October 20, 2011 5:06 PM

White House stands by Biden on murder, rape rates

By
Lucy Madison
Topics
White House

Vice President Joe Biden speaks during a news conference urging the passage of the Teachers and First Responders Back to Work Act, Wednesday, Oct. 19, 2011, on Capitol Hill in Washington.

(Credit: AP Photo/Haraz N. Ghanbari)
White House Press Secretary Jay Carney defended Vice President Joe Biden on Thursday after Biden suggested that rape and murder incidences in the U.S. would increase without passage of an Obama administration-backed $35 billion jobs measure. Carney told reporters that the president "absolutely" shares Biden's belief that an increase in law enforcement "would have a positive impact on crime."

Biden incited the ire of Republicans on Wednesday when he doubled down on the suggestion that the country would see an increase in rapes and murders if the jobs bill, which would provide funds for state and local governments to hire teachers, fire fighters and police officers, is not passed.

"Police departments, as I said, in some cases literally cut in half like Camden, New Jersey and Flint, Michigan," Biden said in Washington, referencing remarks he made in Michigan last week. "In many cities the result has been, and it's not unique, murder rates are up. Robberies are up. Rapes are up."

Asked if the president agreed with Biden's comments, Carney said yes.

"I think it would be hard to find anyone who doesn't agree with the simple equation that fewer police officers on the street has a direct effect on the crime rate," he told reporters.

Biden, in a conversation with a conservative journalist following his initial remarks, pointed to rising crime rates in Michigan to back his claim.

"I said rape was up three times in Flint. Those are the numbers. Go look at the numbers. Murder is up, rape is up, burglary is up. That's what I said," said Biden.

Carney said the president "absolutely does share" Biden's belief that an increase in the number of law enforcement officials on the street will lead to a decrease in crime.

"We saw this in the '90s...I don't know that anybody, any lawmaker up on Capitol Hill, will contest that simple fact," he said. ...Having more law enforcement officers on the job, police officers on the job, would have a positive impact on crime. That's the point he was making. And that's a point that the president absolutely does share."

When asked how Mr. Obama would respond Republicans contending "they're being told their opposition means more people will be raped; more people will be murdered," Carney wondered if the GOP was trying to argue that there was no correlation between the number of employed police officers and crime rates.

"You know, you can focus on the words or you can focus on the simple fact," Carney said. "The president put in the American Jobs Act a provision that would provide assistance to states to put teachers back to work and to put firefighters and police officers back to work, first responders."

"I mean, are they arguing -- are Republicans arguing that there is no correlation between the number of cops on the beat and the crime rate?" Carney asked. "That would be an interesting argument to hear. It's a new one, a novel one, but I'd like to hear it."

He continued: "Yes, we are saying that more police officers on the beat is a good thing and will help keep crime rates lower. More firefighters fighting fires will reduce the impact that fires will have in our communities and will save lives. That's a fact."

The $35 billion jobs bill is one measure from the president's $447 billion American Jobs Act, which could not get through Congress earlier this month. Mr. Obama has since vowed to push each component of the bill through Congress piecemeal, and has dared Republican lawmakers to look voters "in the eye" and tell them "what exactly they are opposed to" in a bill aimed at putting teachers, police officers, and firefighters back to work.

"I think they'd have a hard time explaining why they voted no on this bill other than the fact that I proposed it," Mr. Obama said in an October 11 speech. "Folks should ask their senators, 'Why would you consider voting against putting teachers... back to work?'"

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has said he will hold a vote on the $35 billion bill by the end of this week, but it is not expected to get the 60 votes necessary to move forward in the Senate.


Add a Comment
by vielmann October 21, 2011 6:56 PM EDT
It's no surprise to me that the GOP sees rape and murder as mere problems for the poor to handle and not their particular concern.
Reply to this comment
by obwan222 October 21, 2011 2:31 PM EDT
So I assume that those of you who disagree with the VP think that less cops means a safer city?

FactCheck.org said Biden is "right on his larger point," that murders increased in Flint as police staffing dropped.

Even FauxNews had to admit,"The number of officers in Flint has declined from 201 in 2008 to 132 in 2010, according to FBI stats, while the number of murders has just about doubled in that time."

You can call names and whine all you want, but let's see your FACTS that crime doesn't go up when the police presence goes down.
Reply to this comment
by dantom39 October 21, 2011 9:12 AM EDT
Poor old Joe to many hair plugs destroyed what few brain cells left.
Reply to this comment
by vielmann October 21, 2011 6:57 PM EDT
Hair plugs? Is that what happened to you, dainty boy?
by obwan222 October 21, 2011 4:17 AM EDT
"There will not be fewer cops id [SIC] the states do their jobs. It is not a fed issue is it? Or least it is not suppose to be."

Theoretically you are correct. It is the job of the states and localities to hire police. But the reality is that state and local governments are cutting back. They are not hiring the number of officers that are required to police their communities. Check it out in your area and you will probably find that your police dept. is under-staffed.

"Obama is just an idiot and Biden is the private clown who has never been right about anything in his life."

So I guess you think they are wrong when they say that -

"I think it would be hard to find anyone who doesn't agree with the simple equation that fewer police officers on the street has a direct effect on the crime rate..."

Because if you agree with that simple statement of fact then you have to admit that he is right - and you are just a hateful blowhard that can't bring yourself to agree with the President and VP even when they are right.
Reply to this comment
by Ole76er October 20, 2011 5:49 PM EDT
If more folks would get their concealed weapons license and the training to use a handgun, there would be less crime even with the reduction in the number of police officers.

FBI statistics show crime is down across the U.S. Is this more Democratic propaganda to sell their half billion dollar stimulus package America cannot afford? C'mon Biden, check facts before opening mouth.
Reply to this comment
by LisaMW621 October 21, 2011 12:15 PM EDT
Yes, that's a MUCH easier solution than hiring more law enforcement. Do you really want guns in the hands of more idiots than they are already in? I'm picturing some of the people in my community carrying concealed and I have to tell you, that picture does NOT make me feel any safer.
by lh2010 October 20, 2011 5:29 PM EDT
Is this the same White House that got a US Border Patrol Agent KILLED in the Fast and Furious Gun scheme in an effort to take away our 2nd amendment rights???? Now they are worried about crime. Fancy that! Oh and rape and murder rates are down in many of the major cities even with the reduction in police. The WH may want to look those numbers up!
Reply to this comment
by ThatCentristGuy October 20, 2011 6:11 PM EDT
Indirectly killing american citizens by giving guns to evil drug lords so that they might shoot people up, thus convincing the public to support gun control sounds like a tiny bit of a stretch.

Still, I agree with you on the 2nd amendment rights. Repealing it is very much a slippery slope. Ever heard of "Metal Gear Solid 4?" It's a video-game that shows what gun control might end up to be. It's even worse then having your guns taken away.

Here's what I mean. http://youtu.be/C0I7bMYtgpI
.

Follow Political Hotsheet

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook