Political Hotsheet
By

Phil Hirschkorn, Laura Strickler /

CBS News/ April 20, 2012, 9:01 PM

Pro-Romney super PAC maintains speed

Super PAC funding helping Romney
Last Updated Saturday 12:39 p.m. ET

(CBS News) NEW YORK - As the presidential campaign turned toward the general election last month, the super PAC supporting Mitt Romney raised three times more money than the super PAC supporting Barack Obama. But the president's campaign committee ended the first quarter of 2012 with ten times the cash on hand as the Republican challenger's.

During March, the pro-Mitt Romney super PAC raised $8.7 million and spent $12.7 million, according to its required monthly fundraising report with the Federal Election Commission. Some of its biggest givers were a Koch brother, investor Charles Schwab, tycoon Harold Simmons, and the hotel-running Marriott brothers.

Restore Our Future bumped up its donations by $2 million compared to the month before, and the pro-Romney group continued to out-pace the pro-Obama Priorities USA Action. Priorities USA raised $2.5 million in March, leaving it with $5 million entering April. It has already spent close to $1 million this month to run a pair of anti-Romney ads in general election battleground states - Colorado, Florida, Iowa, New Mexico, Ohio, and Virginia.

The pro-Romney super PAC came into March with $10 million cash on hand but reported having only $6.454 million coming into April. So far this month, Restore Our Future has spent at least $1.6 million on ads in Wisconsin - which held its primary April 3 - and in New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Delaware, which all hold primaries on Tuesday.

In a strategic switch reflecting rival Rick Santorum's exit from the presidential race, 83% of the pro-Romney super PAC's spending in April has been on positive pro-Romney ads.

Over a 15 month period starting in January 2011 and through March, Restore Our Future has raised $51.9 million and spent $45.4 million, far more than all the other presidential super PACs combined.

By comparison, the Romney for President campaign raised $12.6 million in March, bringing its total for the past 12 months to $87 million in primary funds. The campaign had $10.1 million cash on hand entering April.

The president's campaign, Obama For America, raised $35 million in March and spent $15.6 million, leaving it with $104 million cash on hand.

Unlike campaigns, which can accept a maximum of $2,500 per individual for the primaries and another $2,500 for the general election, there is no limit on what super PACs can receive and spend, thanks to a 2010 Supreme Court decision upholding expansive free speech rights of individuals, corporations, and unions in political campaigns.

The biggest giver last month to pro-Romney Restore Our Future was a company -- $1 million on March 5 from Huron Carbon, which is run by billionaire William Koch, a brother of Charles and David Koch, who run Koch Industries and are prolific conservative political donors.

Huron Carbon has the same Palm Beach, Florida, address as William Koch's Oxbow Carbon. Brad Goldstein, a Koch spokesman, told CBS News Huron is a subsidiary of Oxbow Carbon that specializes in "calcining," or making a calcine petroleum coke, a primary ingredient, for making aluminum.

Koch, worth as estimated $4 billion, and his company, Oxbow Carbon, previously gave a combined $1 million to Restore Our Future last year.

The second biggest March gift to the pro-Romney super PAC was from billionaire Chicago investor Ken Griffin, CEO of Citadel LLC, who gave $850,000 on March 12. Griffin had previously given Restore Our Future $200,000. Griffin has now given Restore Our Future $1,050,000, making him the 13th individual or company to cross the million dollar donor threshold for the pro-Romney super PAC.

With another $700,000 donation, Griffin was also the top giver in March to American Crossroads, the pro-Republican super PAC co-founded by Karl Rove, which raised just $1.2 million in March, but entered April with $24.4 million cash on hand.

The third biggest gift to the pro-Romney Restore Our Future in March was from a familiar name -- Texas tycoon and billionaire Harold Simmons, who gave Restore Our Future the group another $600,000 in two chunks: $100,000 on March 9 and $500,000 on March 19.

The third biggest gift in March was from a familiar name - Texas tycoon and billionaire Harold Simmons, who gave Restore Our Future another $600,000 in two chunks: $100,000 on March 9 and $500,000 on March 19.

Simmons, CEO of Dallas-based holding company Contran, had previously given the pro-Romney super PAC $200,000, for $800,000 overall. He has been more generous with super PACs, supporting Rick Perry, Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich - giving them each at least $1 million - and at least $12 million to American Crossroads, the pro-Republican super PAC co-founded by Karl Rove.

James Davis, the chairman of New Balance sneakers, from outside Boston, Massachusetts, gave Restore Our Future $500,000 on March 8. Steven Webster, a Houston equity fund manager, gave $500,000 on March 1.

