Political Hotsheet
By

Lucy Madison /

CBS News/ May 21, 2012, 6:15 PM

Obama: Gains in Afghanistan fragile as Taliban remains "robust"

President Barack Obama speaks at a news conference at the NATO Summit in Chicago, Monday, May 21, 2012.

/ AP Photo/Kiichiro Sato

(CBS News) In a press conference marking the end of this year's NATO Summit, President Obama on Monday touted the group's formal agreement for a "responsible" withdrawal from the war in Afghanistan, and said that while gains in the country remain "fragile," he does not believe there will ever be an "optimal point" to withdraw.

"There is genuine improvement in the performance of Afghan National Security Forces, but the Taliban is still a robust enemy and the gains are still fragile," Mr. Obama told reporters in Chicago, where he hosted this year's two-day meeting.

Added the president: "I don't think that there's ever going to be an optimal point where we say, this is all done, this is perfect, this is just the way we wanted it and now we can wrap up our equipment and go home. This is a process and it's sometimes a messy process."

NATO leaders formally agreed Monday to Mr. Obama's timetable to turn primary security responsibilities in Afghanistan over to the Afghan people by the end of December 2014, pledging in a group declaration that the withdrawal would be done "gradually and responsibly" over the next two years. The alliance's 28 members also agreed that the transition would be "irreversible" and discussed how to build on the NATO-Afghanistan partnership going forward.

In his remarks, Mr. Obama acknowledged that the withdrawal of NATO troops from Afghanistan "will not mark the end of Afghanistan's challenges," nor would it mark the end of America's partnership with the country.

"We leave Chicago with a clear road map. Our coalition is committed to this plan to bring our war in Afghanistan to a responsible end," Mr. Obama said. "We also agreed on what NATO's relationship with Afghanistan will look like after 2014. NATO will continue to train, advise, and assist and support Afghan forces as they grow stronger." '

The transition is slated to begin in 2013, when Afghan security forces are expected to officially take the lead on combat operations. Not all countries involved will be abiding by the same timeline, however: Newly-inaugurated French President Francois Hollande has affirmed that he plans to withdraw French troops from Afghanistan by the end of this year, earlier than his predecessor had intended to do so.

When asked if the withdrawal was premature given the continued presence of the Taliban, Mr. Obama argued that further prolonging the drawdown would be unproductive at best.

"The Afghan security forces themselves will not ever be prepared if they don't start taking that responsibility," Mr. Obama said. "Frankly, the large footprint that we have in Afghanistan can over time be counterproductive."

Pointing potential to concerns among Afghan citizens over sovereignty, as well as America's domestic interests, Mr. Obama said that after ten years, "that's a strain."

"We've been there 10 years - 10 years in a country that's very different," he said.

The president acknowledged that the transition would not be without difficult moments.

"I think the timetable we've established is a sound one, it's a responsible one," he said. "Are there risks involved in it? Absolutely. Can I anticipate that over the next two years there are going to be some bad moments along with some good ones? Absolutely."

Mr. Obama also detailed a conversation he had with Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari and Afghan President Hamid Karzai on Monday while the leaders were about to take a group photo.

"Keep in mind my conversation with the President Zardari was very brief," Mr. Obama said. "I emphasized to him what we have emphasized publicly as well as privately. We think that Pakistan has to be part of the solution in Afghanistan, that it is in our national interest to see a Pakistan that is Democratic, that is prosperous and that is stable."

Mr. Obama said Zardari "shared with me his belief that these issues can get worked through." He said they never expected to resolve a stalemate over a deal to reopen a NATO supply routes through Pakistan during the summit, but "we're actually making diligent progress on it."

Two senior administration officials told CBS News Monday that a deal over the supply routes is very close and could come "in the very near future," according to one national security official.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
10 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
fredricwilliams says:
"Fragile"? Does this mean that our puppet government might last six months after we leave (if we ever do)? There are no gains -- fragile lives have been lost by the tens of thousands, children and women massacred by our own soldiers.

Mr. Obama may have won the Nobel Peace Prize -- but it certainly wasn't for bringing peace to anyone (unless this is the "Rest In Peace" prize.

The Carter-Bush-Obama Afghanistan War (yes, Carter got it started by arming a rebellion against the government of Afghanistan in 1978) shows the arrogance of American power.

Those who live by the sword will die in the same way.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
wfw3536 says:
It is so disappointing that the folks who claim to be Peace supporters are no where to be found or heard. We should be out of this war today, instead Obama has signed us on for another 10 year commitment. I guess the Peace groups are so in the tank for Obama they are afraid to stand up for what they believe. Oh the hypocrisy of these folks.
reply
JoSCh001 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
"Obama has signed us on for another 10 year commitment."

What are you talking about? 2014 is 2 years away, not 10. Keep voting R, it's working great for you.
wfw3536 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
JoSCh001-------------Maybe you were sleeping for a few days, as on May 1st of this year President Obama signed the Strategic Partnership Agreement with Afghanistan which continue for 10 years beyond 2014, and commits the US to assist in security and provides Billions upon Billions in military and financial aid. Keep voting for Obama and see this waste of money and American lives continue.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
gep1955 says:
This post has 7 comments, Fox has 700, why? three articles here about the NATO summit and not one word about the chaos and injuries to police by the Occupy protesters just wanting anarchy. If you can't report honestly you lose readers. Networks are for the anarchists and not for America. Pathetic.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
stormerF69 says:
Withdraw immediately and no money from the tax payers.Let them read their Quran.Not our responsibility to nation build.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
GeneralMorals says:
Why is CBS not reporting on a hate crime that happened by law enforcement against a quiet New England family?

Why this story instead?

Is the press oblivious to New England?
Not sensational enough?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Lerianis4 says:
With all due respect, Mr. Obama, what gains? The only thing we are doing is wasting our treasury on trying to 'fix' a country who liked living under the Taliban for the most part.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Observer1504 says:
Will someone please tell that ignorant SOB that this war is a useless mess ? After over 10 years the enemy still remains " Robust " ? The enemy can strike anywhere and anytime they wish. Our people are being murdered by those that they train. I predict that shortly before we pull our forces out that Karzai and the rest of the Afghan elite will leave that country and live very comfortable lives in a friendly country on the millions of American taxpayer dollars that they have stolen. Right now there is an American family that will eventualy get a visit from the team that will notify them that their son was the last American to die in Afghanistan ...for absolutely nothing. I did two in the bush tours in Vietnam and I hate to see this whole scenario played out again. The only thing that will be missing is the helicopter on the roof....
reply
Lerianis4 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Agreed. The only way to end the war in our favor is to realize it is lost and pull out, not wasting anymore American lives on this debacle.