Political Hotsheet
By

Rebecca Kaplan /

CBS News/ August 17, 2012, 3:08 PM

Ryan denies requesting stimulus funds

Republican vice presidential candidate, Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis. listens to the crowd response during his speech at a campaign stop at Walsh University in North Canton, Ohio, on Thursday, Aug. 16.

/ AP Photo/Phil Long

(CBS News) YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio -- Rep. Paul Ryan told a Cincinnati television station in an interview airing on Thursday that he "never asked for stimulus" money made available by the Recovery Act, contradicting documents that show he advocated for Wisconsin companies that were seeking funds.

"I opposed the stimulus because it doesn't work, it didn't work. It brought us deeper into debt. It was about $1.1 trillion when you add the borrowing cost, it put us deeper in debt and further out of work," Ryan told WCPO in an interview.

Subsequently, after reports about the contradiction emerged, Ryan said he checked his files and amended his answer. He said that while he never personally asked for funding, his staff had written in support of it.

"They were treated as constituent service requests in the same way matters involving Social Security or Veterans Affairs are handled. This is why I didn't recall the letters earlier. But they should have been handled differently, and I take responsibility for that," he said. "Regardless, it's clear that the Obama stimulus did nothing to stimulate the economy, and now the president is asking to do it all over again."

(Listen to a clip of Ryan's 2010 interview with WBZ.)

The Boston Globe reported on Tuesday that Ryan wrote letters in 2009 to Energy Secretary Steven Chu supporting grant applications for Recovery Act funds. The Wall Street Journal subsequently published one of the letters.

"I am writing to express my support for the grant application submitted by the Energy Center of Wisconsin and its partners for the Recovery Act - Training Program Development for Commercial Building Technicians, Building Operators, and Energy Commissioning Agents/Auditors," Ryan wrote in one such letter. "I have reviewed the partners' grant narrative, and I believe that they would make effective use of the funds they would receive from the DOE."

Ryan similarly denied requesting stimulus money in a 2010 interview with WBZ's Nightside with Dan Rea.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
57 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
reformed_druid says:
Helping others who want them is not the same as requesting them yourself. Get your heads out of your collective *****! Obama has had four years to do something constructive, when are you people going to stop waiting for him to do something and admit failure and bad judgement? Yes a lot needs to change in this country, but being forced into a communist hell hole isn't the answer.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bitterbloger says:
Sure to be the first of several "are you going to believe me, or your lyin' eyes" moments for Ryan.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tvwatcher5345 says:
but did he vote for two unfunded wars?? and the prescription drug benefit which is bankrupting this counrty???, obama will get re-elected with unemployment over 8%, obama is another ronald reagan
reply
RollotheNorman replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Blasphemy!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
philom-2009 says:
Romney's V.P. - An Echo of His Master's Voice

No more speculation about who it will be
now that Romney has finally named his presidential V.P.
The noise heard was a collective groan
when Mitt announced in choosing Paul Ryan he had picked a clone.

When Paul agrees with Mitt that money given to the wealthy to the poor trickles down
does he know he's quoting a phrase coined by a clown?
Humorist Will Rogers used the expression
to try to raise the people's spirits during the Depression.

Today like Romney the affluent place their ill-gotten gains
in off-shore accounts in places where it seldom rains.
And where the tax man is so kind
that when they pay few, if any, taxes he does not mind.

Paul is another who laps up Ayn Rand's skewed philosophy with unbounded admiration
and says for him it has always been an inspiration.
He agrees that giving to those in need is tommyrot
for one should always give to those who've got.

When he announces his plans for benefits like food stamps, Medicare and Medicaid
one can only wonder what he's imbibing with his lemonade.
Does he really expect voters to place their trust
in someone who believes prices paid by the poor do not rise but simply adjust?

Donald Trump, Ryan's supporter and infamous birther,
described by some as a Middle-Earther,
admonished him for announcing his budget plan
before the election was in the can.

Better to wait, he said, and not yet about his ideas brag
or he'd risk letting his cat out of the bag.
And Rupert Murdoch, that Antipodean epitome of fair play and straight dealing ,
agree s for America Mitt's and Ryan's plans are the most appealing.

Paul is advised by Cheney who, by some magical black art,
was finally able to acquire a heart.
Is Mitt's sidekick thankful to receive words of cheer
from the most notorious war profiteer?

If he's taking lessons from Dick about how animals to kill
he should remember that shooting is not his friend's greatest skill.
Paul should never consider inviting him on a deer hunting trip
or letting him on any kind of weapon get a grip.

As to Rush Limbaugh, to reject The Blob's blessing Paul would be wise
since his massive Viagra doses never helped him to any occasion rise.
Meanwhile Romney, by introducing Ryan as the next U.S. president with a ringing shout
shows he is still suffering from a serious case of foot-in-mouth.

When in the U.K. Mitt boasted that the Anglo-Saxons were the cream of the crop
in three of the Kingdom's countries a penny could be heard to drop.
In Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales exasperation was felt
by each and every inhabitant who takes pride in being known as a Celt.

