Stimulus Bill Sparks Partisan Parsing
The Senate will start deliberations on the Economic Recovery and Reinvestment Plan at 2pm ET this afternoon, but do not expect a vote anytime soon. All weekend, senators and administration officials had plenty to say about the bill's future, but no one seemed to agree on their predictions.
Which raises the question: Is this weekend's war of words a harbinger for a long, partisan Senate debate?
In an interview Sunday, President Obama said, "I am confident that by the time we have the final package on the floor that we are going to see substantial support, and people are going to see this is a serious effort. It has no earmarks. We are going to be trimming out things that are not relevant to putting people back to work right now."
Of note is the fact that the administration has almost completely stopped offering number estimates on what Republican support they can count on. Gone from their nomenclature is the confident estimation that the bill will pass with the support of eighty senators.
Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) seemed confident on 'Face the Nation' Sunday that the stimulus bill will be met with Republican support this week. "Republicans won't have the luxury they did in the House of voting no and still letting it pass," he said.
"This will pass with Republican votes because it is a good package and we will make some changes around the edges," Schumer said. He added that he "would rather have a really good bill that helps our economy get out of this mess with sixty five votes than dilute the bill and get eighty votes."
On NBC's 'Meet the Press,' Senator John Kerry (D-MA), a member of the finance committee, said the "bipartisan effort here" is "unprecedented." He cited examples of Republican input in the bill, lauding "Republican Representative Eric Cantor's suggestion that the entire bill be put on the Internet."
"Everybody can go look at every provision in it," Kerry continued. "We've accepted Republican proposals. Arlen Specter's going to put in $12 billion for NIH. One of the largest increases in the bill is the Alternative Minimum Tax fix. That came with the advocacy of Chuck Grassley, Republican Finance ranking member."
Ranking Republican in the Senate Banking Committee Richard Shelby seems to disagree. He told Bob Schieffer on CBSNews.com's 'Washington Unplugged' Friday that he hopes "Republicans can stay together."
He said he has not done a vote count but "we could keep talking about it. If the Republicans band together, there are forty one of us this bill won't pass."
Shelby dampened expectations, however, saying he is "doubtful" there will be full Republican unity. "I think there will be some Republicans that will jump on the bandwagon and jump ship," said Shelby, adding, "but I think it's a bad piece of legislation."
What would it take to get Republicans on board? "A one hundred and eighty degree turn," Shelby said.
Another Republican, Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison, also knocked the bill.
"Oh, I would fight this bill as it is, absolutely, because I think it is the wrong emphasis," the banking committee member said Sunday. "When we talk about bipartisanship, it means that some of the ideas that would be incorporated would be the Republican ideas. Just talking a good game and then not having any real input or change is not going to make a difference."
Senator John McCain, meanwhile, said he "appreciates" the president's outreach to Republicans but "we're a long way away" from agreement on the stimulus package.
"There's too much spending, too much unnecessary spending, not the right kind of tax cuts and no end game," McCain said. "There's a lot of other proposals we have. We think we need to eliminate a lot of the wasteful pork barrel spending that's been put in and have a real, meaningful stimulus package. We realize they need the package. We need the package, America needs the package, but we're not there yet."
Adding his hat to the ranks of Republicans speaking out against the stimulus bill, Senator Mitch McConnell told Bob Schieffer Sunday he "doubt[s]" the economic stimulus package passed by the House has a chance of passing as is in the Senate.
"I think we need to exercise some discipline here and I think it may be time for the President to get a hold of these Democrats in the Senate and House who have rather significant majorities and shake them a little bit and say look, let's do this the right way," McConnell added.
Asked by Schieffer if Republicans plan to filibuster the vote, the senator said that a "super majority" is certainly needed for passage but that Senate Republicans will not purposely hold up the process.
The stimulus package -- known formally as the Economic Recovery and Reinvestment Package -- was passed by the House of Representatives last Wednesday, but not a single Republican voted for its passage. How it will be received in the Senate will be revealed this week as the bill hits the floor. Based on this weekend's conflicting predictions, it could be a contentious week.
© 2009 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Which raises the question: Is this weekend's war of words a harbinger for a long, partisan Senate debate?
(AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)
Of note is the fact that the administration has almost completely stopped offering number estimates on what Republican support they can count on. Gone from their nomenclature is the confident estimation that the bill will pass with the support of eighty senators.
Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) seemed confident on 'Face the Nation' Sunday that the stimulus bill will be met with Republican support this week. "Republicans won't have the luxury they did in the House of voting no and still letting it pass," he said.
"This will pass with Republican votes because it is a good package and we will make some changes around the edges," Schumer said. He added that he "would rather have a really good bill that helps our economy get out of this mess with sixty five votes than dilute the bill and get eighty votes."
