities for 2007 through 2009.
  • No deaths caused by entrapment, when the suction in a pool or hot tub traps a swimmer underwater, were reported in 2011. Seven entrapment injuries were reported last year.

According to the CPSC, more than half of reported drowning deaths involving children under the age of 5 could be attributed to a lapse in adult supervision. Also, more boys were treated for pool- or spa-related injuries than girls. The CDC says nearly 80 percent of people who die from drowning are male.

"These numbers are consistent, and it has been long known that drowning is the number one cause of death in children younger than 5," Tenenbaum said.

Tenenbaum noted that swimming is a featured activity in first lady Michelle Obama's "Let's Move!" fitness initiative, and she encouraged parents who don't know how to swim to make swimming lessons a family activity.

At Thursday's announcement, Tenenbaum will be joined by representatives from the National Drowning Prevention Alliance, USA Swimming and the Josh Project, a non-profit which teaches minority children to swim.

Drowning rates among African Americans increase through childhood and peak at 15 to 19 years of age, according to the CDC. Factors such as the physical environment - such as access to swimming pools - and a combination of social and cultural issues (e.g., wanting to learn how to swim, and choosing recreational water-related activities) may contribute to the racial differences in drowning rates.

The CDC's drowning rates are based on population, and not on actual participation in water-related activities. If rates were determined by participation, the CDC says, disparity in minorities' drowning rates compared to whites would be much greater.

The CDC has more information on drowning.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
16 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rwsmith29456 says:
This has been a problem for many years. Whenever I would hear about drowning accidents they mostly involved minority children.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
lillyhorton says:
Public schools teach kids to swim. It is a PE requirement to graduate. Hows that? Government can't make all those people attend swim classes. It would be voluntary and chances are kids who love water would gladly take the free lessons. Making it a requirment to graduate insures we teach all of the young minority people. Most communities have a pool and those that don't are probably pale communities anyway whose kids swim in the local lake. Handing out grants to communities who have a moderate minority population doesn't mean those minorities are aware of the program. It doesn't mean that parents can take the time to get their kids to the classes that are often held during work hours low income people hold. The grant holders smudge the paper work and use the extra money for pool upkeep which normally comes out of pool passes and other grants from parks and recreation. If the government were really serious about this it would be a school requirement. When do I get to vote on this matter?
reply
rwsmith29456 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
How many public schools teach swimming???
skeezix06 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Not around here they don't. Most of the schools don't even have swimming pools.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
OnTheRoad01 says:
I just loved it when they state in the article ""there's no question" that not knowing how to swim contributes to the deaths of minority children who drown in pools and in natural bodies of water such as lakes, streams or the ocean."
I just wonder how much tax payer money was used to determine this face?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jared131 says:
When I was around 8 I went to a public pool on my own and taught myself to swim. Took about an hour.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rmm26a says:
They also love fried chicken and watermelon. They should do a study on that too...haha
reply
audemus replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
...and after that maybe we could teach white kids how to play basketball and Salsa.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nehicks says:
WHY aren't the parents at fault for allowing their children to be around a body of water, be it a swimming pool or an ocean, KNOWING those children don't know how to swim? I am tired of people expecting the government to protect them from their own idiotic actions. If you know your child can't swim, you tell them not to get in the water, and then you make sure you watch them. Quit expecting everyone else to raise your child. If you don't want the responsibility, don't have the kid or give the existing one up for adoption.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
skeezix06 says:
I agree. This is a safety issue. I suspect this could be at least partly an issue of not having the extra money to pay for the lessons and to get access to a swimming pool where it would be safe for them to learn.

Chuck and bbarnes, if you want to potentially save someone's life and you object to government paying for it, dig some money out of your own pocket to pay for a season pass and the swimming class for a kid whose parents simply can't afford it. It could make you a hero.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
skeezix06 says:
I agree. This is a safety issue. I suspect this could be at least partly an issue of not having the extra money to pay for the lessons and to get access to a swimming pool where it would be safe for them to learn.

Chuck and bbarnes, if you want to potentially save someone's life and you object to government paying for it, dig some money out of your own pocket to pay for a season pass and the swimming class for a kid whose parents simply can't afford it. It could make you a hero.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
magnumdr says:
When I was a boy I was taught to swim by being thrown into a pond at my cousins house. It was either sink or swim. Guess what I learned that day.
reply
skeezix06 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It doesn't work that way for everyone. And then there's the little matter that if you sink in the pond water (weeds and stuff that grow in the bottom of the pond that can entangle your feet) which is not the cleanest or clearest, they might not be able to find you till too late. Kids need to learn to swim in swimming pools, not ponds, creeks, or lakes.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mari1963 says:
My son is a competitive swimmer, and I am always stunned when we go to the pool how many adults don't know how to swim. They never learned how, because their parents didn't think it was important. My son is incredible in the water and I know he could rescue someone if necessary, but EVERYONE should know how to swim. It is important. Parents should enroll their children in water safety/or swimming classes as soon as they can.

And if there are programs available to help pay for these classes for the underprivileged, I would be happy to support the program.

AMERICA - WAKE UP! Swimming counts!
reply
See all 16 Comments