Political Hotsheet
By

Brian Montopoli /

CBS News/ June 14, 2011, 2:27 PM

GOP debate: The winners and losers

On the latest episode of "The Drive," which you can watch above, I break down the winners and losers in Monday night's Republican presidential debate - which included one contender who wasn't actually in the building.

The big winners of the night were Michele Bachmann and Mitt Romney. Bachmann announced her campaign at the debate, garnering early headlines, and she spoke in clear, compelling sound bites - so much so that her occasional stumbles are unlikely to be remembered. With her performance, Bachmann positioned herself as a plausible Tea Party standard bearer, as well as a viable alternative to potential candidate Sarah Palin.  

Michele Bachmann wows in first debate

As the closest thing to a frontrunner in the field, meanwhile, Romney had been expected to take hits at the debate. But his rivals held their fire, allowing the former Massachusetts governor to sail through the debate without any real damage. Romney was so relaxed and comfortable that he even managed an update on the Boston Bruins' lead in the Stanley Cup finals - winning a roar of approval from the New Hampshire audience.

Debate analysis: The Mitt Romney Show

The biggest loser of the night was former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, who had been expected to attack Romney on his health care plan. On Sunday, Pawlenty coined the term "Obamneycare" to draw a link between the Massachusetts law signed by Romney and the federal health care law so disdained by Republicans. He awkwardly retreated from that made-up word, however, instead opting to play nice and largely fade into the woodwork with the other candidates. It was an odd choice for a candidate seeking to present himself as the alternative to Romney - and one who had gone on the offensive just one day before.

These debates are little-watched by the general public but are important events for the donors, reporters and GOP officials who can make or break a contender. Pawlenty's timid performance is already raising questions among this group about Pawlenty's ability to face off with the frontrunner. 

Will backing off "Obamneycare" in GOP debate hurt Pawlenty's campaign?

Another loser: Herman Cain. The former Godfather's Pizza CEO had been the breakout star of the first debate, but his underwhelming debate performance will harden the emerging conventional wisdom that he is a compelling figure but not quite ready for prime time.

Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich, meanwhile, did nothing to improve their status as serious long shots for the nomination; Santorum didn't produce any YouTube moments to galvanize the social conservatives he has been courting, while Gingrich's regular scowling isn't going to help win over the donors scared off by his disastrous campaign rollout and staff mutiny.

Ron Paul, meanwhile, was the Ron Paul we've come to expect: Charming, clear-eyed and perfectly willing to break with GOP orthodoxy. But unless the GOP electorate shifts dramatically toward his brand of libertarianism, Paul will remain little threat to Romney and whoever emerges as his top rivals.

Check out the full episode of "The Drive" above.

The top five takeaways from the GOP debate

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
106 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
The Tea Bag KKKlan is a front group for the billionaires to fight their Class War against the American people. We need to spread the word that the General Strikes will start on October 6th, 2011.

Be prepared to support those who go out on strike. Hopefully we can get enough unions involved to shut down commerce like the ports and airports. We the People just HAVE to win this Class War before the next depression hits and we are left with nothing.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Lindag10 says:
by TeaPartyChris June 15, 2011 3:56 PM EDT
Only Ron Paul has the guns to stand up to the negro lobby and the Israel lobby and the jew controlled Federal Reserve. Of course mainstream jew controlled media will try and destroy him.


----------------

Tea Party despite claims of not being bigoted and racist, you just about covered everybody except the native Americans with slurs. Get over it.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
pr_boxer says:
They're all losers!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RET-ABNRGR-CSM says:
Hey "fraudmarinever", "usa" "disloyal" get ahold of your cbs gang leader "slow the paid cbs toll ho with silver birds" and you guys might win a chance to eat with your Messiah!

(CNSNews.com) - In return for a $5 donation to his reelection campaign, President Barack Obama is offering supporters a chance to participate in a raffle to win a "casual" dinner with him at an unstated location.

In an e-mail to supporters, the president says his campaign will raffle off four tickets for the casual dinner.

HAR!

Hey "disloyal" when does your War start so I can get the word out?

HAR!
reply
pr_boxer replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Paul is senile, haven't you noticed!
RET-ABNRGR-CSM replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Obama is an idiot, haven't you noticed?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
1pheasant1 says:
by TeaPartyChris June 15, 2011 3:56 PM EDT

Only Ron Paul has the guns to stand up to the negro lobby and the Israel lobby and the jew controlled Federal Reserve. Of course mainstream jew controlled media will try and destroy him.

***********************

Is that what Ron Paul says? I suspect that TeaSipperChris would like his racism to be Ron Paul's platform. Paul may very well adopt it as his platform to gain TeaSipper's vote! You're not even smart enough to mask your ugliness. Typical Republican.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
1pheasant1 says:
by ProudWhiteTexan June 15, 2011 3:52 PM EDT

I am so glad that God has brought fourth Michelle Bachmann to rule in these critical last days. She proudley lives for Jesus and what is right unlike the disgraseful porch monkey.

*********************************

America sees that racism is the motivating factor behind the Republican/Tea Party. ProudWhiteTexan is a typical supporter and voice of their Party. Nice job, Republicans! You must be so proud.
reply
1pheasant1 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
By the way, you may want to open a dictionary and look up the words forth, proudly, and disgraceful. Your Texas education has failed you, although you appear to be slightly smarter than George W. Bush.
pr_boxer replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Being Christian won't solve the problems like health care, deficit, Arab spring etc, she's in over her head!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
Justme is completely wrong. The Class War is between the Top 2% and The Other 98%. It was the Wall Street banksters who starting with Reagan who started the War. We the People will finish it, they HAVE to lose.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
Winner and losers in the GOP? That's like asking who won a suicide bombing. Or a nuclear attack. They still have their completely failed cure all of tax cuts. That is exactly what has caused this Second Great Republicon Depression. Complete mentally deficient idiots, the whole lot of them.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
Anyone who defends anyone based on Jesus or religion is a very sick individual indeed. Christianity is being used to justify murder, genocide, brutal occupations and all kinds of racism and crimes against humanity. A prime example was Bushoccio, the leader of the Bush Crime Family. Disgusting sick bunch of fake Christian murderers.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
XPIOLT says:
CBS evidently saw a different debate than I did, I saw Ron Paul wiped the floor with the other candidates. He got more applause and he won the CNN poll after with like 80% but the other socialist network CNN decided to lie about it and said he got 0 votes.
reply
See all 106 Comments
Scroll Left Scroll Right