Political Hotsheet
By

Brian Montopoli /

CBS News/ February 14, 2011, 5:11 PM

Sarah Palin Gets Facts Wrong in Budget Critique

Getty Images

Sarah Palin has turned to Facebook and Twitter to criticize President Obama's 2012 budget proposal. Here's what she wrote on Twitter: "Here's how minuscule the White House's $775 million a year cuts are: less than 1/10 of 1% of this year's budget deficit."

And on Facebook: "If you want to know how minuscule their proposed $775 million-a-year budget 'cuts' really are, please look at this chart. The proposed cuts are so insignificant - less than 1/10 of 1% of this year's $1.65 trillion budget deficit - that they are essentially invisible on the pie chart. That speaks volumes about today's budget."

Palin links in both places to a chart posted on The Blaze, Glenn Beck's website, five days ago - before the budget proposal came out. It uses an op-ed by White House Budget Director Jacob Lew to suggest that Mr. Obama was proposing to cut $775 million from the budget, and goes on to mock that amount as insignificant.

The problem? Lew wrote in his op-ed that he was only discussing "a small fraction of the scores of cuts" in the budget proposal, not the total proposed cuts, as a Democratic official pointed out to Ben Smith. Now, it's difficult to quantify the exact total of those first year cuts, and there is new spending that actually increases the deficit projection for 2012. But the cuts themselves are certainly more than Palin suggests: there are $2.5 billion in cuts to the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program alone, for example. Smith writes that the proposed cuts, in total, add up to about $75 billion.

There is no problem with Palin criticizing the cuts as too small, of course. But the simple fact is that she is using an incorrect figure as the basis of her critique.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
302 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Jeanne256 says:
Why does this not surprise me.? PLEASE.. It is IGNORE SARAH PALIN MONTH.. PLEASE CBS... PLEASE
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
edeltraud-2009 says:
Palin s Mouth neat to be Muzzle at stah s open 24 /7 .this Women is really stupid
reply
JV1970 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
edeltraud-2009 can't even type a sentence that makes sense but, yet they have the gall to call someone else stupid!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
edeltraud-2009 says:
Palin s Mouth neat to be Muzzle at stah s open 24 /7 .this Women is really stupid
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
CarloCaraluzzo says:
The great thing is that she is such a poster child for modern Republicans. And she is not the only example. Reagan was lucid only about half the time during his second term, Baby Bush hardly could open his mouth without putting his foot in it and lets not even get started on Christine Odonnell, who didnt know the First Amendment of the Constitution.
I just dont get why anyone is paying attention to her. She was a laughing stock in 2008 and has done nothing to improve her image ever since. No party will back her, she has zero experience governing anything, especially since she quit the only political job she ever had two years in and one of those was spent on the campaign trail.
Again, why is this none issue being given press space? She had her 15 mintues, we were all entertained, now trot out the dancing dogs.
reply
slappy_mcghee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
She had her 15 mintues, we were all entertained, now trot out the dancing dogs.
========
Or dancing daughters.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Birdman04 says:
She is bad for business. My business. It is nothing personal, I choose not to respect those that do not fulfill their sworn obligations.

People can make all the excuses they want to justify her actions but it doesn't change the simple fact that a person of integrity steps up to the plate, brings their best game and fights till their last breath when the going gets tough. That simple concept like a gentle breeze flies right over the heads of most people. That is a fact. It is not personal.

It is simply business and these values should apply to everyone. Those that feel the need to defend the people of that nature are in fact lacking in self esteem and just plain good common sense.
reply
edeltraud-2009 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
She is nothing but low Life Trash .that includes her Husband .doing Porno in the Past .that is the Reason the laying low now .that Women is a Nut case
linkicon reporticon emailicon
slappy_mcghee says:
by san850 February 15, 2011 7:43 PM EST
Now JV that's funny! And I didn't think you had a sense of humor. Please explain, though, why Katie Couric would need to "apologize" to Palin? You do realize that it was Sarah Palin who could not give sensible answers to Couric's questions, right? You know, the one about Supreme Court decisions for instance? Why should Couric apologize for Palin's incompetence?? Please explain.

========

I can see Couric now: "Gee, Mrs. Palin, I am SO sorry for asking you simple questions, like what you read, and what your favorite SCOTUS ruling is. We'll stick to asking you which brand of applesauce you like, if you can handle that...."


.
reply
slappy_mcghee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I'm pretty sure Obama could answer what he reads, or his fav SCOTUS case, Prosperity, don't you? I've never liked a politician, but rarely have I seen one as mind-numbingly stupid as Palin.
CarloCaraluzzo replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ProsperityBeginsIn2012 the woman was asked one time, while she was running for vp and she couldnt answer. Are you telling me she needs a teleprompter to know what her job duties are?
See all 6 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
slappy_mcghee says:
by JV1970
slappy_mcghee Yes, I'm aware of that but I'm also aware of many Republicans and conservatives who do!

======

It's a minority. Most Repubs and conservatives want nothing to do with her.
reply
JV1970 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
That's just your opinion! You don't know that to be a fact! All you see is the polls. You won't know if it's a fact until the primaries are over if she decides to run!
erasmus111 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
by JV1970 February 16, 2011 2:00 AM EST
That's just your opinion! You don't know that to be a fact! All you see is the polls. You won't know if it's a fact until the primaries are over if she decides to run!


Why does every single sentence have to end in an exclamation mark?!!!!!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
larrryshrine says:
For all you Palin defenders, would you give Obama the same pass if he made a similar mistake? I didn't think so. You would excoriate him and call him names.
reply
JV1970 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
He has made similar mistakes and, yes, you liberals and CBS gave him the same pass! In fact when Obama makes a mistake CBS says very little, if anything about it and "kills" the story and takes it off their website as soon as possible. They let stories about Palin's mistakes run for days and sometimes even weeks on their website.
slappy_mcghee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You say "you liberals" like you think everyone who dislikes Palin is a lib.

You ARE aware that many many Repubs and conservatives want NOTHING to do with her, don't you?
See all 6 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
slappy_mcghee says:
by JV1970
That doesn't seem like a "quitter" to me!

==========

You have pretty low standards, then.
reply
JV1970 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
That's YOUR opinion! Your opinion doesn't matter any more than mine does! I told the truth, though, and you and I both know it!
slappy_mcghee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
You didn't tell the truth any more than I did.
See all 4 Replies
linkicon reporticon emailicon
JV1970 says:
You liberals can say what you will about Sarah but the only thing that she is wrong about was the amount of the budget cuts. She is right that they aren't drastic enough even the cuts that President Obama announced. The information that she was given is old and not accurate. That is the only thing she's wrong about.

Also I'm going to remind you people who continue to call her a quitter that she is still around and standing after over two years of the worst verbal assaults that I've ever seen anyone take in all of my 58 years of living! A little over a month ago she was being called a murderer in these comment boards. She also received death threats by the hundreds!

Her children have been verbally attacked and ridiculed both in these boards and on twitter and facebook and by every late night "comedian" in the country. Sarah, herself, has been sued, threatened, accused, and called stupid, and an idiot and called every filthy name there is in the dictionary and some new ones that aren't in the dictionary yet.

She has withstood all of that for the last two years and hasn't disappeared back to Alaska yet! She could have just gone back to Alaska after the 2008 election never to be heard from again but she hasn't! That doesn't seem like a "quitter" to me!
reply
slappy_mcghee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I'm not a liberal, and still find her to be an idiot of staggering proportions.
JV1970 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It's still just as I told you in my comment to you above, that's YOUR opinion and your opinion doesn't matter any more than mine does!
See all 4 Replies
See all 302 Comments