Political Hotsheet
By

Corbett B. Daly /

CBS News/ September 22, 2011, 9:40 PM

Romney wants everyone in America to be rich

Michele Bachmann and Mitt Romney Fox News
Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney wants everyone in the United States to be rich, but he declined to say what he considers "rich."

"I don't try and define who is rich and who is not rich," Romney said when asked what level of income he considers rich at Thursday's Republican debate in Orlando, Fla.

"I want everybody in America to be rich," the former governor of Massachusetts told debate moderator Bret Baier of Fox News, "I want people in this country to have opportunity. I want everybody to have the kind of opportunities that we on this stage have had."

Asked what the tax rate should be for average Americans, Michele Bachmann said Americans should not have to pay income taxes.

"That's your money. That's not the government's money," Bachmann said in response to what Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly said was the most popular question in last week's Republican debate: "out of every dollar I earn, how much do you think that I deserve to keep?"

"I think you earned every dollar, you should get to keep every dollar that you earn," Bachmann said.

The former tax attorney then hedged and said the government would need to collect some revenues but she did not specify a desired rate.

"Obviously we have to give money back to the government so that we can run the government but we have to have a completely different mindset and that mindset is the American people are the genius of this economy, it certainly isn't government that is the genius," Bachmann said.

GOP debate: Winners and losers

Rick Perry, Mitt Romney tell each other: Read my book!

Perry calls fellow GOP candidates heartless

Perry on HPV: "I erred on the side of life"

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
42 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Lindag10 says:
Bachmann is hilarious. "No one should pay income taxes".... The government will just run itself on hot air or something according to her. And Romney must think that if you're breathing, you're rich. Ah for the "good old days" when the Republicans could at least field a candidate that had some intelligence.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tsigili says:
That's simply a pandering comment. That will not happen, and we all know it.

It is interesting to me, that no one, not Romney, nor the media, have ever said what business/s Romney is actually in. I find that rather curious......you know? I see Romney, as a Democrat wearing a GOP label, myself.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
If his childish fantasy would come true, all life on earth would be extinct due to man made global climate change. In fact, that may happen anyway.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
stupa5 says:
"I want people in this country to have opportunity. I want everybody to have the kind of opportunities that we on this stage have had."

Like:
1. Gingrih Adulterer & Liar
2. Bachmann & her Husband god squaders toget the mind
of "Homosexuals" to have correct thinking
3. Perry the Gov..."Hang em High"

ya right right Mitch whatever you say!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
stupa5 says:
Define Rich!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
imppress says:
Cool! If everyone's rich: Demand for goods will skyrocket!
As producers notice that demand is high, they'll ramp up prices until the supply can keep up with demand and production can keep up.
As prices go up, items will become less affordable and folks won't buy as much.
Some people will either ratchet back spending and retain their remaining wealth or spend themselves back into a middle class status, into poverty, or into debt.

So... we're back with the status quo, but prices are higher.

Did Mitt Romney basically just endorsed hyperinflation? Everybody rich at the same time would have that result. Someone please tell me how I'm wrong and Romney isn't just waving magic wands and spinning fantasies. I don't think he believes any of it. He's just pandering to idiots that think it's POSSIBLE for everyone to be rich. These same people buy lottery tickets.

If everyone is "rich", we essentially have all the same wealth despite our abilities, work ethics, and luck. If a Democrat said this he'd be called a "Socialist". (and with some justification.)
reply
Maddsci33 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
That is one of the most ignorant arguments I've ever heard. Romney wants everyone to have the same opportunity to become rich as everyone on stage. Obviously not everyone will be rich because the huge majority of people are too lazy to do the work required to be self made, but those who do are rewarded. The progressives want to take that away from people - they tell you "you'll never be rich, you have to take money form those who have more". That is just welfare - and hey, if your greatest aspiration is to be a welfare case then good for you, but you're going to be poor forever and it won't be MY fault! The rest of us get up everyday and work to better ourselves. Don't try and take it away just because you're too lazy to do the same.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RobAla says:
Wishing for everyone in America to be rich is much better than President Obama'a attack on the rich and pushing for everyone to share the same amount of poverty.

President Obama is all about his administration having more money, not Americans being more prosperous or having jobs. All he can talk about is how we must send more of our money to Washington. Enough of that crap! Greedy insatiable Washington is the most inefficient and biggest waster of money of any entity on earth.

Not one more dime should go to Washington in higher taxes or fees until it goes on a diet and becomes efficient and practical in how it spends the public's money. We can not afford the size and scope of this horribly corrupt and bloated government. It must be reduced to a manageable size and scope - to a level that the American citizens and businesses can afford.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Fatesrider says:
Rich is NEVER having to think about whether you can afford to keep food on the table, clothes on your back and a roof over your head.
reply
silvereagle2718 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
security from crime, good health and good kids might be nice too. so where does obamacare fit into this? and where does america fit into the rest of the world? they want it too.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
oldman67 says:
Not to worry! The Constitution Ron Paul believes in doesn't exist any longer. Remember what both Bush and Obama said about our Constitution. 70 congressmen voted to do away with it eariler this year.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Transatlantique says:
If everyone were rich, who would clean the sewers? "Rich" would be indefinable. This man is living in a fantasy world or is simply telling people what they want to hear.
reply
See all 42 Comments