October 18, 2010 8:25 AM

Animal Abuse Registry: First-in-Nation Law in NY County Sick of Cruelty

By
Barry Leibowitz
Topics
Daily Blotter

(CBS/AP)

FARMINGVILLE, N.Y. (CBS/AP) You've probably heard of Megan's Laws, designed to keep sex offenders from striking again. Now there's a law created to prevent animal abusers from inflicting more cruelty - or moving on to human victims.

Suffolk County, on the eastern half of Long Island, moved to create the nation's first animal abuse registry last week, requiring people convicted of cruelty to animals to register or face jail time and fines.

"We know there is a very strong correlation between animal abuse and domestic violence," said Suffolk County legislator Jon Cooper, the bill's sponsor. "Almost every serial killer starts out by torturing animals, so in a strange sense we could end up protecting the lives of people."

The online list will be open to the public, so that pet owners or the merely curious can find out whether someone living near them is on it. Some animal abusers have been known to steal their neighbors' pets.

Cooper is also pushing legislation that would bar anyone on the registry from buying or adopting a pet from a shelter, pet shop or breeder.

The law was prompted by a number of animal abuse cases in recent months, including that of a Selden woman accused of forcing her children to watch her torture and kill kittens and dozens of dogs, then burying the pets in her backyard.

Animal welfare activists hope the law, passed unanimously Tuesday in the suburban New York City county of 1.5 million people, will inspire governments nationwide in the same way Megan's Law registries for child molesters have proliferated in the past decade.

A spokesman for county Executive Steve Levy said he intends to sign the legislation. It then requires a six-month review by state officials before it goes on the books, said the spokesman, Dan Aug.

More than a dozen states have introduced legislation to establish similar registries, but Suffolk County is the first government entity to pass such a law, said Stephan Otto, director of legislative affairs for the Animal Legal Defense Fund.

The Suffolk County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals will administer the database, to be funded by a $50 fee paid by convicted abusers. All abusers 18 or older must supply authorities with their address, a head-and-shoulders photograph and any aliases. Convicted abusers will remain on the registry for five years. Those failing to register face up to a year in jail and a fine of up to $1,000.

As Fred Surbito took his Yorkshire terrier, Sasha, in for grooming at a Farmingville pet store this week, he applauded the legislation.

"It's very, very important," he said. "If you don't love an animal, you should not have an animal. An animal is part of your family. Like your children, they should never be neglected or harmed. Anybody that does should never own a pet again."


Add a Comment
by animalownerfarmer January 14, 2011 9:40 AM EST
We often see when someone is charged with animal abuse before a day in court they are already seen as guilty along with threats of harm or wishing, or "burn in hell" or they would fall off the earth. Many people have been called or e mailed with death threats, while this may be just a threat with fringe groups in animal rights and unstable activist it should be a concern. Many different activist organizations seem to draw those who are just looking for a cause, not only animal rights activist. There are laws for threatening people by e mail, phone of death or bodily harm. How seriously will authorities take these calls and protect, not only the animals but the humans. Really have a concern that some "nut job in the animal rights extremist groups" may like to take matters into their own hands. Remember Biden's breeder who was found innocent of abuse charges after selling a dog to Biden? She received death threats! In the final analogy what is the main point of an animal abuse registry? The studies in child abuse registries have shown it does not curb child abuse? Has DWI registries deterred the drunk driver? I do not agree with any true animal abuse where anyone harms an animal, but one has to not go overboard to the point where humans are crucified before a court trial. All of this sets a dangerous presidence. I believe in animal welfare and also raise animals to feed the USA, and I imagine that itself is unpopular and almost a crime in itself as in some arenas of thought, I am a murderer in raising animals food.
Reply to this comment
by nygln December 5, 2010 10:41 PM EST
They're not looking to form a registry of animal abusers simply as an effort prevent future serial murderers, and no, that doesn't mean hunters are more prone to "random killing". Though some behaviors may be more socially acceptable than others, the cruelty they are trying to prevent, by definition, is anything which "is intended to cause extreme physical pain; or is done or carried out in an especially depraved or sadistic manner." I don't think the people who put forth the legislation to create and pass this bill were considering themselves as candidates for the "perfect ones" registry. Perhaps these "perfect" people are tired of offenders like the two men in Detroit who recently decided to cover their dog in lighter fluid, set fire to her, and record her death via cell phone, repeat hoarders who continue to replenish what animals the authorites seize from them, the father and son that beat their dog to almost to death with a baseball bat and left it still breathing on the ground with broken ribs, legs and a missing eye while they dug it's grave, the man who takes it upon himself to destroy his neighbor's dogs, or any other multitude of "imperfect" human beings. It's not another crazy list because we all like making crazy lists of people who are a little different, it's meant to prevent people from commiting repeat animal abuse offenses.
Reply to this comment
by branch15 October 25, 2010 3:43 PM EDT
Wow, profilers find that serial murderers often abuse animals in their childhood and so that means that anyone who hunts is at a higher risk for random killing? Have we lost our minds? We need registries for mean people, bad neighbors, and narcissists. Better yet, why don't we have a registry for the "perfect ones". It would be a much shorter list and require less time away from our Leave it to Beaver families. What happens when THEY uncover everyone?
Reply to this comment
by corrine11 October 21, 2010 12:33 AM EDT
I support this 100%! This is a great thing. There are cruel people out there - and forget about the sick, cruel people. There are seriously neglectful people as well!
Reply to this comment
by carolynB1953 October 20, 2010 8:11 AM EDT
"requiring people convicted of cruelty to animals to register or face jail time and fines"

Wow this is great that means NY State DEC better get those licenced sports hunters specifically the bowhunters to register because they knowingly commit horrific cruelty to animals for amusement which is just as disgusting as shooting an arrow into an innocent defenseless dog or cat for amusment.

Here are some videos

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrJ9jmou0ik
(this particular bowhunter is from NY and how bowhunted deer suffer to die sometimes left overnight)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jb5UczhEkFE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Weoy4SYOxwQ&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_1aHVfH1Ng
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6gYSDmmQrY&feature=relatedhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?

I believe you should all view the video and then see for yourself because we cannot be living in a nation of hypocrisy can we? And I don't believe cruelty to animals should be a "recreation" what kinds of a contradicting message are we sending to chilldren if we can cause deliberately pain and suffering to a deer for amusement yet we say it's wrong to do it to a dog or cat? Because it's "legal" it's "ok"? Slavery was once legal but it was totally evil and also in Fla. Beastiality is legal does that make is right? Absolutely NOT! Please be fair and register the NY Bowhunters then and hopefully we can do this to many other states and add their bowhunters.


"We know there is a very strong correlation between animal abuse and domestic violence," said Suffolk County legislator Jon Cooper, the bill's sponsor. "Almost every serial killer starts out by torturing animals, so in a strange sense we could end up protecting the lives of people."

Monsters among us who kills for sports - WARNING-Video is GRAPHIC AND DISTURBING
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sduc_FDdHG0
Reply to this comment
by cyndie966 October 20, 2010 12:34 AM EDT
Hats of SUFFOLK County...I support and stand by your new law...Every county in every state should follow your example and be ashamed if they don't make this a law in their county..Once again STANDING OVATION you are the smartest county in all 50 states...Way to go Jon Cooper and everyone else who made this happen...You should feel very proud of yourself's...Cindy from Michigan..
Reply to this comment
by CACBINFO October 18, 2010 11:29 AM EDT
Welcome to Complaints Against Cat Breeders Info

If you have purchased an expensive pedigree cat or kitten from a *registered pedigreed cat breeder & you are not satisfied with your purchase & the registered cat breeder refuses to want to deal with you. You have emailed them, called them, the breeder will not answer you whatsoever. But they were quick to take your money that is for sure. You have come to the right site.

If you've been defrauded by *registered pedigree cat breeders, please know that you are not alone. You can reach out to others who've been taken advantage of, just like you have. Together we are no longer victims, but we certainly are VICTORS, we can heal one another through this experience.

We are CACB.INFO, the survivors network of those taken advantage of by *registered pedigree cat breeders, & were sold inferior pedigree cats whom had compromised health issues before it left the breeders cattery. Due to the impaired health of these cats, we were then were ripped off financially & emotionally by the entire experience.

We are the nation's only, victor support group for women and men taken advantage of by mainly CFA registered cat breeders. These breeders mainly make a living in their homes as cat breeders & some are serious exhibitors campaigning their show cats all around the world, & some are just hobbist. We are an independent and confidential network, with no connections with the world of pedigree cat breeders registries or governing bodies whatsoever. And we are here to help.

We also provide a safe and productive outlet for the passion many victors feel toward preventing future abuse.

Our web site exists to provide support and knowledge to all trusting, protential cat buyers [who have been taken advantage of & was sold either a sickly cat or kitten], & to help educate the public. We want the word to get out on how disreputable registered pedigreed cat breeders do business in our market place worldwide.

Welcome! Reach out! Get help!
http://ca-catbreeders.info
http://sicb.info

Thank God the NY officials are caring enough about the innocent pets God gave to us for our companionship and they need to be protected by demon possessed people who want to harm innocent pets. Thank you New York I pray all the 50 states look up to your policies and follow through developing them in each state God bless you NY officials
Reply to this comment
by davefromdayton October 18, 2010 10:36 AM EDT
Well done Suffolk County. Excellent idea. I will fully support any legislater that wants to enact similar legislation here in Ohio.
Reply to this comment
.

Follow Crimesider

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
48 Hours New iPad app A perfect companion to TV's most popular true-crime series.
CBS News on Facebook