Political Hotsheet
By

Lucy Madison /

CBS News/ April 12, 2012, 12:26 PM

Ann Romney to Hilary Rosen: My career choice was motherhood

Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney and his wife Ann.

/ EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP/Getty Images
As the Romney campaign continues to court women voters, Ann Romney is defending her career as a stay-at-home mom and says she has struggled plenty, even if not financially.

"My career choice was to be a mother," she said Thursday in an interview on Fox News. "We need to respect choices that women make."

The presumptive Republican presidential nominee's wife is in the midst of a firestorm after Democratic strategist Hilary Rosen suggested in an interview with CNN Wednesday that Mitt Romney was unqualified to speak about the kinds of economic issues facing women in America because his knowledge of women's issues comes from his wife, who had not struggled financially the way many women do because she had never "worked a day in her life."

"She should have come to my house when those five boys were causing so much trouble," Ann Romney laughed.

" I know what it's like to struggle, and if maybe I haven't struggled as much financially as some people have, I can tell you and promise you, that I've had struggles in my life," she added.

Rosen's comments have sparked an uproar among Republicans, who have called on Democratic National Committee chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz to apologize on Rosen's behalf for the comments, which they're casting as an "affront to mothers everywhere."

"Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz should immediately apologize for the insulting and insensitive comments of her adviser, Hilary Rosen," said Republican National Committee spokeswoman Kirsten Kukowski. "To suggest that any mother has 'never worked a day in her life,' is an affront to mothers everywhere."

In a Tweet Thursday, Wasserman Schultz responded, saying she was "disappointed" in Rosen's comments. "As a mother of 3 there's no doubt that raising children is work," Wasserman Schultz said.

Michelle Obama also made a rare appearance on Twitter to address the matter: "Every mother works hard, and every woman deserves to be respected," read a Tweet posted on her account signed "mo."

Rosen on Thursday sought steer the conversation toward Mitt Romney's record with policies for working women.

"This is not about Ann Romney. This is about the waitress in a diner in some place in Nevada who has two kids whose day care funding is being cut off because of the Romney/Ryan budget and she doesn't know what to do," Rosen said in a follow-up CNN interview. "Does Mitt Romney have a vision for bringing women up economically and can he himself stop referring to his wife as his economic surrogate? That's an important thing. He's the one that keeps doing this. Not me."

On Fox, Ann Romney rebuffed that idea, emphasizing not only her husband's commitment her own choices, but also to surrounding himself with women advisers.

"He listens to a lot of different women," she said. "I will tell you that Mitt said to me more times than you would imagine, Ann, your job is more important than mine."

As Mitt Romney seems increasingly poised at clinching the Republican presidential nomination, the candidate has made efforts to combat the Democratic accusation that he's insensitive to the needs of working-class women.

Ann Romney appears to be a crucial part of the equation.

"I've been on the campaign trail for one year, and guess what women are talking about?" she said Thursday. "They are talking about jobs, and they are talking about the legacy of debt that we are leaving our children. That's what I'm hearing."

© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
104 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cntrygirl3 says:
I have no problem with Mrs. Romney's choice. What I have a problem with is a Republican party that wishes to take away any other choice from American women. It is what Santorum ran on and ran pretty well. That is what is wrong and why Romney is behind with women double digits. The Republicans have made it very clear they believe the only proper role for women is the one Mrs Romney chose, and are prepared to pass whatever laws or repeal whatever laws are necessary to make this a reality. This is the war on women and it is very real.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
hharrison22 says:
I want to steer clear of the heavy politics surrounding this debate. However, it has ignited the age old Mommy War of "Whose job is the most difficult?" It is the stay at home mothers versus the working mothers. I talk more about this war here:
http://www.themommypsychologist.com/2012/04/12/mommy-wars-whose-job-is-more-difficult/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
dj_chi says:
Her career choice wasn't to be a mom - it was to marry a filthy rich guy and be set for life. Come on. She didn't struggle to raise a family like the average American - she called people, from her weekly appt at the spa, to take care of such mundane things.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
catzombie says:
I anyone thinks Mrs. Romney actually cooked cleaned and took care of those 5 boys by herself they are crazy. She had nannies, cooks and someone to drive them to school. She is not the typical stay at home mom and she needs to stop pretending like someone belittle her. She belittled her own self as mom by getting someone else to do her job. And very few women have a choice at staying at home especially after Bush ruined this country. Of course her husband sent many women home when he closed a lot of companies and factories. The video When Romney Came To Town will show you just how he made sure women and men too can stay at home while his pockets get fatter. Don't pity Mrs. Romney hard work for her was trying to pick the best nanny and cook. And she has absolutely NO voice for women that struggle.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Souptwins says:
Rosen was responding to a statement by Mitt that his wife would report back to him what women were saying to her on the campaign trail about what concerns them the most. For Rosen to say she has so right to provide this insight about the economy is just ridiculous. She's an intelligent & articulate woman who's been listening to all women from all over the country. Then to say she's "never worked a day in her life" is just insulting. She was mistaken in her assumption that "work" must involve a paycheck.
I saw an interview with Josh Romney who clarified that there were no nannies when he was growing up with just one woman who came to help clean once a week for about an hour. Hardly the lavish lifestyle with servants running around everywhere. They started their family while still in college and living in a basement apartment. I'm quite confident Ann Romney has "worked" plenty in her life and can report back on the conversations from other women concerning the economy. Rosen totally stepped in it with this one.
reply
mbryanm replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
They were so "hard up" that they even contemplated selling some of their invstments? Rosen speaks the truth, even if she did have to apologize for doing so. I mean no malice toward Ann Romney,but truth is truth. Managing a family under Ann Romney's circumstances is a far different cry from that of the middle class or the impoverished and she cannot have a clue thereof. I struggled to raise a family of four under very adverse circumstances and make a living at the same time. God and family prepared me for motherhood. Nothing prepared me for coping with the business part/working part of a poor economic reality. Any
other woman who has done the same can attest to which is hardest.
Truth is truth. If Mrs. Romney is going to be a spokesperson for her husband, then her remarks are subject to analysis. No apology was warranted.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Cru09 says:
"We need to respect choices that women make."