As we witness the continuing pre-election drama
there is one thing where no-one can deny Paul Ryan beats Barack Obama.
But the President will probably shed no tears
when he hears Paul declare he is the one who has the bigger ears.

*****
As for me, I make no apology
for not being taken in by Romney's harebrained Mittology.

www.philitics.com
reply
RollotheNorman replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Pretty good actually, kudos.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Lindag20 says:
Now Ryan's claiming he "didn't know" the request for stimulus funds was a request for them. REALLY??? Looks like he just got caught on that one
reply
nonameindependent replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Will he claim to not know if he voted to keep the southern border open for the further invasion by foreign hostile hordes
linkicon reporticon emailicon
LouAz says:
Yea, sure. It is not your doing is it. It was your "staff". C'mon, is this what you and your "partner" are going to say when WW III starts ? Are you EVER going to accept responsibility for YOUR actions ? Just another pig with lipstick as Teapublican VP Nominee.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
WHAT-IS-HE-SMOKING says:
FLIP, I asked for the money
FLOP, No I didn't ask for the money
FLIP, Yes I did ask for the money.
reply
greenlantern1 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Did Ryan EVER oppose the Republican pork to build the bridge to nowhere?
WHAT-IS-HE-SMOKING replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I have not been able to find were he voted against it, but when a bill was introduced to cut the funding in 2011, it was shot down by, wait for it, THE REPUBLICANS. Shocked aren't you.

In HR662 there is continued funding for the above project. Rep. Jared Polis (D-CO), spoke in support of a motion to recommit the bill, with a very specific amendment, explained in his words, "This motion rescinds all remaining funds, about $183 million, provided for the planning, design, and construction of the two bridges under SAFETEA-LU" and that "According to the CBO this motion will reduce the deficit by $160 million by eliminating funding for these two bridges, nothing else."
3/2/2011 4:10pm: Floor summary: DEBATE - The House proceeded with ten minutes of debate on the Polis motion to recommit with instructions. The instructions contained in the motion seek to require the Committee on Transportation to report the bill back to the House forthwith with an amendment which inserts a section rescinding all unobligated balances of contract authority provided or reserved for planning, design, or construction of the Gravina Island bridge, Alaska, or the Knik Arm bridge, Alaska.[
In response Rep. Mica (R-FL), spoke in opposition responding "Well congratulations my colleagues welcome to the era of smoke and mirrors and that's exactly what this motion to recommit is and I urge its defeat. And you heard the gentleman describing bridges and he again is trying to mislead the entire house on this particular motion to recommit. It is smoke and mirrors, and I urge the defeat of the motion to recommit." which was the complete argument and explanation he gave, even though he was allotted a full 5 minutes to respond.
"On motion to recommit with instructions Failed by recorded vote: 181 - 246, 2 Present"
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jjoe57 says:
Today, there are news reports that Ryan has half-way admitted requesting stimulus money after being shown the letters with his signature. The darling of the conservatives is a blatant hypocrite, and a liar! Why CBS News and other media outlets aren't jumping on this, as well as Romney's refusal to release tax returns, is beyond me. Giving these guys a pass.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Yeah_Its_Me says:
Ryan is ranked as the most far from center candidate either major party has ever run! Do nationwide independents go for extreme candidates in either direction? That's a big no. If they did, Mittens' campaign wouldn't have said how he needs to track back to center after the primaries.
reply
benunhappy replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Does this intellegent IDIOT (RYAN) think it didn't cost us TAX PAYERS (unlike Romney) each and every time the congress refused to compromize.
sjc_1 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It is well documented that Ryan sought ARRA funds, it is certainly hypocritical of him to criticize the funds that he solicited.

You see this with Republicans, they talk about smaller government and lower taxes while they take their farm subsidies and defense contractor paychecks.

It is like the sign "keep your government hands off my Medicare", as if it came from somewhere else. They do not seem to make the connection and that is the problem.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
smartalecq says:
Too much stimulus and tax cuts will increase the national debt. But austerity will slow down the economy and lead to a 1920's like depression. Austerity can be implemented later, when the economy is more stable. Jobs are more important right now.

If Ryan is really concerned about the national debt, why is he always advocating for tax cuts. Ryan's rhetoric does not match the facts.

I still think that Obama would do a better job in the economy, and in lowering our national debt in the future.
reply
smartalecq replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
The stimulus was mostly:
- 1/3 infrastructure projects.
- 1/3 money back to state governments.
- 1/3 tax breaks.

We needed it to create/save jobs and to stimulate the economy. It was the right thing to do during that desperate time.

At least the money didn't go to democracy in Iraq.
SimonBau replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Obama WILL do a better job. Maybe Romney will create better growth figures, but he will not be creating more jobs and do so while not heavily increasing your gini coefficient.
http://simonbau.blog.com/?p=35
See all 57 Comments