Political Hotsheet
By

Lucy Madison /

CBS News/ April 26, 2011, 5:00 PM

"Birther" claims debunked in new report

Yet another investigation has determined that, contrary to claims by "birthers," there is no doubt that President Obama was born in the United States.

The latest inquiry into Mr. Obama's birthplace, conducted by CNN in a report that airs tonight on AC360?, concludes that "Obama was born in Hawaii on August 4, 1961. Period."

Doubt surrounding Mr. Obama's American citizenship has been thoroughly debunked by multiple sources since the issue arose on the 2008 campaign trail. Still, the matter has resurfaced in recent months, thanks in large part to Donald Trump's recent "birther"-friendly media blitz, in which he has repeatedly hammered the issue.

And surveys suggest that a significant numbers of Americans -- particularly among Republicans -- believe the claims. In a recent CBS News/New York Times poll, one in four Americans said they thought Mr. Obama was not born in the United States. Among all Republicans, 45 percent said they believe he was born in another country, as did 45 percent of Tea Party supporters.

Similarly, a CNN/Opinion Research Corp. poll taken between March 11-13 indicated that while 75 percent of Americans believe Obama was definitely or probably born in the U.S., more than 40 percent of Republicans thought he definitely or probably was not born in the country.

In an attempt to definitively put the matter to rest, CNN interviewed a number of sources who were able to confirm the validity of the president's birth certificate and provide first-person accounts of the events surrounding his Hawaiian birth.

Dr. Chiyome Fukino, former director of the Hawaii Department of Health, said in an interview with CNN that she had "no doubt" of Mr. Obama's Hawaiian origins.

Fukino, a Republican, said she has on multiple occasions examined Mr. Obama's birth certificate (as opposed to his certification of live birth, which the Obama campaign released to the public in 2008) and found it "absolutely authentic."

"He was absolutely born here in the state of Hawaii," she said, adding that no mention of his religion was made on the certificate. (Trump, in a recent interview, speculated that perhaps the president had not released his birth certificate was it said he was a Muslim.)

Fukino said Mr. Obama's original birth certificate is stored in a vault in the state's Department of Health. According to Hawaiian state law, certain public officials have access to view the document in the event of a "direct and tangible interest." The certification of live birth, however, is the standard document given to any Hawaii resident who requests his or her birth certificate.

The article points out that the president could request to see and make copies of his original birth certificate under the Freedom of Information Act, but notes that the Obama administration believes even that would be ineffective in convincing those who continue to doubt his status.

Dan Nasako, a reporter for the Honolulu Advertiser, addressed the concern that Mr. Obama's family might have faked the birth announcement that appeared in two separate Hawaii newspapers within days of his birth.

"It's not possible," Nakaso told CNN. "Under the system that existed back then, there was no avenue for people to submit information that way. ... The information came directly from the state Department of Health."

Finally, CNN points out that Hawaii Gov. Neil Abercrombie, a Democrat, personally vouches for the president's birth since he was friends with Ann Dunham, Mr. Obama's mother.

"Of course, we had no idea at the time that the future president of the United States was that little boy, that little baby," Abercrombie told CNN.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
259 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Butcer says:
A political maneuver By obama and a very smart one by the way, when the birthers were gaining track with politicians he released it make the gop politcans who were smuching up to the birthers look like tin foil hat crazys

Problem with a group like the birthers, no amount of evidance will satisfy them just like the 911 truthers and kooks of that nature.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
batazoidz says:
Does anyone have one single, solitary provable fact that Obama was born on Hawaii?

ex animo
davidfarrar
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
randyshu says:
Many of these "birthers" are the same people that don't think we went to the moon and think Elvis isn't really dead. Proof means nothing to most of them because it's just the way they are "put together". Conversation with these folks can be quite entertaining...scary that they can vote.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
starving1968-3 says:
by Mmmrng April 27, 2011 10:07 AM EDT
This is so funny!!!

All of the Obama-as-god people on here daily who said that Obama could not do this are all proven as liars!!

All those that claimed he legally could not get a copy of this are all liars!!!






He had to go to the EXTRAORDINARY, EXTREME step of issuing an executive order as president of the United States, and legally compel the Hawaii Department of Health to release it, which is completely against their policy.

Your inability to understand the complex issues, are obviously the reason you consider yourself to be a conservative. You're just not smart enough to be a liberal.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
starving1968-3 says:
by mkbjon April 28, 2011 11:36 AM EDT
That one in four Americans believe this is not **BREAKING NEWS**.






Jon Stewart said it perfectly last night: "This isn't a 'bombshell', it's a 'non-shell'."
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Abigail2004 says:
Hope your lives will be filled with happiness and beautiful children. On this day I remember Princess Diana, your mother's spirit will be with you on your wedding day. I think Princess Diana would be very pleased with your bride. I also think the people will love her as they loved your mother. Have a very happy life together.

Franklin, Louisiana
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mkbjon says:
That one in four Americans believe this is not **BREAKING NEWS**. They are the reason that instructions for steam irons still carry the message "Do not use on clothing while wearing." The pot-stirrers already knew it wasn't true, they just hoped that if they threw enough crap, some of it would stick, or at least muddy the waters. They bet that gullible Americans that were ALREADY eager to believe the worst would fall in lockstep, which to no surprise, they did.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
magik1369 says:
Sadly, many Americans are so low in intelligence that they have not yet developed discernment, the faculty of consciousness that we use to distinguish truth from falsehood. That is why these types of delusional beliefs are readily gobbled up by the soul sick narcissists that dominate the republican party. People at this level of development do not have the intelligence to examine their beliefs to determine if they are true. People at this level do not even care if they are telling the truth or not. These are the "People of the Lie" that Scott Peck wrote about. These are the evil people with hardened, closed hearts that every spiritual tradition warns about. Republicanism is nothing but a manifestation of narcissism, which is spiritual depravity. These types of lies damage people and the USA in general....yet here again...the average republican does not really give a hoot what happens to the USA; they are entirely self centered people only concerned with the aggrandizement of their own shallow, weak egos.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
dasilvak says:
i don't buy it. not a birther but the whole thing just doesn't add up. why didn't he just show it from the get-go? his excuse, because i didn't have to. you are president...you are up to a point answerable to the people...19% of Democrats...your own teammates don't believe you were born here. anyhow, NOW you decide to publish it? BUT the whole thing doesn't matter...he is still president. Americans voted him in because they wanted to show the world how progressive they are. Obama is here and he's staying in office, whether we like it or not. if you don't like it, you never should have voted for him.
reply
timrw46 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I agree with you that at this point it doesn't matter. I would also add that, had I been Obama, I wouldn't have released it either. Give in to knit picking only opens the doors for more. What is it that Trump is saying now?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
DrRowdyAintItGrand says:
Actually this is GREAT! Obama, Sr. is his father which means he was not, is not, and never will be eligible for the job he holds! He should be removed from office IMMEDIATELY! TODAY!
reply
johndevinejr replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Put on your tinfoil hat, take your meds and go to bed.
badrubberdukky replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
No, it doesn't mean that; however, your comment DOES mean that you're an idiot. Congratulations on that.
See all 6 Replies
See all 259 Comments
Scroll Left Scroll Right