Too bad your husband and his party don't feel the same way.
reply
winchester95 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
She had a choice of course. It is easy when your husband hides his millions in Cayman Islands and pay only 15% in taxes unlike most of us who pay lot more at much less salary... Count your millions Ms Romney however this does not qualify you to know ANYTHING about real world
Souptwins replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
winchester-- I'm firmly in the middle class and paid 8%. More than 80% pay less than 15%. Pretty sure she's qualified to report back what women of all walks are reporting to her while on the campaign trail.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
citizenoflife says:
Why are people getting defensive about having to work outside the home to be considered a "real mom"? Isn't the ultimate hope of many mothers to be able to be with her children as much as possible? And don't we agree that a great mother is to be there, to support, to care for them - not to earn money for them (unless needed). In Ann Romney's case, she didn't NEED to earn money for her family, and therefore was able to support and care for her children full-time. Isn't that goal of most mothers: to be with their children and care for them as much as possible? I'm confused why we are saying Ann doesn't know how to be a true mom, when it seems she nurtured her children adequately enough.
Unfortunately we aren't more instructive and supportive of men and their vital roles in our lives, so many women and young mothers NEED to work outside their home to support their families. If that financial support is already being provided by a hard-working father, then mothers don't need to also provide financially for their families. Unfortunately that is not the case in many families, so many mothers have to do double duty - it is not required that mothers have to work away from their children unless they NEED to.
So, why are we saying that Ann doesn't know what it's like to be a true mother, when she fits all of the natural requirements of nurturing her children, just not the added requirements we as a society have placed upon women and mothers (such as working outside the home as a necessary part of motherhood)?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
BridgetteF says:
It surprised me to find out that according to some I don't know about economics since I stayed home to raise my eight children. Well I beg to differ.
When finances were tight in our family I had a budget of a dollar a day per person. We did this for several years. This included all food and other items I would buy at a grocery store like laundry detergent, toilet paper, shampoo etc. Sometimes I splurged and bought disposable diapers. We did it. It was tight but it was possible. We did not buy cold cereal, cookies or other snacks. Items like chips and soda pop were purchased a couple times a year as a special treat.
For breakfast we would eat things like oatmeal, cream of wheat, whole grain pancakes. Ten cents worth of oatmeal will fill up the tummy, when a dollars worth of cold cereal might not.
Cooked from scratch, ground my own grains, sprouted, grew a garden, canned, dehydrated, learned how to combine foods to get a complete protein, whatever it took to nourish my family. Purchased things in bulk, bought what was on sale and stocked up on those items. Meat was something added to other dishes, not often the main dish.
I did a preschool with other moms where we took turns teaching, I sewed for myself and my children. I designed my own cloth diapers with flannel and Velcro, I sewed jeans as well as other things. I can find a deal at a garage sale or a thrift store. I work on Birthday and Christmas gifts all year and am able to give several times the value of the money I spent.
If a mother has a husband working, they might be surprised when they truly look into economics. It might be financially better off to stay home to raise and nurture their children. Take into consideration childcare, as well as the extra you spend on fuel, career attire, convenience foods, services you could do yourself like cutting hair, shopping sales, decorating, tutoring, yard work, gardening, repairs and so many other things.
reply
Lindag10 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
The issue is that Ann Romney knows NOTHING about living on a tight budget like you do. She did NONE of the things you describe in order to make ends meet. She had all the money she ever needed to buy and do whatever she wanted to, servants to do the housework, tend to the yard, cook the meals, etc. That's why people find her so irritating.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Lindag10 says:
"I chose motherhood as a career"... Oh please!!! Women with children work because they HAVE to in order to keep a roof over their family's head, food on the table, etc. and then this pampered RB says something that shows she doesn't have a clue as to what it's like to work 8 or more hours in a day and then come home and put in several MORE hours fixing dinner, doing laundry, overseeing homework and all the OTERH myriad tasks that the average working mother accomplishes EVERY single day of their life. Ann Romney is SO out of touch with the rest of the US that she thinks that her lifestyle is the NORM. She should go on that show "Wife Swap" and trade places with a middle class working mom.
reply
CaardVaark replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I chose motherhood as a career too. I just didn't have enough money to get my choice so I had to work. Must be nice to be free to choose like Ann. I bet having a housekeeper and a personal chef was your choice too, huh Ann?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Larnan5 says:
Anne Romney and Mitt will never get it. They hob nob with the rich and famous and have no connection whatever with the poor and hard working middle class. I'm sure neither of them have ever had to cash a pay check that was mostly eaten up by bills already due or late and just hope there was enough left to get through the week.
reply
Lindag10 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I remember the "olden days" when you could kite a check a couple of days before payday and not have to worry about beating your paycheck to the bank. One day at work several of us single moms were talking about how we used to be able to do that and avoid late fees. Our manager, a childless married woman was in the group, smiling and nodding as if she knew what we were talking about although she had NEVER done anything like that in her entire life. Ann Romney reminded me of that incident.
See all 104 Comments
Scroll Left Scroll Right