World Watch
February 16, 2010 4:17 AM

Why Taliban Leader's Arrest Matters

By
Tucker Reals
Topics
Terror Monitor
Haroun Mir, a leading expert on the Afghan Taliban movement, tells CBS News the arrest of Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar is "the most important event in the war against the Taliban and the war on terrorism in years."

"This is a significant blow to the Taliban. In the past they have been able to replace leaders, and no doubt they will replace him, but there are not many members of the Quetta Shura who can step into his role," Mir told CBS News producer Ben Plesser in Kabul, referring to the Afghan Taliban by its traditional name.

But the implications of Baradar's arrest for America and its allies in the war against Islamic fundamentalism may be far greater than the tactical victory of nabbing the purported No. 2 commander of the group.

"The real significance is the change in the Pakistani policy," explains Mir.

U.S. and Afghan leaders, "have been criticizing Pakistan for years for allowing the Taliban to move freely between Afghanistan and Pakistan, and now, by arresting Mullah Baradar, they have demonstrated in the strongest way a change in policy."

"Until now the Pakistanis treated the Afghan Taliban as an asset. They have gone after members of the Pakistani Taliban, but they have never — in eight years — arrested any significant member of the Afghan Taliban. Until now."

That apparent shift in policy, says Mr. Mir, is a direct result of "huge pressure" applied by Washington — where officials likely recognized the Pakistani Army's desperate need for funding as a means of leveraging action on the ground.

"They had no choice but to finally start going after the Taliban," says Mir.

If Baradar's arrest does herald a broader crackdown on Taliban militants in the Afghan border region by Pakistani security officials, and a willingness to work more closely in covert operations with American intelligence operatives, that will dramatically affect the militant group's ability to wage attacks.

"The command and control of the Afghan Taliban is destroyed in Pakistan, which is going to make it very difficult for them to operate because they will not be able to go back and forth into Pakistan to receive orders," says Mir.

"The most important thing is that Pakistan is no longer a safe haven for them, so they have to run and hide for their safety, which will make it much harder for them to keep up the fight."

  • Tucker Reals

    Tucker Reals is a senior news editor and overnight site editor for CBSNews.com, based at CBS News' London bureau.

Add a Comment See all 17 Comments
by Bigheader February 16, 2010 1:50 PM EST
This is a huge change. No longer will the Taliban in Pakistan be able to protect Osama Bin Laden with tacit approve from the Pakistani military. All the idiots on this blog are railing about Bush or Obama failed to see the fundamental shift. The paradigm has changed and it had nothing to do with Bush or Cheney, this happened on Obama's watch
.
Reply to this comment
by goldmineman February 16, 2010 1:39 PM EST
Yeah - we'll see. All this MSM cheerleading has me suspect the obama mis-administration is up to something underhanded.
Reply to this comment
by jxknowles February 16, 2010 2:40 PM EST
That, and the new light bulbs. Something's amiss.....hmmmm
by signseeker1717 February 16, 2010 1:09 PM EST
Excellent news! This is MUCH more than the capture of one "politician". The leader of al Queda in Afganistan was also killed recently. And a major coalition offensive (which includes 60% Afghan troops) is now taking place in the Helmand province and (stronghold of the Taliban/poppy-growing/drug traffic that funds terrorism).

