Political Hotsheet
By

Brian Montopoli /

CBS News/ March 2, 2011, 5:26 PM

Bachmann to Democrats: Don't tell Americans what light bulbs to buy

Rep. Michele Bachmann, R-Minn. addresses the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in Washington, Thursday, Feb. 10, 2011.

/ Alex Brandon

Minnesota Republican Rep. Michele Bachmann on Tuesday reintroduced the "Light Bulb Freedom of Choice Act," a bill to repeal a 2007 law mandating that incandescent light bulbs be phased out.

"The government has no business telling an individual what kind of light bulb to buy," she said in a news release Wednesday. "In 2007, Congress overstepped its bounds by mandating that only 'energy efficient' light bulbs may be sold after January 1, 2012. This mandate has sweeping effects on American families and businesses and needs serious consideration before taking effect."

Bachmann says the mandate should only stay in place is (1) there is proof that alternate bulbs save consumers money, (2) there is proof that alternate bulbs significantly reduce carbon dioxide emissions and (3) that it's shown that alternate bulbs "would not lead to a health risk for consumers, particularly those in hospitals, schools, day care centers and nursing homes."

The bill isn't the first "nanny state" critique to come from Bachmann, who said with regard to the IRS making breast pumps eligible for tax breaks: "To think that government has to go out and buy my breast pump - you want to talk about nanny state, I think we just got a new definition."

Bachmann, founder of the House Tea Party Caucus and a potential GOP presidential candidate, has also gone after Michelle Obama's campaign to reduce childhood obesity, which she casts as "very consistent with where the hard left is coming from."

House Republicans have already taken advantage of their newfound power to dial back some of Democrats' environmental initiatives. This week, foam plastic coffee cups reappeared in Congressional cafeterias after a four year absence, the result of new Republican Speaker John Boehner moving to reverse much of former Democratic Speaker Nancy Pelosi's "Greening the Capitol" initiative.

Pelosi had introduced compostable cups, forks and knives into the Congressional cafeterias, a cause of consternation for some customers who complained that the cutlery broke easily. She also introduced compact florescent lighting, healthier food and energy-efficient vending machines to the Capitol.

The most controversial part of Pelosi's initiative was the decision to convert the last coal-powered power plant in Washington to cleaner burning fuel, which Boehner has not moved to reverse. The speaker has also not changed any of the anti-smoking rules that Pelosi instituted despite the fact that he is an unapologetic smoker.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
198 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
TigerLily1945 says:
Dear Ms Bachmann..... Where is your science degree? Do you have one? If not, please stop taking the very breath of life from my grandchildren by putting back the very poluters we fight hard to eliminate. I am a Republican, Conservative and most of all a human living on this planet. I changed all of my light bulbs over 7 years ago with the new bulbs and have not had to change any of them. My electric bill went down over $30 dollars and has not risen. I change out all of my Christmas decorations to LED's and reduced my electric bill significatantly. Now having said that, I am a responsible person who takes the planet seriously..... but many do not and think that it is some one else responsibility to take of it..... ARE YOU ONE OF THEM? Sometimes we need laws to make the irresponsible humans to comply for the sake of the rest of us...

If you want to save the laws and budget of theis country, then I suggest that you and your family give back the subsidies you have taken from the American people to run your farm and help the poor buy the bulbs they need to light their lives up and you and your family can work your farm the way many of us have to work every day....... the hard way with no government hand outs........

I find it laughable that with all the problems this country has before it that you take on the light bulbs and breast pumps... go to work Ms Backmann and do the job that is before you and stop looking for the lint in your naval.......
reply
san850 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
great post...!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mi_opinion says:
Thank goodness we have a politician addressing the pressing social needs of the people.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RedWings_ninety_one says:
The government telling us what we can and can't buy...sound familiar? I believe that the last time that it happened to this extent, these words were written:

"When, in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people..."

When did it become OK for the government that was established to escape tyranny and oppression from another government to resort back to exactly what we escaped from in the first place? This is tyranny and oppression of a different sort.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RedWings_ninety_one says:
dinkydog1,
Nice one...but it worked fine in other fixtures.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
formrusmcsgt says:
Bachmann says the mandate should only stay in place is (1) there is proof that alternate bulbs save consumers money, (2) there is proof that alternate bulbs significantly reduce carbon dioxide emissions and (3) that it's shown that alternate bulbs "would not lead to a health risk for consumers, particularly those in hospitals, schools, day care centers and nursing homes."
---
Even if provided what she seeks, she would dismiss it as "voodoo" science.

This broad is past daft......
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cbs3200 says:
by _-_One_American_-_ March 3, 2011 2:34 PM EST
Liberals need daily spoonfeeding and scripted breathing instructions from the government to survive.
And they try to make fun of Michelle Bachmann for thinking on her own.
==========================================================
Bachmann is known for many things.
Thinking is not one of them.
Maybe you, Barbara, and Sarah could go on tour ... as the THREE B1TCHES ...
I can hear the argument now .... NO, I AM THE DUMBEREST .....
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
southpaw99 says:
Can you imagine this idiot as President?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
erasmus111 says:
I'm stocking up on the incandescent bulbs. And when they run out, I guess it will be candlelight for me. When they can come out with something NON-TOXIC, I will buy them.

I did start to buy the CFLs, but when I found out you had to wear a hazmat suit to clean them up when they broke, that was the end of that. I did some research on them and found out they put off very dirty electricity and people were getting sick from them. You can't sit too close to them. That is the OPEN coil ones. Apparently the better ones are the closed ones. They look similar to the incandescent ones. BUT, they are still toxic.

Soooo, then I heard that the LED lights were good. I phoned and asked some idiot at Home Depot if they were toxic and he said "no" (which is the same thing they told me about the CFLs). But again, I did some research on them, and they are toxic. No mercury, but loaded with heavy metals. They too put off a gas and can cause liver and kidney damage. And you have to wear a hazmat suit to clean them up too. : ) Those bulbs ran anywhere from $35 to $50 (in Canada). They last around 22 years. I would have gladly spent that if only they were NON-TOXIC!

Of course in that bit of research I found that my LED TV is Toxic! What now?? Of course it doesn't give off radiation, so that's one good thing. : )
reply
MissMeYetAbdullah replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
So is your LED flashlight and the headlights on your boss' BMW. So is sucking on an exhaust pipe. Jeez, find an issue.
Mozart1220 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You do realize that every flourecent bulb ever used has mercury in it right? I suppose you have no thermometers in your house either. EVERYTHING can be "toxic" if you misuse it. Where did you learn to be so paranoid?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
northpark2 says:
What was Nancy Reagan telling me to do all those years? How does this lady feel about 8-tracks?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
lighthouse10 says:
About the unpublicised industrial politics behind the USA ban on simple incandescent light bulbs
http://ceolas.net
with documentation and copies of official communications
.
reply
See all 198 Comments