Dow
     -11.39
12866.81
-0.09%
|
     -0.64
1346.41
-0.05%
|
     +1.68
14065.11
+0.01%
|
     +1.59
2905.67
+0.05%
|
     +0.11
54.08
+0.20%
|
     +1.28
114.68
+1.13%
|
     +0.01
1.98
+0.38%
Econwatch
March 10, 2010 1:26 PM

Out-of-Control Toyota Reports Multiplying

By
Alex Sundby
Topics
Toyota

On Monday James Sikes, seen at left, drove his Toyota Prius down a southern California highway when he experienced something now familiar to many Toyota owners: his car was accelerating past his intended speed and wouldn't slow down.

That's when Sikes grabbed his phone dialed 911. (Listen to his call below left) While trying to keep the car under control and hold the phone to his ear, the Prius sped up to 94 miles per hour. Eventually the emergency dispatcher sent a California Highway Patrol car to him, and officers instructed him how to reduce his speed before they accelerated in front of him and — driving bumper-to-bumper — guided the car to a complete stop.

Just two weeks before the alarming incident, Sikes had brought his Prius into a dealership, recall notice in hand, to have a technician look under the hood, but the dealership turned him away.

As federal officials begin an investigation to determine what caused Sikes' Prius to race out of control, a congressional committee revealed Wednesday that investigators are also looking at an incident involving a Lexus in nearby San Diego, reports CBS News Correspondent Nancy Cordes.

On Friday, an employee of a San Diego dealership was driving his 2006 Lexus IS 350 when he tapped the accelerator to beat a yellow light, Cordes reports. When he took his foot from the gas pedal, the car didn't slow down but continued to speed up. He put the car in neutral and coasted to the next traffic light. With the car in neutral, the driver tapped the gas pedal three times before the engine returned to normal. The car is on lockdown until federal investigators check it next week.

Even with executives from the Japanese car company apologizing to lawmakers and with television commercials advertising that their service centers are open around the clock, any time it appears like Toyota is moving past the problems in its cars another accident happens on U.S. roadways.

Local Video from CBS 2 HD in New York

On Tuesday, a housekeeper pulled out of her driveway in Harrison, N.Y., when the 2005 Prius shot across the street and smashed into a stone wall, ruining the front end.

"It's hard for us to determine whether it was a stuck accelerator or whether or not the vehicle accelerated for some other reason," Harrison Police Capt. Anthony Marracini told CBS News Station WCBS-TV in New York.

Further north, in Yarmouth, Mass., Anne Wilkins was behind the wheel of her Toyota Rav 4 when the SUV slammed into a medical building Tuesday. The accident happened after she brought the vehicle to her dealer in February to prevent its gas pedal from sticking, reports CBS News Station WBZ-TV in Boston. Local police plan to test the vehicle this weekend to determine whether Toyota's recall issues contributed to the crash.

This week's incidents add to others that have been reported since Toyota CEO Akio Toyoda apologized for his company's lapses in safety and told a congressional panel that his managers will drive cars under investigation to experience potential problems first hand.

Local Video from WBZ in Boston

For example, the owner of a 2009 Camry, Stewart Stogel, of Mount Vernon, N.Y., told The Associated Press he narrowly missed driving over an embankment and hitting a wall when the mid-size sedan accelerated on its own Feb. 27, five days after being serviced as part of the recall.

Stogel said the car had accelerated two previous times before the recall fix, and both times he took it to dealerships to be checked. In one case it was inspected by a Toyota corporate technician who could find nothing wrong, he said.

Carolyn Kimbrell, 59, a retired office assistant in Whitesville, Ky., told the AP her 2006 Toyota Avalon accelerated around the same time as she was returning with her 9-year-old granddaughter from a trip to the mall. The incident occurred a week after her dealer inserted a metal piece into the gas pedal mechanism on Feb. 20 to eliminate the friction blamed for the pedal problems.

The dealer said her car wasn't covered by the floor mat recall, but agreed to do that fix after she reported the latest incident, she said.

Now she wonders if the company's remedies will solve the problem. "It just scares you," Kimbrell said.

More on Toyota's Troubles:

911 Call Reveals Prius Driver's Terror

Toyota's Prius Recall Coming "Soon"

Toyota Fires Away at Acceleration Theory

House Panel Seeks Details on Toyota Recall

New Reports of Post-Recall Toyota Troubles

No Fix? Trouble with Some Repaired Toyotas

Senate Committee Members' Toyota Links

NYT: Troubles Predate Recalled Toyotas


  • Alex Sundby

    Alex Sundby is an associate news editor for CBSNews.com

Add a Comment See all 103 Comments
by zippiez March 17, 2010 10:18 AM EDT
Mechanical, electrical, or software engineering problem or a combination of all three?
Industrial espionage or sabotage?
Just a "plain" old virus introduced?
Reply to this comment
by ladyang March 12, 2010 7:38 PM EST
There will be more stories of Toyota cars being blamed for everything, from cars running out of gas, to running down a cheating spouse. Watch for it!
"I don't know what happened officer, I swear the brakes just wouldn't stop the car. My wife just happened to standing right in front of the car as it barreled right over her. I just couldn't get the car to stop!"
Toyota and the insurance industry would go broke investigating every case of stuck accelators.
I hope someone is watching out of abuse!
Reply to this comment
by Uncle_Eccoli March 15, 2010 6:37 PM EDT
I agree completely. This is all a bunch of absurd nonsense. I want to see numbers on how many poor and/or careless drivers ran their cars into buildings or up embankments before all this "unintended acceleration" stuff had saturated the news media. I'd bet dollars to doughnuts you'd wouldn't see any significant deviation between Toyotas and any other car.
by thomderr1 March 12, 2010 7:10 PM EST
Not to say that I am right or wrong however, I haven't read much on this topic: Cruise Control malfunction.