Yes, progress is FINALLY being made. New policy IS making a difference.
Reply to this comment
by pensacola8-2009 February 16, 2010 12:52 PM EST
I agree, that getting a qualified replacement will not be easy for the Taliban. There is not institutional method other than by wealth or brutal reputation to ascend into Taliban leadership positions. Since this is a largely undereducated and impoverished body of men, finding the best qualified won't be easy.
Reply to this comment
by excop1949 February 16, 2010 12:48 PM EST
SOME OF THESE BLOGGERS ACT LIKE OBAMA CAPTURED THIS SCUM HIMSELF...I AM QUITE SURE THAT IF THE OPPORTUNITY PRESENTED ITSELF WHILE PRESIDENT BUSH WAS IN OFFICE, OUR BRAVE MEN AND WOMEN IN UNIFORM WOULD NOT HAVE LET THE OL' MULLAH GO WITH A STERN LECTURE ON BEING NICE.
Reply to this comment
by Leaderless February 16, 2010 12:29 PM EST
We being had.
This idiot now can count on eric holder to effort him a worldwide audience and the attention that he needs to continue his quest.....can't really do that from a cave.
eric holder will used our tax dollards to give this idiot the best defense available.....can't think of anything better to waste our tax money on?
eric holder will also used our tax dollards to provide security for this idiot, give him comfortable accomodation and culturally appropriate cuisine......homeless people should be this lucky.
This will show we are better than them right eric? You attack us and we will protect you with our constitution.
There is absolutely no downside for attacking America eric, you are their hero.
Reply to this comment
by jxknowles February 16, 2010 12:53 PM EST
by Clueless February 16, 2010 12:29 PM EST
We being had.

Son, he was arrested in Pakistan, not Pittsburgh. We don't have jurisdiction in Pakistan. That is another country. On the other side of the world. He was arrested in the largest city in Pakistan, not a cave. They have TV stations, satellites, hotels and five star accomodations there.

Eric Holder is the Attorney General for the United States of America. That is not the same as Pakistan. These are all important facts you cannot get from right-wing rant radio. Please, get an education for yourself. It may not be too late.
by Leaderless February 17, 2010 11:00 AM EST
jxknowles, Pakistan is an Asian country with many provinces ranging from modern to primitive. With the population of almost 200 millions, ghani can hide in plain sigh or in a cave when things get too hot.
If you don't think the U.S. won't eventually push Pakistan to hand over ghani, then you're in for an education.
by hillarynow February 16, 2010 12:14 PM EST
oh look! the Obama administration apparently really DOES know what they are doing when it comes to fighting terrorism, who knew? certainly not DICK or Lynn Cheney..
Reply to this comment
by joshbuckner February 16, 2010 11:12 AM EST
I thought we were fighting terrorist networks and Taliban. Did I miss when we declared "war against Islamic fundamentalism"?
Reply to this comment
by ranger2930 February 16, 2010 10:33 AM EST
I love how the media gives Bin Laden unlimited access. I personally am not impressed with anything the dirty S.O.B. has to say. His hatefilled "fatwah's." Let AlJazeera be Osama's propaganda conduit. It's all just bad breath after all.
Reply to this comment
by IzThatSoBad February 16, 2010 6:12 PM EST
we count according to weight? lol
by apostasyusa February 16, 2010 10:32 AM EST
Taliban and Al Qaeda are allies and Bin Laden, the guy who took credit for 9/11, is directly connected to these groups. Taliban and Al Qaeda and other organizations are funding their operations through production of the opium poppy.

So I say finally; these are the fools that hit America. This is where we have world-wide support to root out the fools that did it. Allies are with us, NATO I'm glad that it is our Marines are there to lead the demise of the Taliban and do so with professionalism and high regard for the lives of the civilian population.

As far as the Taliban are concerned they picked their battle when they involved themselves in the crashing of planes against American soil. See, we can't have the best armies in the world if we don't know how to pick our battles. I don't know why the Cheney neo-con Republican warmongers decided to march us into Iraq at the cost of 2 trillion American taxpayer dollars, but at least Obama has shifted the priority to those who deserve to have their doors kicked down.

We can not have a war on terrorism even though our soldiers may die. There is no honor in carpet bombing and military organizations must believe in a universal rule of law to honor the innocent. We must be principled warriors. Taliban and their associated organizations who have committed crimes against us deserve this fight, but not the people who the Taliban cowardly hide behind.

Down with the Taliban...and enough with Dick Cheney and his daughter.
Reply to this comment
See all 17 Comments
.

Follow World Watch

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook