October 28, 2009 7:30 AM

McCain: "It's Time to Act" in Afghanistan

By
Daniel Carty
Topics
Afghanistan
Sen. John McCain said the White House was dragging its feet on the decision to increase troop levels and chided President Barack Obama for the delay, saying "it's time to act."

"We watch this situation continue to deteriorate while this long protracted process of decision-making goes on. We're not operating in a vacuum. The president of the United States needs to make this decision and soon," McCain, R-Ariz., said on CBS' "The Early Show." (Watch the video at left)

Violence continues to flare up in that country as the president recommended by Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan. The Taliban claimed responsibility for 12 more deaths Wednesday, including one American, after in Kabul. U.S. troop deaths made October the deadliest month for American forces since the 2001 invasion.

Special Report: Afghanistan

But McCain said the spike in violence, believed tied to Afghanistan's upcoming runoff election, should not dissuade Mr. Obama from authorizing the troop increase.

"Yes, it's a heavy responsibility. But to drag that responsibility out and that process out is not helpful to our effort," he said.

The Afghanistan war effort is gaining some detractors. Matthew Hoh, an Iraq war veteran and State Department official, Tuesday in protest over the United States' continued presence there.

Hoh said the violence was rooted in opposition to the American occupation, not for ideological reasons.

McCain respectfully disagreed.

"The strategy is right. The strategy has been reviewed time and time again since march when the president announced his support for it. The strategy is there. And everybody knows that the troop number is around 40,000. So there is not reason for further delay."

Amid the debate over troop levels, the New York Times reported Wednesday that Ahmed Wali Karzai, the brother of Afghan President Hamid Karzai, has been on CIA payroll for much of the past eight years, despite his alleged involvement in the illegal opium trade.

McCain said plainly that was wrong.

"Well, I'd heard that rumor before. I think it's wrong. It's wrong of the CIA to do it and I'm sure our military commanders there would disagree with it."

Meanwhile, attacks continued in neighboring Pakistan as Secretary of State Hillary Clinton arrived for a three-day trip aimed at showing U.S. support for that country's ongoing battle against militants.

A car bomb in the restive northwest region of the country, killing 80 people.

McCain said he felt the Pakistani government was doing "much better" in its campaign against extremists, but cautioned it was a "long, difficult process" – one the U.S. can't afford to let it lose.

"I would remind you again that Pakistan is a nuclear-armed country. And with a nuclear arsenal, we certainly can't afford to see the collapse of Pakistan either."

Add a Comment See all 17 Comments
by amacd385 October 29, 2009 12:02 PM EDT
For god's ake, McCain, have you no memory --- have you no shame?

This unusual and unexpected 'anti-war' Op-Ed allowed by the NYT may be the 'Walter Cronkite moment' for the Afghanistan War.

Much thanks to the NYT for publishing this compelling lesson of Soviet EMPIRE history today:

Op-Ed Contributor
"Transcripts of Defeat"

By VICTOR SEBESTYEN
Published: October 28, 2009

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/29/opinion/29sebestyen.html?ref=opinion

Such advice and sanity today is better than waiting for the NYT to have to print the "Pentagon Papers 2.0" later --- disclosing that our deceitful ruling-elite corporate/financial EMPIRE knew the truth about the Afghanistan War's trajectory all along.

Alan MacDonald
Sanford, Maine

PS. "Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it." George Santayana
Reply to this comment
by srr60 October 28, 2009 8:13 PM EDT
We have not won a war when the politicans were running it. Korea and Viet Nam. If Obama does not listen to his Generals and support there needs we will lose this war and the terrorest will be back on the home land (USA)doing there thing, killing Americans.
Reply to this comment
by longtree-2009 October 28, 2009 7:03 PM EDT
we should all listen to mccain. after all wasn't he a 4 star general or a full admiral during the vietnam war? mccain knows how to win a war after all he developed all the strategy for vietnam. wait one. wasn't mccain in a pow camp for most of the vietnam war? yeah, the nation should listen to mccain NOT. mccain was the dufus who selected palin as his running mate, his maverick decision, that gave obama the presidency on a silver platter. sure, lets all listen to the old loser.
Reply to this comment
by JusticeInAmerica October 28, 2009 3:52 PM EDT
Matthew Hoh and I know a heck of a lot more about Afghanistan than John McCain ever will! We've been there, done that, and know the real deal. McCain still doesn't know what he's talking about. Thank goodness he lost the Presidential election.
Reply to this comment
by isanyonefair October 28, 2009 1:55 PM EDT
McCain ... "I know how to ..."
- "... get bin Laden"
- "... handle the Iranians"
- "... reach across the aisle"