Billionaire investment adviser Charles Schwab and his wife, Helen, who live in San Francisco, gave a combined $250,000, or $125,000 each, on March 13. Schwab, worth an estimated $3.5 billion according to Forbes, is the 17th billionaire to donate to the pro-Romney super PAC.

In addition, a Hamilton, Montana company, Fair Oaks Finance LLC, with an address apparently linked to the Schwabs, gave Restore Our Future $250,000 on March 21. The company's registered agent with Montana's Secretary of State is "Charles R. Schwab," and its address and the Schwabs are listed on a 2004 Federal Communications Commission radio service application for a working ranch in Montana, according to documents reviewed by CBS News. A representative for Mr. Schwab did not reply for comment.

The billionaire Marriott brothers - J. W. "Bill" and Richard -- each gave another $250,000 to Restore Our Future, on March 7 and 23, respectively. The hotel chain heirs and bosses both gave the super PAC $500,000 last June and another $250,000 in January, making them the 14th and 15th million dollar donors to ROF.

A Palm Beach company called Seaspray Partners, run by investor Scott Desano, gave Restore Our Future $400,000 on March 1. The firm is inactive, according to the Florida Secretary of State.

The Fox family of St. Louis - Jeffrey, Marilyn, and Sam -- gave a combined $300,000 -- three $100,000 gifts last month. Jeffrey Fox is CEO of the Harbour Group, a buyout firm, according to its website.

Los Angeles real estate developer Geoff Palmer gave $250,000 to the pro-Romney group on March 9, bringing his total to $500,000. A new giver, Betty Brown Casey, President of Casey Management, a real estate management company in Maryland, gave it $200,000 on March 29.

There were 16 other $100,000 donors to Restore Our Future in March.

Investor John Griffin, President of Blue Ridge Capital, in Florida, gave $100,000. Griffin is a "Tiger cub" apprentice of billionaire hedge fund legend Julian Robertson, CEO of Tiger Management, in New York, who previously gave $1.25 million.

The Linder family of Cincinnati, a family with a history of big Republican giving, now led by Carl Linder III, co-CEO of the American Financial Group, gave a combined $100,000.

Kelly Loeffler, owner of the WNBA franchise Atlanta Dream, gave Restore Our Future $100,000 on March 5. She listed herself as the VP of International Exchange. Her husband, Jeffrey Sprecher, Chairman of International Exchange, previously gave the super PAC $230,000 last year.

Smaller but substantial donors to the pro-Romney group included Rod Aycox, Owner and President of Select Management Resource, a Georgia-based pay day lender, who gave Restore Our Future $50,000 in March. Similarly, Axcess Financial, which specializes in prepaid MasterCards and debt recovery, gave it $35,000.

Billionaire Sam Zell, who previously gave the super PAC $50,000 last year, gave another $20,000 last month.

There were ten donors who gave Restore Our Future only $25. The smallest of the 135 donors in March was a New York City probation officer from Brooklyn, James Bennett, who gave $5 twice, for a total of $10.

The pro-Romney group did return at least one donation -- a $5,000 gift from last year from M.C. Dean, a government defense contractor based in Dulles, Virginia who was listed hosting at least one super PAC event at Bloomfield Hills Country Club in Michigan.

Endorse Liberty, the leading super PAC supporting Republican presidential candidate Ron Paul, has taken a serious dive in donations, receiving only $13,000 in March while spending $114,000. Its cash on hand coming into April was $53,984. For the second month in a row, the group's biggest benefactor, Silicon Valley billionaire Peter Thiel, did not contribute. Thiel, CEO of Clarium Capital Management, previously gave the group $2.6 million.

On the other hand, the Paul campaign raised $2.6 million in March, leaving it with $1.8 million cash on hand and zero debt entering April. The campaign raised another $1.4 million April 15 in a Tax Day internet-fundraising drive, and is eyeing the May 29 Texas primary. Campaign Chairman Jess Benton said in a written statement, "These ample funds also will help us compete even harder in Texas, where Ron Paul is the only Texan, veteran, and authentic conservative running."

Editor's Note: An editing error in the 1Q numbers' totals of Restore Our Future has been corrected.

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
35 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
hypnotoad72 says:
"Restore our future"?

The people Romney represent never had anything to lose to require "restoration" in the first place.