Point 1: The cruise control switch has to be the most common switch left in the 'on' position when not in use.

Point 2: The resume/accelerate mode causes the vehicle to speed up dramatically once a 'minimum speed', usually around 25 M.P.H. is reached, topping out at the set speed or accelerating past that set speed when needed. (If your set speed is 70 and you select resume, your car 'floors it'!)

Point 3: The braking system 'usually' deactivates the resume/accelerate or normal cruise mode.

Most drivers, after clicking 'resume' on the vehicles, feel an increase in acceleration quicker than they had planned. It seems to me that this may be a failure of the likes of "Cruise Control Gone Wild."

A drive by wire malfunction of all of the interconnected systems.

I am not an automotive engineer. I just remember the feeling the first time that I hit 'resume' without gradual acceleration.
Reply to this comment
by stychokiller March 17, 2010 9:16 PM EDT
@thomderr1:
I do not understand why some engineer thought that an agressive acceleration slope was necessary in the cruise control of newer vehicles wither. My 1990 Dodge Dakota Truck accelerates at a reasonable rate when the "Resume" control gets activated. I've drive a 1989 Jeep Cherokee, a 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee, and a 2001 GMC Safari mini van where the vehicle simply opens the throttle all the way when the cruise control is "Resumed". Of course, once you've driven them once, you know what to expect, AND the brake overrides the cruise control system. I suspect that these incidents are more due to driver error than anything else. Statistics show that most of the folks experiencing this problem are drivers over the age of 40. Either the electronics of these vehicles are smart enough to know the age of the driver OR... the drivers aren't as smart as the vehicles. Which seems more logical?
by dealersfirst March 12, 2010 1:39 PM EST
With as many problems as are prevalent in the auto industry today, you would think that a competent auto manufacturer like Toyota could get it fixed.

What pain and suffering this is causing to auto companies, auto workers, dealerships, auto owners, lenders, floorplan financing companies and the American government.

More and more problems within the industry will ultimately benefit no one.

-R. Howard
Dealers First Financial
http://www.dealersfirst.com
Reply to this comment
by tsaojamescar March 11, 2010 7:14 PM EST
This is why you should never completely trust a brand. Just look at Toyota now. Check out a variety of automakers before making a decision on which to buy. Check out Carsala for the range of cars that you can buy at the lowest possible prices. And for the people out there who have had bad experiences with car dealers, Carsala goes through the whole car-buying process for you with the lowest price guaranteed.
Reply to this comment
by tooloose2 March 11, 2010 9:53 AM EST
OH WHAT A FEELING TOYOTA!!!!!!!.............shame, shame shame...
Reply to this comment
by Hanks2010 March 11, 2010 9:51 AM EST
Let's put some historical perspective on all of this... Anyone remember the Ford Pinto?

http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2010-02-01/historys-10-biggest-car-blunders/#gallery=1280;page=1
Reply to this comment
by tooloose2 March 11, 2010 9:55 AM EST
I don't have time to remember anything but......OH WHAT A FEELING TOYOTA!!!!!!!!!!!...........A feeling of shame..
by iirishamerican March 11, 2010 5:03 PM EST
The Pinto thing was really bad it killed 27 people. It shows a person how bad the toyota thing is toyota unintended acceleration has killed 52. They still have Pinto jokes and that was in the 70's.
by dontknowitall March 11, 2010 6:35 AM EST
Remember Pearl Harbor.
Reply to this comment
by Dgunner March 11, 2010 5:57 AM EST
When you send your american dollars overseas you deserve everything that happens to you.Next sunday after praying to God to save your economy. BE sure jump up and run to wal-mart before you drive your children and grandchildren to the park or out for a ice cream cone that could cost them thier life.I GET GREAT JOY FROM THE DEMISE OF ALL YOU TRAITORS.ARE SMART ENOUGH TO KEEP YOUR CHILDREN OUTN OF THAT DEATH TRAP? WE WILL SEE.
Reply to this comment
by stychokiller March 17, 2010 9:20 PM EDT
@Dgunner:
-- So, I suppose that means you've NEVER drank Tequila, or Russian Vodka or French Wine.
You're happy NEVER having eaten Chinese Food.
How limited your life must be, given the current Global economy. Good luck finding much of anything that's made exclusively in whatever Country you live in!
by Cyber998 March 11, 2010 5:47 AM EST
52 deaths in 5 years? We average 50,000 road deaths a year in the USA, so "out-of-control" Toyota's are responsible for 0.02% or 1 in 5,000 road fatalities.

Hardly "massively unsafe" vehicles. There are many car models of various brands with far higher fatality rates than that.
Reply to this comment
by iirishamerican March 11, 2010 5:06 PM EST
the pinto only caused 27 deaths, was that a safe car too?
See all 103 Comments
.

Follow Econwatch

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook