Political Hotsheet
By

Brian Montopoli /

CBS News/ August 3, 2010, 1:27 PM

Fred Thompson: Renew the Bush Tax Cuts

Former GOP presidential candidate, actor and senator Fred Thompson is appearing in a League of American Voters ad pressing Congress to renew the Bush tax cuts, which are set to expire at the end of the year.

Check out Thompson's pitch at left. "Folks, America's economy is struggling, and Congress is about to make it a whole lot worse," he says, warning of the "massive, automatic tax increase" to come if the cuts aren't extended.

Thompson suggests that income taxes could then increase "10 percent or more," while taxes on capital gains will increase 30 percent and taxes on dividends will more than double.

The effects of not renewing the cuts, he says, will be "devastating."

The Obama administration and most Congressional Democrats want to extend the Bush tax cuts for individuals making less than $200,000 and couples making less than $250,000, but let them lapse for those earning more than those levels.

Republicans and some Democrats (including three senators) are pushing for an extension of all the cuts, and have argued that government revenue would be higher if that happens because lower taxes spur economic growth.

According to Fox News' Chris Wallace, extending the cuts for high earners would cost the government $678 billion over 10 years. Many Republican-leaning voters, particularly those associated with the Tea Party movement, have expressed frustration about the size of the deficit and national debt.

Under the Obama administration plan, the 0.7 percent of married, jointly-filing Americans who make more than $373,650 would see their marginal tax rate increase from 35 percent to 39.6 percent, according to the Tax Policy Center. For the 1.2 percent making between $209,251 and $373,650, it would increase from 33 percent to 36 percent.

The Thompson ad is currently running on Fox News Channel and elsewhere.

"A massive tax increase in the midst of the worst recession since the Great Depression would be cataclysmic to our nation's broken economy," Bob Adams, executive director of the League of American Voters, said in a release touting the spot.

© 2010 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
22 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ec1964 says:
People, please get your facts straight!

Actual effects of letting Bush tax cuts for rich expire
A non-partisan Congressional analysis gets beyond the rhetoric ("Obama is increasing taxes") and into the reality of what allowing the Bush cuts to expire for the most wealthy will do to those at the top -- and to the rest of us. Bottom line: the rich will still pay a lot less than they were paying in 2001 and the rest of us will stay at the lower post-2001 rates.

Taxpayers with income of more than $1 million for 2011 would still receive on average a tax cut of about $6,300 compared with what they would have paid under rates in effect until 2001, according to the analysis, which was prepared by the Joint Committee on Taxation at the request of the Democratic majority on the House Ways and Means Committee.

That compares, however, with the roughly $100,000 average tax cut that households with more than $1 million in income would receive under current rates. Filers with taxable income of $500,000 to $1 million would still get on average a tax cut of $6,700 compared with pre-2001 rates, according to the data from the tax analysts. But that compares with roughly $17,500 if the top Bush tax rates were maintained.
If the president gets his way, in 2011 the top two income tax rates ? now 33 percent and 35 percent ? would revert to the levels before the Bush administration, 36 percent and 39.6 percent, respectively. But the four lower rates would remain 10 percent, 15 percent, 25 percent and 28 percent. For some taxpayers earning up to $250,000, the top marginal rate would remain 33 percent. ...NYT

If, on the other hand, the Republicans were to get their way and the scheduled expiration of the Bush tax cuts were extended across the board, the already burdensome national debt of the Bush years would increase by $3.8 trillion.

In other words, the party that screams the loudest about debt is also fighting to expand that debt. The same hypocrites also yell about what "expiring" the tax cuts for the richest will do to small business. Huh?

...They say Mr. Obama is about to spring a big tax increase on many small-business owners who file their taxes as individuals. Analyses from the Joint Committee on Taxation and the Tax Policy Center, a nonpartisan research organization, show that less than 3 percent of filers with small-business income pay at the top two income tax rates, and many of those are doctors and lawyers in partnerships.

The analysis comes from the Joint Committee on Taxation.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kellie1234321 says:
Why do they want to further tax the people that provide jobs? People need jobs in this country and small business is the key. If they continue to tax them, they will not be able to hire more workers. I know this, my family has a small business and we only have so much money to work with. We will have to cut staff if we are taxed more. I wish they would listen to the people. People are getting fed up with the way our Government is not listening...they will show them this Nov. and in 2012! Obama needs to quit blaming Bush for everything. He needs to take responsibility and do something good for this country! Quit spending our $$$$$!!!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kevjustice says:
THOMPSON IS LIKE THAT ROCK GROUP MFSB(GET IT OR GOOGLE IT).
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
KatBlue60 says:
You know, I agree with a lot of comments that I've read, but I do believe that Tax Cuts should be issued to all people. My husband and I make $32,000. per year (retired, and disabled, and I am willing to pay taxes based on my income. Those with higher incomes should pay taxes on their higher income. Job's being sent overseas will happen regardless. They already have and do. Job's will be cut when the rich get richer and greedy for more money. If we weren't paying for all the illegals in this country, the government could begin paying down the deficit. Everyone is walking around with blinders on.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cherielyn43 says:
I believe everyone should have the tax cuts remain. The high earners are the people that normally create the jobs. I am sick and tired of this admin taking everything they can from us. Then they spend it for such ridiculous things as cocaine for monkeys. Wow.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RobAla says:
Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner stuck by the Obama administration's plan to let the Bush tax cuts expire for the wealthiest Americans at the end of the year.

That tax cheat Geithner is only doing his master's bidding, and President Obama wants to expand the federal government at the expense of businesses and individual taxpayers. A n expiration of the tax cuts would redirect money from the economy and into Washington. We need jobs. We need to grow economic growth, so that jobs can be created in private businesses.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tom7001 says:
Well, the republican big lie,? tax breaks for the rich create jobs? is being abandonded. Only because you can look around and see after 10 years of tax breaks, the job market is in the toilet, and the deficit has swelled. Greenspan,and a host of economist finally admit to that fraud. Tax breaks should remain the same for people making less than $250,000 , and big increases for above. Which is pretty much Obamas program???..Social security just needs the cap on it raised to about $110,000, and it will be solvent!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
pake3 says:
A person hauling in $373,650 per year has a networth of at least $10,000,000. A marginal tax rate of 39.6% equals $147,965.40. That's .01% of their networth, but with tax deductions, deferments, etc. and he's paying a lot less.

What's a person hauling in $373,650 per year going to spend his money on? Why, more investments to make more money and on more extravagant toys! So what if he has to stay at the Plaza instead of the Four Seasons!


$373,650 would see their marginal tax rate would increase from 35 percent to 39.6
reply
Mortar_29 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
It is none of YOUR business what they would spend THEIR money on.

Why is it moral to "soak the rich"? Why is it moral to take a higher PERCENTAGE of their income than anyone else? After all, their money...whether it is $50,000 or $5million, is still theirs.

What do you think a person does with their money?
Mortar_29 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Another thing you dont get. That guy making $373,650 per year is probably a small business owner. He probably has the company's income and his personal income intertwined. So, you go and take almost 40% of his income, and you practically starve his business.

And if he can stay afloat, you make sure that he doesnt expand or hire new people.

My wife and I are in this very same boat. With taxes set to increase next year, plus the Obamacare boondoggle, we are not expanding as we would have...and we are shipping two jobs overseas to India in order to make up for some of these tax increases.

Now, who lost out? Me? Nope...I am still bringing into my house as much or more than I was. The two employees I would have hired to expand never got hired. Thus, two more people off of unemployment...AND providing taxes. And the two jobs we are shipping overseas (thus two of our employees will lose their jobs at the end of the year) will now have to draw unemployment AND wont pay taxes.

See where this is going?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kevjustice says:
THOMPSON REMINDS ME OF THAT ROCK GROUP MFSB(I DON'T MEAN MOTHER, FATHER, SISTER, BROTHER).
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
msimamaji says:
What can you expect from a greedy billionaire?
And how does Fred Thompson propose to balance the budget? He wants to eliminate Social Security and Medicare, forcing millions of senior citizens out of their homes where they will die penniless on street corners. Of course, Thompson conveniently forgets that we pay into social security and Medicare, so he is really stealing the money that millions of people put away for their retirement, so he can ride around in a fancy jet. The same applies also to 401K's. If Fred Thompson had his way, everyone would put their money into 401K's. Then Fred Thompson and his buddies would steal that money so they could buy new mansions.
The rich are unpatriotic, anit-American parasites. They off-shore American jobs to other countries. They want abolish minimum wage laws, so that Americans will work for $ 2 a day. They want to eliminate unions and all worker safety provisions, so that thousands of workers will be killed and maimed each year. They want to import "guest workers" whom they treat as slaves. Now they are demonizing "illegal immigrants", but when they have a gala fund-raising banquet, whom do they hire to do all the kitchen work - the same illegal aliens they love to hate. The rich have had tax holidays for years. All they do is start wars, buy elections, hire lobbyists, poison the air and the water supply and murder their employees. They don't deserve a tax break. They must be made to pay for the death, destruction and damage they have wrought upon the American people.
reply
See all 22 Comments