Political Hotsheet
By

Michelle Levi /

CBS News/ March 23, 2010, 1:49 PM

Stupak: Randy Neugebauer Should Apologize on House Floor for "Baby Killer" Remark

Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Mich.) called on Texas Republican Rep. Randy Neugebauer to apologize on the House floor for calling out "baby killer" during Stupak's speech on Sunday night in support of the health care bill which passed.

"Randy did call and apologize. He said it wasn't directed towards me personally. Well, if that's the case then it must have been directed to the rest of the members of the House. I would hope Randy would just clear it up and take to the House of the Floor and say, 'look I didn't mean to offend anyone. If I did, I apologize,' Stupak said on "Washington Unplugged," CBSNews.com's daily politics Web show.

"That's what he should do and that's what I would expect him to do," he told moderator John Dickerson.

The Michigan Democrat admitted he has received a "mixed reaction" from his constituents after negotiating an 11th hour deal with White House officials in order to limit federal funding for abortions in the health care legislations, paving the way for his "yes" vote.

"It's sort of been a mixed reaction. It's always sort-of a toss-up in my district," he said.

He did not hide his enthusiasm for the language of the executive order he negotiated. "It's very clear. The Hyde language, which does not allow federal funding for abortions will apply to this new law," Stupak told Dickerson.

"Some people say this piece of paper isn't worth it, but I would remind them that in 2007 when George W. Bush signed the executive order to prevent stem-cell research these groups that are criticizing it, they applauded it, they welcomed it and now President Obama's going to sign an executive order once again protecting life and somehow it's not worth the paper it's written on. You can't have it both ways," he explained.

CBS News' Jill Jackson notes that this executive order does not have to be renewed annually, as the Hyde amendment must, but that any president, including President Obama, can overturn that rule.

"The president said he will implement the Hyde restrictions. Makes it applicable to this law. This executive order goes to the law creating this health care plan. It doesn't apply back to the annual appropriation process. So the Hyde restrictions would apply to this law. Not the annual appropriations.," Stupak explained.

Finally, Stupak explained that the political implications of his vote do not overshadow the importance of his vote to pass health care.

"The political downside, look if for some reason you lose your seat I'd rather lose my seat over something like this, a good piece of health care legislation that I believe in and if I lose my seat over it well maybe it was worth it," he said.

Watch the full interview above. "Washington Unplugged" appears live on CBSNews.com each weekday at 12:30 p.m. ET. Click here to check out previous episodes.

© 2010 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
13 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rocketjl says:
The guy who has sold out America want an apology on the Hose floor. Since we know the Executive order is worthless, lets stop all this smoke and mirrors about an apology. Was it only the tax payer money for airports in his district or was it something else. No more smoke. He flipped on all the other people that were holding their votes based on his lead. He stabbed them in the back after Obama took him to the WH wood shed. Don't have the feeling he consulted with them on the switch, just jumped on the them as bad guys.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
smoknmirrors says:
I can't be positive, of course, but I think may Randy was trying to revisit his Vietnam Draft Avoidance days. It's quite possible he just liked the sound of those words. Nostalgia being so prized these days.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
hateisafourletterword says:
Some people view it as murder. Others view it as a womens choice. It is as simple as that. So to apologize for your beliefs is a stupid idea.
reply
smoknmirrors replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Maybe what he should apologize for would be what your mama would tell you to apologize for, not your beliefs, but just for interrupting someone while they are speaking. Bad manners are never in style in mama's house.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
pr_boxer says:
"Tecnically", by supporting the bill Stupak did what a Congressman should do, vote for laws to improve the living standards of Americans. He or no law is "killing babies"!

To those who aren't aware of it some insurance policies do and have covered abortion, the law has nothing to do with that.

Try as you may, abortions whether legal or not happen and will continue, the only change outlawing abortions will succeed in is greatly reducing the quality of the medical treatment. Oh! the rich girls will fly to the hospitals in Canada or Sweden for abortions, the poor girls will get them in cheap motels from quacks.Abortions aren't caused by Govt policy, but by social pressures.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Tugud says:
I don't see why Neugebauer should apologize. Technically, by Stupak supporting the bill, he is endorsing the killing of babies.

I tend to find it refreshing when politicians actually speak the truth!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
realbluesky says:
Stupak owes an apology to the American people for betraying them by trying to derail healthcare. I hope the good people of Michigan have the sense to get rid of him in November. He is a low-life hypocrite and deserves to be kicked out of Congress.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
VoteThemOut2010 says:
I don't understand why he would be upset. If baby killer is the worst thing he is called, he is getting off light.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
VoteThemOut2010 says:
I hope Stupak fails at his next job too!
Good Ridance!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
TallyHoh says:
Enjoy your time in the House Bart. You'll be gone soon
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
wfw3536 says:
Stupak should apologize for supporting abortion which is in the health care bill. We all know an executive order cannot over ride a law. Or maybe Stupak isn't that smart.
reply
1notrub11 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I think its the latter.
infmom-2009 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Where EXACTLY in the health care bill does it state federal funding for abortion?
See all 13 Comments