Ummm .... yeah. Too bad he can't work with anyone to get anything done.

McCain ... do you know how to Shut Up? Or maybe Think?

The correct course of action in Afghanistan is to WAIT. If the govt there doesn't get its act together. Then LEAVE. If it does, the military needs to leave the country in a strong enough state that we can leave.

Fighting terrorism needs the FBI & CIA to be accountable. Not the Army and Marines to be put in harms way so every day we can discuss if our strategy is correct when another soldier dies.

At the end of the day, if the Afghan population is not determined enough to fight the Taliban themselves, it won't matter how secure we leave it. The taliban will surely resurge.

McCain, you should really try being a Maverick. Hey, maybe you could vote FOR Health Care Reform.
Reply to this comment
by vietnamwar October 28, 2009 1:04 PM EDT
Learn from history.
when Japan invade China , Vietnam, Korea, they have kill a millions of people from each country, forcing women into sex slave and starved million people to death, when we drop two BOMB to end the war no more people die after that....

Let have a multiple choices:
1.to win the war, drop a few MOAB bomb non_nuclear weapon, yes innocent will die but conceder a small percentage.
2. continue to what we do and bring our troops home in the body bags..
Reply to this comment
by dnamj October 28, 2009 12:16 PM EDT
Ummm, we are in the middle of a war there. NOW it's time to act? Afghanistan is a quagmire. Just ask the Soviet Union. Oh wait, there IS no Soviet Union. They went BANKRUPT doing what we're doing. Not Learning, repeating others' mistakes. We are too stupid to survive.
Reply to this comment
by bc-1948 October 28, 2009 10:34 AM EDT
Let's see - there are now 100,000 Nato and American Troops in Afghanistan, 200,000 Afghan security troops - against an estimated 25,000 Taliban. Wow - 12:1 - so 40K more American Troops are going to make a difference? It didn't work for Russia, it isn't going to work for us. We need to do the same as in Iraq - pay the local tribal leaders to keep peace and get the h... out. It's not up to us to run their country - the people have to want it - We put Karzi in as a puppet of the US and the Afghan know it. All they want is peace - I understand the hard Muslim doctrine of the Taliban, but it isn't up to us to change that - just a harsh reality.
Reply to this comment
by babooph October 28, 2009 9:56 AM EDT
After 8 years of stumbling around we nust now go act in a panic?I wish I could get back the $$ taxed into the congress & pentagaon.....
Reply to this comment
by briannorwood October 28, 2009 9:27 AM EDT
Would someone tell this Jackass that he LOST the election. He is not the Commander in Chief. And by the way, after 8 years of failed strategy under the Bush Administration, he was deafly silent.

Let President Obama do his job without bitter sideliners throwing jabs.
Reply to this comment
by doctajim October 28, 2009 12:35 PM EDT
Might also tell him to read the history of the Soviet incursion as well as Alex the Greats attempts in that region. More troops, more force wasn't the answer then - might be time to consider Hoh's concerns before recreating another VN. VN - remember that John? We lied, we didn't know the enemy nor Giap, we shouldn't have been there - and we lost! Wisdom is measured by the ability to learn from past situations (not live in the past) and make more cogent and appropriate decisions on those situations (John Vann & Elsberg - remember?). Go back to counseling John, you're not in 2009.
See all 17 Comments
.

Follow Political Hotsheet

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook