September 2, 2010 2:41 PM

Jan Brewer's Cringe-Worthy Debate Opening Statement

By
Brian Montopoli
Topics
Campaign 2010

Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer gave what can only be described as a cringe-worthy opening statement in her debate against Democratic opponent Terry Goddard last night.

Politico's Ben Smith, who picked the video up off YouTube, wrote that Brewer's performance "reflects either an amazing lack of preparation, or sheer panic."

Check out the statement at left.

As for the rest of the debate: Brewer, a Republican whose popularity in her state and nationwide shot upward after she signed Arizona's controversial immigration measure S.B. 1070, seemed to recover after her disastrous opening, sparring with Goddard on that issue as well as the economy, as the Arizona Republic reports.

She boasted of balancing the budget of a state once on the verge of bankruptcy by cutting 2.2 billion in spending - though, as the Republic notes, the state is facing a $700 million budget shortfall.

"It has been a tough row to hoe, but I got the job done," she said. Goddard, the Arizona attorney general hoping to unseat Brewer as governor, responded that Arizona has lost more jobs than have been created during Brewer's tenure.

On immigration, Goddard argued that S.B. 1070 would do little to secure the border; Brewer countered that the bill forced the federal government to focus on the issue, and suggested it had resulted in the deployment of more National Guard troops.

He also called out Brewer for saying that "law enforcement agencies have found bodies in the desert either buried or just lying out there that have been beheaded," a claim for which she has provided no evidence.

"You need to stop saying things that are untrue, that defame our state, like there are beheadings in the desert," he said. "Our men and women of law enforcement have done a great job, and it's time we recognize and thank them rather than tear them down."

Pressed by reporters after the debate, Brewer refused to recant the beheadings claim.

There were actually two other candidates participating in the debate, Barry Hess and Larry Gist, but the conversation was dominated by Goddard and Brewer.

Goddard once looked like a strong challenger to Brewer, but her decision to sign S.B. 1070 has catapulted her to a strong advantage in the race; a Rasmussen poll late last month found Brewer leading by almost 20 percentage points.


Add a Comment See all 151 Comments
by whatithink-2009 September 9, 2010 1:12 PM EDT
Ironic. The majority of people she is trying to deport speak better English than she does (plus a second language).
Reply to this comment
by afmcalax September 9, 2010 1:12 PM EDT
My God, please get some intelligence. The bill she signed did absolutely nothing to stem illegal immigration. At best it pushed it to other states; at worst it just drove it further underground. Illegal immigration is stopped at the border not once it is walking downtown streets. If she really wanted to do something, she shoud have called up the Arizona National Guard and placed them on the border and the sent the bill to the Federal government. That would be a real plan instead of grandstanding.

As to the true facts that Arizona is still reeling from huge Republican made deficits and cannot generate the creation of new jobs should come as no surprise as the Bush era from 2000 to 2008 saw a LOSS of total private sector jobs, a decrease in worker wages, an explosion of medical costs, and the destruction of retirement income and house equity. That is the real truth about Republican economic planning.
Reply to this comment
by gruven13777 September 9, 2010 12:16 PM EDT
Yuck it up all you moonbat chuckleheads.

She will be Arizona's next Governor and SB1070 will be upheld by the SCOTUS.

Just sit back and watch.
Reply to this comment
by jimatmadison September 9, 2010 12:16 PM EDT
Typical Tea Party Republican.

Even the gubernatorial candidates are 'low information voters'.

Yikes!
Reply to this comment
by gruven13777 September 9, 2010 12:16 PM EDT
Yuck it up all you moonbat chuckleheads.

She will be Arizona's next Governor and SB1070 will be upheld by the SCOTUS.

Just sit back and watch.
Reply to this comment
by afmcalax September 9, 2010 12:16 PM EDT
My God, please get some intelligence. The bill she signed did absolutely nothing to stem illegal immigration. At best it pushed it to other states; at worst it just drove it further underground. Illegal immigration is stopped at the border not once it is walking downtown streets. If she really wanted to do something, she shoud have called up the Arizona National Guard and placed them on the border and the sent the bill to the Federal government. That would be a real plan instead of grandstanding.

As to the true facts that Arizona is still reeling from huge Republican made deficits and cannot generate the creation of new jobs should come as no surprise as the Bush era from 2000 to 2008 saw a LOSS of total private sector jobs, a decrease in worker wages, an explosion of medical costs, and the destruction of retirement income and house equity. That is the real truth about Republican economic planning.
Reply to this comment
by whatithink-2009 September 9, 2010 12:16 PM EDT
Ironic. The majority of people she is trying to deport speak better English than she does (plus a second language).
Reply to this comment
by jimatmadison September 9, 2010 12:15 PM EDT
Typical Tea Party Republican.

Even the gubernatorial candidates are 'low information voters'.

Yikes!
Reply to this comment
by AZ_Independent September 9, 2010 12:15 PM EDT
Besides supplying no evidence about "beheadings," Ms. Brewer also did not have any facts to support her claim that she brought thousands of jobs to Arizona. Is it possible that the "jobs" she is referring to were a result of federal stimulus funds? Ms. Brewee and her fellow Republican "conservatives" continue to wail against the federal government, but then are among many throughout out the country who take credit for any positive impact federal dollars have in their states.
Reply to this comment
by texas_liberal September 9, 2010 12:15 PM EDT
cript keeper brewer stumbled horribly.
Reply to this comment
See all 151 Comments
.

Follow Political Hotsheet

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook