Political Hotsheet
By

Brian Montopoli /

CBS News/ October 4, 2011, 6:30 PM

Herman Cain rises, Rick Perry slides in new CBS News poll

Romney, Cain, Perry CBS/Getty

CBS News Poll analysis by the CBS News Polling Unit: Sarah Dutton, Jennifer De Pinto, Fred Backus and Anthony Salvanto.

Herman Cain has moved into a tie with Mitt Romney atop the field of Republican presidential candidates, according to a new CBS News poll, while Rick Perry has fallen 11 percentage points in just two weeks.

CBS
The poll shows Cain, who stood at just five percent support two weeks ago, now holding 17 percent support among Republican primary voters. That puts the former Godfather's Pizza CEO into a tie with Romney, the former Massachusetts governor, whose support has essentially held steady over the past two weeks.

Perry, meanwhile, has dropped from 23 percent support to just 12 percent support over the past two weeks, a sign that the Texas governor's shaky debate performances - in which he has alienated portions of both the Republican base and the party establishment - have taken their toll.

Eight in ten Republican primary voters said the candidates' debate performances are at least somewhat important to them, and 58 percent said they have watched the debates that have already taken place. Just ten percent of Republican primary voters said they agreed with Perry that the children of illegal immigrants should be allowed to get in-state tuition, a contentious topic in recent debates.

The silver lining for Perry is the race remains fluid: Three in four Republican primary voters who chose a candidate also said it was too early to make up their minds completely. Just 19 percent said they had definitively decided who they would support.

Rounding out the field are Newt Gingrich with eight percent support, Ron Paul with seven percent, Michele Bachmann with four percent, Rick Santorum with three percent and Jon Huntsman with two percent. Eighteen percent said they were undecided or unsure.

At left, CBS News' Brian Montopoli discusses the new poll and the state of the Republican presidential race.

Cain's rise follows a flurry of positive media coverage for his upset victory over Perry in the Florida straw poll last month. The only African-American candidate in the GOP field, Cain has also been getting traction with GOP voters and conservative columnists with his 9-9-9 tax plan - a proposal to replace the current tax code with a nine percent flat income tax, a nine percent corporate tax and a nine percent national sales tax.

The CBS News poll shows Cain as the top choice among self-described conservatives, with 21 percent support. (Two weeks ago, he polled at just six percent with this group.) Romney polls in second among conservatives with 15 percent support, followed by Perry at 13 percent. Cain is also the top choice of Republican primary voters who support the Tea Party, polling at 24 percent to Romney's 17 percent, Gingrich's 13 percent and Perry's 12 percent.

Yet Cain's strong showing comes as he embarks on a book tour that will keep him busy for much of October - a scheduling decision that has some wondering how serious he is about his presidential campaign. Cain is not scheduled to return to the first-in-the-nation state of Iowa until the middle of November, and he has seen significant staff shakeup, most recently losing his respected communications director - a sign that his staff may not see him as mounting a serious challenge for the nomination.

The poll suggests that Romney may gain traction with the argument that he has the best chance to unseat President Obama next year: 32 percent of Republicans say Romney is the candidate most likely to defeat the president. Twenty-one percent cited Perry, while just eight percent chose Cain.

Romney also led the field on who exhibits the strongest leadership qualities, with 26 percent pointing to the former Massachusetts governor. Perry came in second with 23 percent, followed by Gingrich with 14 percent and Cain with nine percent.

Asked who most cares about people, Romney and Cain topped the field, with both cited by 16 percent of Republican primary voters. Four candidates - Romney, Cain, Bachmann and Perry - finished close to each other atop the list of which candidate most shares voters' values.

The poll is being released in the wake of New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie's announcement that he would not enter the race despite pressure from Republicans unhappy with the GOP field (the poll was conducted before his announcement). With the filing deadline for many GOP primaries coming at the end of October and primary voting expected to begin in early January, time is running out for new candidates to enter the race. 

In the poll, Republican primary voters were asked if they were satisfied with the current field. Forty-six percent said yes - and just as many said they want new choices.

It's not clear who that new choice might be. There is not a groundswell for the most prominent Republican still openly considering a run, 2008 vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin, to jump in: Three in four Republican primary voters said they would not like to see her enter the race. Just 23 percent said they wanted to see a Palin candidacy.

