Lou Dobbs: I Never Hired Illegal Immigrants
Lou Dobbs.
/ CBSFormer CNN talk show host Lou Dobbs, who is known for his hard line on illegal immigration, today denied that he has ever hired illegal immigrants.
"I have never, nor has The Dobbs Group at any time, hired an illegal immigrant," Dobbs said on his radio show this afternoon.
Dobbs was responding to a story in the Nation magazine alleging that he "has relied for years on undocumented labor for the upkeep of his multimillion-dollar estates and the horses he keeps for his 22-year-old daughter."
The story in the liberal magazine alleges that at least five undocumented immigrants worked in Dobbs' gardens and in stables where his family's horses were cared for.
Dobbs, who called the story a "fairly typical hit piece, a smear piece," interviewed the reporter behind the story, Isabel Macdonald, on the radio show. He repeatedly asked Macdonald if he or his company had ever hired illegal immigrants.
Macdonald eventually allowed that Dobbs and his company had not - but she said that his contractors had done so. She pressed Dobbs on why he had not checked the status of the workers.
Dobbs, who was calm throughout the interview, responded that he does not have the standing to check the status of anyone - and said Macdonald sounded like a "nativist" for asking him to do so. He insisted that he wanted to have a friendly conversation with Macdonald despite her "outrageous claims," and said she was trying to "deflect and avoid" his questions.
The two discussed the details of the article, and Macdonald indicated that she believed Dobbs was trying to distract from the main point of the piece, which is titled "Lou Dobbs, American Hypocrite" - that Dobbs employed (albeit indirectly) illegal immigrants even as he railed against them publicly.
"You have actually contradicted not one single claim that was made in that article," Macdonald said, adding: "Your listeners deserve to know the truth."
Dobbs said in an interview with the Associated Press before the show that the article is "a political assault" based on a lie. He accused Macdonald during the interview of putting out a story that has been "used by the left wing press as a hammer on me."
"I was gonna take the day off, but sometimes circumstances overwhelm those plans, and this is one of those days," he said as the show began.
Popular in Politics
- Senators: U.S. must take "more decisive" military action in Syria
- Obama and Berlin: Faded echoes meet new realities
- Immigration reform would cut deficit, analysis shows 79 Comments
- House Republicans pass 20-week limit on abortions 216 Comments
- Smooth, on-time Obamacare rollout no sure thing: GAO
- Obama renews push for a nuclear disarmament legacy
- Bill Ayers: Obama should be tried for war crimes
- Snowden: U.S. gov't destroyed my chance for fair trial
I would also suggest this is a "Catch 22." Had Mr. Dobbs inquired about the immigrant status, the left would have called him a racist (a charge used by many liberals against conservatives).
When you make outragous statements
you subject yourself to nit picking of opponents.
In this case they are apparantly correct.
Sadly dobber performed poorly as would be expected for an aloof arrogant mouthpiece.
When one runs to defend ones self as the great and mighty dobber did in this article, it leads to Shakespear, "Methinks thou dost protest too much."
Hence admission of guilt.
Hang him...."Judge Roy Bean" the law west of the Pecos.
Similarly, O-cratic operatives purposefully out, for future jail time and deportation, a young mother who, to the advantage of the operative, not the young mother, admits she is here illegally and has committed fraud to get the job she was paid over $23/Hr to work for 9 years.
In Self-service, laying her out as willfully committing fraud and breaking US laws. For what purpose or advantage, one would ask, surely not hers!
Now it seems a East coast version of outing dozens of illegal?s, tricked to freely admit, once again, not to their advantage, that they ALL are illegal law breakers.
So which is worst to be an anti-illegal immigration advocate who perhaps is indirectly a hypocrite, or to be directly a pretender of pro illegal immigrant advocacy, willing to out illegal?s, to publicly admit either fraud and or law breaking, or both, putting them clearly in the bulls eye of paying the price alone for the sole benefit of these false advocates.
Also, none of the "East Coast" illegals got outed. The Nation didn't use their real names. Time will tell how Whitman's housekeeper fares. I bet her chances are a lot better now that she's at least got a spotlight and a high-profile voice rather than being just another anonymous schmoe waiting to get picked up by ICE.