U.S. obesity rates may be underestimated, study finds: Blame BMI test?

istockphoto

(CBS News) America may have a worse weight problem than anyone thought. Current estimates from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show roughly one-third of Americans are obese. But the authors behind a new study that questions the test commonly used to measure obesity think that rate might be underestimated.

U.S. obesity epidemic at standstill, CDC says
Shocking report says half of Americans will be obese by 2030
PICTURES: F as in Fat: Top 15 fattest U.S. states

"Roughly 30 percent of Americans are obese," based on their body mass index (BMI), study author Dr. Eric Braverman, president of the nonprofit research group, the Path Foundation in New York City, told HealthDay. "But when you use other methods, closer to 60 percent are obese. We call BMI the 'baloney mass index.'"

A BMI is a fat measurement that takes a person's weight and divides it by the square of his or her height. According to the National Institutes of Health, a BMI of 25-29.9 is considered overweight and a BMI of 30 or greater is considered obese.

But the authors of the study, published in the April 2 issue of PLoS One, say that measurement leads to many false diagnoses.

For their study, the researchers reviewed more than 9,000 charts of patients who visited a medical private practice in New York City. Patients were an average of 51 years old, and 63 percent were women. Researchers wanted to compare how BMI tests measured against a different test to measure obesity, called a duel-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). The DXA is a machine that uses x-rays to measure muscle, bone mass and body fat.

What did they find?

BMI tests found 26 percent of patients were obese, while DXA indicated 64 percent were obese. What's more, 39 percent of patients found to be not obese by BMI standards were classified as obese by the DXA test. BMI tests were twice as likely to misclassify women, the researchers found.

"A 55-year-old woman who looks great in a dress could have very little muscle and mostly body fat, and a whole lot of health risks because of that - but still have a normal BMI," Braverman told CNN. "People aren't being diagnosed [as obese], so they're not being told about their risk of disease or being given instruction on how to improve their health."

So why doesn't every doctor's office use a DXA machine? They're very expensive, so it's not a practical routine test. But Braverman told HealthDay that a simple blood test that measures levels of the appetite-regulating hormone leptin along with a BMI test can provide a more accurate obesity measurement. The researchers found high leptin levels correlated with body fat, especially for women, and those with the lowest leptin levels were skinniest. Leptin blood levels range from 0 to around 200, and Braverman told WebMD optimal levels are under 5.

The researchers also suggest changing the BMI cut-offs for obesity to 24 for women and 28 for men to maximize accuracy and get more doctors warning their patients of obesity-related diseases.

Obesity is associated with an increased risk of diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, stroke, and cancer, among other diseases.

WedMD has more on obesity.

16 Photos

F as in Fat: Top 15 fattest U.S. states

[slatep]

A good reason to dump technology (electric powered everything) and go back to the good ole days and people powered everything.

[abby_del_abbey]

Everywhere you go you see people with their bellies bulging; some are so obese they can barely walk. Yet they're still stuffing their faces with unhealthy food and refusing to exercise. They only "exercise" they get is to drive through the fast food drive-thru and order the "super-size" meals.
While doctors can usually tell if someone is overweight just by looking at the person, it does not take a genius to figure out if you're overweight or not. A good look at yourself in the mirror after you step out of the bath should tell you. But people are in denial. They say that they're "big boned" or "built that way." They say that they're "healthy" because they are at that moment non-symptomatic for diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, etc., or least they believe they are.
Doctors need to be honest with their patients and offer constructive advice. But the doctors and nurses also need to present a good role model. How many of them are overweight? That makes people think it's okay to be overweight as well.

[MagJuno]

Obesity may be correlated with disease, but it is not a causal factor. 30 minutes of daily exercise eliminates most of the negative correlations. There is, at present, no sure way to make obese people thin. 95% of weight loss diets fail; in five years, people who dieted are back where they started of heavier. Rather than "diagnosing" people with obesity, we need to accept diversity of body size and encourage people to find movement that they enjoy. This is what the evidence suggests.

[DrJohnWarren]

Back in my days as a Marine, I weighed 200 pounds. Today I weigh 200 pounds. By BMI I'm the same person despite said weight having made a measured withdrawal southward toward a more stable and defensive... and dispersed position.

People are always looking for the easy cure, the easy out, the easy diagnosis, and in doing so, they do immense damage. BMI is one of those.

[Smokinjoe36]

They say a man my size (6'1") should weigh 165 pounds. LOL
I lift every day and have almost no body fat and weigh 215 pounds. According to their guidelines, I am obese. LOL

[xfghsfthuyrfth]

You have quite a bit of muscle on your frame.

[lraskie]

Changing the BMI index for 24 and 28 is a ridiculous idea, I'm tiny and my BMI is a 25, I'm most definitely not obese by any standards. They need to find a more accurate way other than BMI if this is the case, like using a skin pull to accurately diagnose the amount of body fat...