January 10, 2011 4:23 PM

Arizona Shooting: Will Jared Loughner Face the Death Penalty?

By
Carlin DeGuerin Miller
Topics
Daily Blotter

Arizona Shooting: Will Jared Loughner Face the Death Penalty?

Jared Loughner (Personal Photo)

NEW YORK (CBS) The father of Christina Green, the youngest victim in the Tucson, Arizona shooting spree, told CBS News that suspect Jared Loughner should be put to death, and according to a Phoenix defense attorney, it's likely that Loughner will face death penalty trials at both state and federal level.

PICTURES: Arizona Shooting Victims

Crimesider spoke with Adrian Fontes, a Phoenix defense attorney who practices criminal law in federal court, about whether or not prosecutors will pursue the death penalty against Loughner.

Fontes said the first question is one of jurisdiction - who will try Loughner? - and that in this regard Loughner's case resembles that of Timothy McVeigh. McVeigh was tried and convicted in both state and federal court of capital charges for the Oklahoma City Bombing in 1995 and was executed by the U.S. Government in June of 2001.

Loughner is currently only facing federal charges, but state charges are likely.

On the federal level, at least one of the five charges currently against Loughner is considered an "automatic" death penalty offense: the killing of federal judge John M. Roll, a United States District Judge. Other factors are that his alleged target, Rep. Giffords, was shot while performing her official duties, as were three of the other wounded, federal employees who were assisting Rep. Giffords.

On a state level, the case appears to meet many of the requirements for the death penalty in Arizona. The statute defines capital homicide as one where the suspect "knowingly created grave risk of death to persons in addition to victim; [the act is] especially heinous, cruel or depraved...[and/or involves an] adult person and victim under 15 or over 70."

There is also the question of premeditation, according to Fontes, did Loughner plan the attack?

Loughner's YouTube rants would seem to say yes, and it's likely that state prosecutors will point to those and letters found in his home as proof that Loughner planned the attack.

According to Fontes, the decision to pursue the death penalty is not a decision prosecutors make lightly - despite any public outcry - but Fontes said he wouldn't be surprised if the federal prosecutor's office wasn't already preparing their death penalty certification application.

For John Green, the father of 9-year-old Christina, the death penalty is fitting. "My wife is very forgiving in that regard," Green told CBS' "The Early Show." "I'm a little about the Old West. It's a fairly clear-cut case, and I'm a fan of capital punishment in this regard," .

COMPLETE COVERAGE OF THE ARIZONA SHOOTING FROM CBS NEWS

6 Photos

Arizona Shooting Victims

View the Full Gallery »


Add a Comment
by SFOD-Bravo January 12, 2011 9:59 AM EST
I can't say I'm a religious person but growing up I always heard the "wages that sin pays is death".....
I say let him live in misery as long as possible so as not to relieve him of his unwarranted heinous acts.
Reply to this comment
by VA_Jill January 11, 2011 7:19 PM EST
Life in prison without parole. In solitary. With pictures of the people he shot staring at him from the walls.
Reply to this comment
by barbiedawle January 12, 2011 12:12 AM EST
definitely. I'm not a fan of the death penalty... just saying.
by betterusa January 11, 2011 9:23 AM EST
HE TOOK SIX LIVES! 13 others were shot including a US Congressperson. He planned this shooting, he bought a weapon and after emptying a clip on his victims, he was reloading - this is not an insane person - this was an angry individual with a mission. If the death penalty is not a deterrent (according to certain libs) then why do criminals (and their attorneys) fight like hell to keep themselves alive? I can accept life in prison without parole if they lock his a$$ in a dark, 4x4 cell with no human contact and slide his bread and water under the door for the rest of his worthless life. At least he is getting the same surroundings as his 6 victims only he gets bread and water.
Reply to this comment
.

Follow Crimesider

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
48 Hours New iPad app A perfect companion to TV's most popular true-crime series.
CBS News on Facebook