Because he is not representing the middle/working classes.

http://www.popscreen.com/v/62Q3x/Romney-says-he%E2%80%99s-not-looking-to-put-money-in-peoples-pockets

http://motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2010/01/vicious-cycle-stagnant-wages

http://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/case/hiring-illegal-immigrants.html

http://hubpages.com/hub/HowH1BVisaFRAUDiskillingAmerica

http://www.realitybase.org/journal/2009/3/10/the-american-dream-died-in-february-1973.html
(forget the URL's name, read the charts within. They speak far more.)
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kevjustice says:
mitt has more baggage than o'hare airport. mitt hides his $ in swiss banks/caymen islands so he will not have to pay his fair share of taxes, will not release 10 yrs of taxes, represents the 1%, is the voice of wall st, etc. numerous awful statements: doesn't care about the poor, likes to fire people, etc. has offended women, latin people,etc. wants to cut people on soc security and give them discount coupons/vouchers. these are huge voting blocks. he is a long shot-a hail mary football throw.
reply
hypnotoad72 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Dan -

Provide some links to credible sources, please.

And see my other posts below.

And shove it with the partisan "lib thieves" drivel.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
zibulki says:
Maybe Obama can take all his earned money and pay down the deficit or use it to pay for his expensive programs instead of raising taxes next year.
reply
jimbom121 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
What expensive programs? Seems like Mitt could take all the money he "earns" doing nothing to help pay down the deficit...no?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jerr879 says:
It seems to me that all these super pacs that these millionairs and billionairs can afford to throw money at can pax extra taxes as well.Or since they got so much damn money to throw away they can afford to hire more ppl.Seems to me most all rich ppl care about is themselves and how they can screw someone else!!
reply
vsmit replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You'd think with the FREE Obama bully pulpit he uses to talk down to the rest of us would get donations too. Seems like the liberals just care about themselves, what free money can Obama get them.
76SpiritOf replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
the only question that I have is what strings are attached to the money?

Millionaires and billionaires did not get where they are by giving money away.

What promises is Romney making to get these huge donations to spuer PACs that are supporting him.

Here in Wisconsin and business owner donated $ 9,200 to Walker and he was rewarded with a $ 650,000 grant to "create" jobs. Thats a return of 70 to 1 on an investment in less than a year!

Where do I sign up. I'll gladly give the GOP or the democrate 50K for a return of 70 to 1.

The problem is only the winner can provide a return so I'll 25K to each side to hedge my bets and recieved 2.1 million from the taxpayers.

Where do I sign up. Afterall as a taxpayer I have already given to wealthy in the last so it's my turn.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
longtree-2009 says:
yeah, yeah. but so tired of obama. if romney selects rice and it's romney/rice vs. obama/biden, will give as much as i can to romney's pac. not a milionaire by any stretch of the imagination but am willing to do without to help romney/rice overthrow obama/biden. if it's not romney/rice, then will grudgingly vote for obama/biden.
reply
jimbom121 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
why? Do you miss invading sovereign nations who did nothing go us?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nonpolitico says:
The Muck throwing and lies will only get worse on the way to November!
In Europe, they envy the rich who have made it from nothing, and seek to tax them very heavily. (They are mainly Socialists).
Obama is alleged by some also to have Socialist leanings.
However if he has grafted Socialist ideas into Washington, there will be NOTHING that voters can do at the election, as the Civil servants write all the legislation, and can do anything with the fine print, even turn capitalist America into a Socialist "dream", in which the "failings" of representative government can be argued.
I believe a certain Herr Hitler got elected on a Socialist promise back in the 1930s.
HIS election changed the world. Fortunately we can ensure Pres Obama has to leave after one term, and possibly avoid further damage to the US Constitution AND citizens` Rights And Freedoms!
Choose well in November!!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Bryon_Evans says:
Vote Mormon!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bonzothemonkey says:
Romney states unequivocally he wants to see those tax rates dropped even lower! Wake up America!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bonzothemonkey says:
Electing a man to the Presidency with a "robber baron" mentality like Mitt Romney's is akin to allowing the fox into the henhouse. This man would be a disastrous mistake for America, most especially America's already diminishing middle class!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Smokey75 says:
I am sure all you liberals know by now that Bush gave a people making 1 million dollars a year a 35,000 a year tax cut.

But how many of you pro Obama sombies know that since Obama took office he ahs given them another 17,000 a year in tax cuts?

Here is a payroll calculator It will allow you to see what a person was brining home in 2008 and what they are bringing home now.

http://www.paycheckcity.com/calculator/netpay/us/arizona/calculator.html

Pretty funny the Obamabots actually believe he is for the middle class. But yet he is has given a person making 60,000 a year a $29 a week tax break where a persons making a million a year has gotten an additional $325 a week from Obama.
reply
bonzothemonkey replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It's a hard right wing Republican congress whose spearheading those tax giveaways to for Ultra Wealthy. They were riders attached to bills that Obama had to sign in order to get the vital legislation he knew was needed for the rest of America.
Smokey75 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Think again it was the payroll tax cut gave the millionaires the tax cut.
See all 35 Comments