On NBC's 'Meet the Press,' Senator John Kerry (D-MA), a member of the finance committee, said the "bipartisan effort here" is "unprecedented." He cited examples of Republican input in the bill, lauding "Republican Representative Eric Cantor's suggestion that the entire bill be put on the Internet."
"Everybody can go look at every provision in it," Kerry continued. "We've accepted Republican proposals. Arlen Specter's going to put in $12 billion for NIH. One of the largest increases in the bill is the Alternative Minimum Tax fix. That came with the advocacy of Chuck Grassley, Republican Finance ranking member."
Ranking Republican in the Senate Banking Committee Richard Shelby seems to disagree. He told Bob Schieffer on CBSNews.com's 'Washington Unplugged' Friday that he hopes "Republicans can stay together."
He said he has not done a vote count but "we could keep talking about it. If the Republicans band together, there are forty one of us this bill won't pass."
Shelby dampened expectations, however, saying he is "doubtful" there will be full Republican unity. "I think there will be some Republicans that will jump on the bandwagon and jump ship," said Shelby, adding, "but I think it's a bad piece of legislation."
What would it take to get Republicans on board? "A one hundred and eighty degree turn," Shelby said.
Another Republican, Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison, also knocked the bill.
"Oh, I would fight this bill as it is, absolutely, because I think it is the wrong emphasis," the banking committee member said Sunday. "When we talk about bipartisanship, it means that some of the ideas that would be incorporated would be the Republican ideas. Just talking a good game and then not having any real input or change is not going to make a difference."
(CBS)
"There's too much spending, too much unnecessary spending, not the right kind of tax cuts and no end game," McCain said. "There's a lot of other proposals we have. We think we need to eliminate a lot of the wasteful pork barrel spending that's been put in and have a real, meaningful stimulus package. We realize they need the package. We need the package, America needs the package, but we're not there yet."
Adding his hat to the ranks of Republicans speaking out against the stimulus bill, Senator Mitch McConnell told Bob Schieffer Sunday he "doubt[s]" the economic stimulus package passed by the House has a chance of passing as is in the Senate.
"I think we need to exercise some discipline here and I think it may be time for the President to get a hold of these Democrats in the Senate and House who have rather significant majorities and shake them a little bit and say look, let's do this the right way," McConnell added.
Asked by Schieffer if Republicans plan to filibuster the vote, the senator said that a "super majority" is certainly needed for passage but that Senate Republicans will not purposely hold up the process.
The stimulus package -- known formally as the Economic Recovery and Reinvestment Package -- was passed by the House of Representatives last Wednesday, but not a single Republican voted for its passage. How it will be received in the Senate will be revealed this week as the bill hits the floor. Based on this weekend's conflicting predictions, it could be a contentious week.
Popular in Politics
- Obama prom pictures surface 107 Comments
- IRS official Lois Lerner placed on leave 98 Comments
- Is President Obama ending the war on terror?
- Rep. Jo Bonner to resign from House for university job
- Protester heckles Obama during counterterrorism speech Play Video
- Obama: America at a "crossroads" in fighting terrorism 106 Comments
- Now, some unions upset over Obamacare
- Obama to tour Jersey Shore with Gov. Christie
I love how these 2 new appointees by Obama have not paid their taxes or "forgot to Pay 120,000 in taxes" ....this is really going well
If you buy that line, then hey guys I have a bridge I want to sell ya!!
Wether or not you agree with the polotics and ideas of anyone other than yourself, you have to have people keeping people in check. Get over yourself already!!!
any stimulas would simply fall flat and just add inflation.
1. Fix the exchange-rates to stabilize world currencies.
2. Put the banks that make-up the Federal Reserve System through bankruptcy re-organization
3. Set up a new National Bank of the United States that only issues credit and currency ''uttered'' by Congress with a 2 tier Sovereign National Credit System.
4. Ignore Wall Street Republicans who profess to be Christians but practice idolatry, breaking the 2nd Commandment, by worshiping ''free markets''.
I believe I can speak for every unemployed person in the country when I ask you to please include the suspension of Federal Income Tax on unemployment benefits for 2008 and 2009 to your stimulus plan. We promise not to spend the money in foreign lands on expensive vacations,or for extravegant remodeling of our homes which in many cases we are in danger of no longer owning. Thank you, and all our best hopes to you and your administration.
I believe I can speak for every unemployed person in the country when I ask you to please include the suspension of Federal Income Tax on unemployment benefits for 2008 and 2009 to your stimulus plan. We promise not to spend the money in foreign lands on expensive vacations,or for extravegant remodeling of our homes which in many cases we are in danger of no longer owning. Thank you, and all our best hopes to you and your administration.