More from the poll:

Most support gays serving openly in military
Read the complete poll (PDF)


This poll was conducted by telephone from September 28-October 2, 2011 among 1,012 adults nationwide. Phone numbers were dialed from samples of both standard land-line and cell phones. The error due to sampling for results based on the entire sample could be plus or minus three percentage points. The error for subgroups is higher. This poll release conforms to the Standards of Disclosure of the National Council on Public Polls.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
366 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cadmus557 says:
michaellovesnyc i wouldn't move to a "beckistan" or uganda and plot to murder my family or those bat poop g-o-p-er's. I know we don't employ dumby's in Intelligence, we just elect thier bosses.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
garettk1 says:
You mainline republican voters are as stupid as the Obama folks. Is there a con you won't buy?Herman Cain is super insider. Mr Federal Reserve. "Oh, just CALL the Fed and ASK them what they're up to." Yeah, just try going up there. You'll be met with armed goons and "Private Property" signs. Which of course is correct as it is a for-profit private enterprise.Wake up fools! Quit being a schmuck! This New World Order puppet wants to install his 999 plan that includes a VAT tax? Gimme a break. 999 today is 18-18-18 tomorrow.to-intimidate-me-will-not-succeed/#comment#ixzz1aVnvkV3G
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
elmgreen11 says:
Nein nein nein mein herr....
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
shrinkgov says:
Do you really trust CBS or any other polling organization?
I sure don't. "Prediction markets" where people put their money where thier mouth tell an unbiased story...

http://www.2012presidentialprospects.com/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
leetrav says:
Vote for a unicorn-eating carnivore...Vote for Herman Cain!
reply
doneinone replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
yep I think I will.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
leetrav says:
I'm always amazed at the hateful comments from liberal pc dems or dims. They just don't make sense. Since Herman Cain is all about common sense...they just don't get it. No surprise there. There is the real universe/world (the one reasonable free-thinking people live in)...and the parallel universe/world...the later being populated by Dims or Dems...whatever. They love magic, rose-colored glasses and the amazing, legendary, unicorns. Cain and I do too...they taste like a cross between lean veal and domestic cat....delicious
reply
doneinone replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Ridicule! lol........He is already enduring that. Something that the media did not do to the annoited one. Could you imagine a hostile interview like the Lawrence Odonnell ever taking place with Obama? Never!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
Cain is the extremist wacko Republicon flavor of the month. The question to ask a GOP supporter is how many clowns does it take to run a Republicon pResidential campaign?
reply
mariannpepit replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I agree with your comment. Cain is a very critical candidate and Florida and Iowa haven't woke up to that fact yet. He critized Obama, Mitt, Perry and then Christie. He doesn't have the makings of a president and if he wins the nomination Obama will win the presidency again.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
shoemael says:
How strange. From the poll:

q20 Which one of these candidates would you like to see the Republican Party nominate forPresident in 2012 - Michele Bachmann, Herman Cain, Newt Gingrich, Jon Huntsman, Ron Paul,Rick Perry, Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, or would you like to see someone else nominated?IF SOMEONE ELSE, ASK: Who would you like to see nominated?

SOMEONE ELSE got 10 as opposed to 17 for Romney and Cain. They don't seem to want you to know who SOMEONE ELSE is.

Notice Gary Johnson wasn't listed in the named options. This kind of stuff has got to stop.

Gary Johnson 2012!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jsclmedave says:
Just spent 3.5 hours in Rick Perry's DMV for a drivers license. When I left the line was out the door and into the parking lot. I was told I was lucky that it was only 3.5 hours. This is Rick Perry's idea of a state run agency? You just lost my vote Mr Perry!
reply
mariannpepit replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Perry did not lose my vote. If you had to wait that long it had to be extremely crowded. Don't blame Perry for how the state runs their drivers license facility. Blame the one who is in charge and they probably need to hire more people.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
elmgreen11 says:
999 is 666 upside down.
reply
reallyfuntoo replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
and Cain's opposite is Obama.
doneinone replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
yeah like good vs. evil.......I get it. Time for the Joker to leave the White House.
See all 366 Comments